iHaveNet.com
GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012 | United States Current Events
Online Breaking News Headlines Single Source to Headlines Breaking News Current Events Top Stories. Find out what is happening in News & the World. Check out iHaveNet.com for the latest news & current events articles plus Movie Reviews, Wolfgang Puck Recipes, NFL Previews Analysis and Politics. Your Single Source to News Articles, Current Events & Reviews.
  • HOME
  • WORLD
    • Africa
    • Asia Pacific
    • Balkans
    • Caucasas
    • Central Asia
    • Eastern Europe
    • Europe
    • Indian Subcontinent
    • Latin America
    • Middle East
    • North Africa
    • Scandinavia
    • Southeast Asia
    • United Kingdom
    • United States
    • Argentina
    • Australia
    • Austria
    • Benelux
    • Brazil
    • Canada
    • China
    • France
    • Germany
    • Greece
    • Hungary
    • India
    • Indonesia
    • Ireland
    • Israel
    • Italy
    • Japan
    • Korea
    • Mexico
    • New Zealand
    • Pakistan
    • Philippines
    • Poland
    • Russia
    • South Africa
    • Spain
    • Taiwan
    • Turkey
    • United States
  • USA
    • ECONOMICS
    • EDUCATION
    • ENVIRONMENT
    • FOREIGN POLICY
    • POLITICS
    • OPINION
    • TRADE
    • Atlanta
    • Baltimore
    • Bay Area
    • Boston
    • Chicago
    • Cleveland
    • DC Area
    • Dallas
    • Denver
    • Detroit
    • Houston
    • Los Angeles
    • Miami
    • New York
    • Philadelphia
    • Phoenix
    • Pittsburgh
    • Portland
    • San Diego
    • Seattle
    • Silicon Valley
    • Saint Louis
    • Tampa
    • Twin Cities
  • BUSINESS
    • FEATURES
    • eBUSINESS
    • HUMAN RESOURCES
    • MANAGEMENT
    • MARKETING
    • ENTREPRENEUR
    • SMALL BUSINESS
    • STOCK MARKETS
    • Agriculture
    • Airline
    • Auto
    • Beverage
    • Biotech
    • Book
    • Broadcast
    • Cable
    • Chemical
    • Clothing
    • Construction
    • Defense
    • Durable
    • Engineering
    • Electronics
    • Firearms
    • Food
    • Gaming
    • Healthcare
    • Hospitality
    • Leisure
    • Logistics
    • Metals
    • Mining
    • Movie
    • Music
    • Newspaper
    • Nondurable
    • Oil & Gas
    • Packaging
    • Pharmaceutic
    • Plastics
    • Real Estate
    • Retail
    • Shipping
    • Sports
    • Steelmaking
    • Textiles
    • Tobacco
    • Transportation
    • Travel
    • Utilities
  • WEALTH
    • CAREERS
    • INVESTING
    • PERSONAL FINANCE
    • REAL ESTATE
    • MARKETS
    • BUSINESS
  • STOCKS
    • ECONOMY
    • EMERGING MARKETS
    • STOCKS
    • FED WATCH
    • TECH STOCKS
    • BIOTECHS
    • COMMODITIES
    • MUTUAL FUNDS / ETFs
    • MERGERS / ACQUISITIONS
    • IPOs
    • 3M (MMM)
    • AT&T (T)
    • AIG (AIG)
    • Alcoa (AA)
    • Altria (MO)
    • American Express (AXP)
    • Apple (AAPL)
    • Bank of America (BAC)
    • Boeing (BA)
    • Caterpillar (CAT)
    • Chevron (CVX)
    • Cisco (CSCO)
    • Citigroup (C)
    • Coca Cola (KO)
    • Dell (DELL)
    • DuPont (DD)
    • Eastman Kodak (EK)
    • ExxonMobil (XOM)
    • FedEx (FDX)
    • General Electric (GE)
    • General Motors (GM)
    • Google (GOOG)
    • Hewlett-Packard (HPQ)
    • Home Depot (HD)
    • Honeywell (HON)
    • IBM (IBM)
    • Intel (INTC)
    • Int'l Paper (IP)
    • JP Morgan Chase (JPM)
    • J & J (JNJ)
    • McDonalds (MCD)
    • Merck (MRK)
    • Microsoft (MSFT)
    • P & G (PG)
    • United Tech (UTX)
    • Wal-Mart (WMT)
    • Walt Disney (DIS)
  • TECH
    • ADVANCED
    • FEATURES
    • INTERNET
    • INTERNET FEATURES
    • CYBERCULTURE
    • eCOMMERCE
    • mp3
    • SECURITY
    • GAMES
    • HANDHELD
    • SOFTWARE
    • PERSONAL
    • WIRELESS
  • HEALTH
    • AGING
    • ALTERNATIVE
    • AILMENTS
    • DRUGS
    • FITNESS
    • GENETICS
    • CHILDREN'S
    • MEN'S
    • WOMEN'S
  • LIFESTYLE
    • AUTOS
    • HOBBIES
    • EDUCATION
    • FAMILY
    • FASHION
    • FOOD
    • HOME DECOR
    • RELATIONSHIPS
    • PARENTING
    • PETS
    • TRAVEL
    • WOMEN
  • ENTERTAINMENT
    • BOOKS
    • TELEVISION
    • MUSIC
    • THE ARTS
    • MOVIES
    • CULTURE
  • SPORTS
    • BASEBALL
    • BASKETBALL
    • COLLEGES
    • FOOTBALL
    • GOLF
    • HOCKEY
    • OLYMPICS
    • SOCCER
    • TENNIS
  • Subscribe to RSS Feeds EMAIL ALERT Subscriptions from iHaveNet.com RSS
    • RSS | Politics
    • RSS | Recipes
    • RSS | NFL Football
    • RSS | Movie Reviews
GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012
Mallie Jane Kim

HOME > WORLD

 

Fencing off the 2,000 miles of U.S.- Mexico border is not an easy task

In GOP primary politics, the U.S.-Mexico border fence is an immigration litmus test, but an apparently unhelpful one. Experts close to the issue agree that the fence may be a nice symbolic sound bite for candidates to show border security bona fides, but it does little to address the nation's complex immigration quagmire. "It's three quarters symbolic and very expensive," says immigration policy expert Rick Swartz, who helped construct and advocate pro-immigrant legislation since the 1980s. Swartz says fencing has definitely helped curb illegal crossings and drug smuggling in some places, but it's "more promoted as a panacea that it is in fact a panacea."

Nevertheless, some 2012 candidates continue to find political capital in touting the fence.

Former Customs and Border Protection Commissioner W. Ralph Basham last month called the idea of constructing a physical fence along the entire border one of the "dumbest" ideas he was presented with during his tenure. A better way, according to Thad Bingel, a security and intelligence consultant who served as Basham's chief of staff, is a mix of infrastructure, like fencing, combined with people and technology, like sensors and unmanned aircraft. "There's a fundamental misunderstanding about what a fence -- even the triple-layer fencing in San Diego -- actually does for you. All it really does is buy you time," he explains. "None of the fencing is impenetrable. People will eventually dig under it or cut through it or go over it, but it gives you enough time to respond and apprehend them."

Since the border terrain varies so widely, different areas call for different types of fencing, if any, designed to hinder either pedestrian traffic or vehicles. And some areas have a natural fence to slow illegal crossers or smugglers already: mountains and the Rio Grande.

In urban areas like San Diego, Bingel explains, "you have seconds or minutes to respond to an incursion before they disappear into a building or somebody's car and get away," he says, explaining why a fence to block pedestrians is helpful there. But in a rural area, like Arizona's Sonoran Desert, it takes a day or two to walk to a paved road from the border, and a simple vehicle barrier can do the trick. "You've got time to track them and apprehend them at a more convenient point than needing a fence out there that would really be a waste of resources."

And wasting resources is never a popular idea, particularly at a time when federal budgets are tight. In 2009, the Government Accountability Office estimated the cost at $6.5 million per mile for pedestrian fencing and $1.8 million per mile for vehicle fencing. The same report found that there had been 3,363 breaches in the border fence as of May 2009, each costing an average of $1,300 to repair -- that's more than $4 million.

The real immigration problem is far more complex, experts say. Approximately 12 million undocumented immigrants are already in the country and have been for years. Anywhere from one third to one half of those entered legally and overstayed visas, according to estimates by the Government Accountability Office and the Pew Hispanic Center. And illegal border crossings have decreased markedly in the past decade, likely from a combination of increased security, economic doldrums in the United States, and an improved Mexican economy. The border is a just a small part of the problem -- a symptom. And treating a symptom won't cure a disease.

"When you're really making a point that we don't like what's going on in suburban Phoenix," Bingel explains, "building a triple-layer fence down in the west desert of Arizona won't actually do anything to improve the situation."

The push for more fencing at the border, he adds, is like trying to solve yesterday's problem. "The damage was done 10 years ago. It's a matter of interior enforcement now," Bingel says. "In some ways, we're fighting the last war on that, and in some cases a war that's already being fought and won with the additional resources that have actually come since 2003, 2004."

Still, several of the 2012 GOP candidates push the fence idea, or attack Texas Gov. Rick Perry -- who has a comparably moderate immigration record -- for suggesting the fence is a waste of resources, and saying, "If you build a 30-foot wall from El Paso to Brownsville, the 35-foot ladder business gets real good."

Michele Bachmann said she will build the fence, "every mile, every yard, every foot, every inch." Former Godfather's Pizza CEO Herman Cain joked about creating something like an electrified Great Wall of China with an alligator moat, and former Massachusetts Gov. Mitt Romney supports a "high-tech" fence, though he hasn't fleshed out the details.

"It's a preposterous oversimplification, but it's one that has political currency," says Chris Newman, director of the National Day Laborer Organizing Network's legal programs, who thinks focusing the debate on the fence is a harmful and manipulative distraction. "Like most things in the immigration debate, it plays to people's fears as opposed to providing legitimate solutions to problems facing the country."

But simplifying the issues is just the way of politics, says Jim Carafano, immigration analyst at the right-leaning Heritage Foundation. It's a bumper sticker debate. "Border security is about what's going on inside Mexico; it's about what's happening at the border; it's about what's going on inside the United States; it's about economics; it's about transnational criminal activity; it's about how people feel about their communities," he explains. "Anybody that can fit that on a bumper sticker, God bless them."

Republican strategist Luis Alvarado of the political consulting firm Revolvis also blames primary politics for the focus on the fence as a tangible object that serves as a proxy for the complex issues at the heart of the immigration debate. "In a certain way, it's one way of relegating all the problems of immigration to one specific issue," he says, adding that this is something both parties do. "Politically, we all know that it's not a viable issue for either party until after 2012 elections are done and over with."

And though Latino voters are not a monolithic, single-issue group, Alvarado explains, those focused on immigration "feel that they've been shelved until 2013" by the president and by GOP candidates. "They're so frustrated with everybody that they've become apathetic," he says. "I don't think they're going to come out and vote in volumes like they did in the 2008 presidential cycle."

Bingel, the former Customs and Border Protection chief of staff, says he understands that support for a physical fence, particularly in places like Arizona, comes from frustration that the federal government hasn't brought immigration policy up to date. He doesn't believe the conversation about the fence itself is bad, as long as it doesn't stop there. "If the fence is a symbol of how to talk about the range of different things we still need to do, then that's a good thing in my mind," he says. "But I hope people don't literally take it as the fence and the fence alone is the solution for that 2,000 miles of border; that would be short-sighted."

 

SocialTwist Tell-a-Friend

 

Twitter: @ihavenet

 

  • Opinions Strong About Gaddafi's End and Libya's New Beginning
  • Libyans Celebrate Gaddafi's Death
  • Wall Street (Unlike)
  • Animal Spirits: Shaping Patterns of Economic Growth
  • Assessing the Damage of the European Banking Crisis
  • Better Ways Forward for the European Union
  • Solving A Deadly Eurozone Sovereign Debt Crisis
  • Steve Jobs May Have Failed Abroad
  • Behind Europe's Debt Crisis Lurks Another Wall Street Bailout
  • Sluggish America Can Still Be a World Leader
  • US Economic Woes Put China in the Political Crosshairs
  • Newspaper Nostalgia
  • Veterans: The Human Rubble of Our Wars
  • A Devalued Renminbi Makes Wealthier Americans
  • US Fears Misplaced When it Comes to China
  • United States - South Korea Trade Deal Win-Win for Jobs and Economy
  • Predator in Chief
  • United States Accusations Turn Up Heat in Simmering Gulf
  • Congress, Administration Discuss Next Steps on Iran
  • Iran and The Diminishing Returns of Reasonableness
  • What if Arbabsiar Was All About the Drugs, Not Terror?
  • Terror Plot's Mystery Link to Iran
  • What War Between Iran and Saudi Arabia Might Look Like
  • Yemen's Turbulent Spring
  • Dealing with the Haqqanis
  • The Conservative Case Against a Border Fence
  • GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012
  • Learning From Mexico's Coalition Debate
  • Mexican Constitution Now Recognizes Right to Food
  • Islamic Plot to Bomb U.S. Embassy Reported in Mexico
  • The Suppression of Democracy in Haiti
  • Colombia: Human Rights Issues Unanswered
  • Chinese Investment Flows Continue to Aid Brazil's Ascendency
  • Free Trade Is Not So Free: The Panamanian Case
  • Arab Spring, Israeli Isolation
  • Israeli - Palestinian Conflict: The Prisoner Swap
  • Iran Alleged Assassination Plot: Emboldened by Nuke Program?
  • The Real Nuclear Threat From Iran May Not Be Nuclear Weapons
  • From the Mediterranean to the Hindu Kush: Rethinking the Region
  • Price of the Libya Intervention: Surface to Air Missiles for All
  • Exporters Armed Arab Spring Crackdown
  • Fighting Escalates in Yemen
  • Hamas Gains From Prisoner Swap Likely to Fade
  • Mossad Gets Dragged Into Latest British Political Scandal
  • Black Magic Widespread in Saudi Arabia
  • Syria: Alawites Go On Arms Shopping Spree
  • Children Man Barricades in Northern Kosovo
  • Macedonia's EU Bid Still Mired in Name Issue
  • Turkey Needs Further Reforms
  • 'Ottomania' on the Rise in Turkey
  • Turkey: Cartoonist Faces Trial for Asserting that 'Religion Is a Lie'
  • Turkey - Russia Relations and Missile Defense
  • The Black Sea: A Forgotten Geo-strategic Realm
  • Central Asia: Russia Grapples with a Security Dilemma
  • Russia: Is Moscow Heading Toward the Time of Troubles?
  • China and the South China Sea Dispute
  • South China Sea Disputes: Why conflict is Not Inevitable
  • Burma's Junta: Can a Tiger Change Its Stripes?
  • Japan: Ozawa Ichiro on Trial
  • India-China Economic Dialogue: A View from Beijing
  • India-Afghanistan Partnership Through the Eyes of the Pakistani Media
  • India Falters in Countering Terrorism
  • The Last Colony in Africa
  • Beyond Good Versus Evil: Fighting Somalia's Perpetual War
  • Heavy Casualties as Somali Forces Attack Rebel Stronghold
  • Somali Forces Seize District in Lower Jubba from Insurgents
  • Hard Times Lead Young Somalis to Delay Marriage
  • Kenya's Risky Intervention into Somalia
  • Children Tempted With a Phone to Carry a Gun
  • African Drought Response: Lessons Still to Learn
  • Rumpus Over Genetically Modified Food Aid in Africa
  • Great Game in the Horn of Africa
  • Crowds and Constitutions: Insights from Iceland
  • Beyond the Nation-State
  • The Human Rights Council: 5 Years On
  • United States Prepares Sanctions Against Iran for Bomb Plot
  • Iran Denies Alleged Plot to Kill Saudi Envoy
  • Cyber Security as a Wicked Problem
  • An Alternative Eulogy for Steve Jobs
  • Americas to Become Mecca of World's Energy
  • Time for United States to Think Big on Latin America
  • Latin Universities Index Doesn't Tell Full Story
  • Blind Eye to Colombia's Questionable Human Rights Record
  • United States - Cuba Policy Staggers from Inept to Pedestrian
  • Rick Perry Proposal of American Troops in Mexico Stirs Criticism
  • GOP Candidates Look at Narco-Terrorism Risks
  • Dexia Bank's Collapse and the European Financial Crisis
  • European Crisis: Precise Solutions in an Imprecise Reality
  • Slovakia Thumbs Down on Euro Bailout Fund Hike
  • Greek Anger and Greece's Survival
  • A Win-Win Strategy for Investors in Greece
  • Amid Strikes, Greek Workers are Hurting
  • Without Textbooks Greek School Year Starts in Confusion
  • Putin's Comeback: Fast Forward to the Past
  • NATO and Russia: Missile Defense Sticking Point?
  • Russia's Arctic Embrace: Cold War Reloaded
  • Putin Calls For Eurasian Union In Former Soviet Space
  • United Kingdom Riots: State of Denial
  • UK Unemployment Rises to 17-year High
  • Study Estimates 3 Million British Children in Poverty by 2013
  • Bank of England Pours More Money Into Quantitative Easing
  • Britain Shuts Down Family Access Immigration Route
  • EC Recommends Serbia Gain EU Candidate Status
  • Spanish Court Won't Let Cameraman Couso Killing Die
  • Poland's Tusk Wins Historic Second Term
  • Turkey: Making Room for Religious Minorities
  • Cyprus: Waters Roil in Eastern Mediterranean
  • A Nuclear Retaliation Alternative for India
  • Strategic Partnership with Afghanistan: India Showcases Soft Power
  • The India - Bangladesh Border: A New Beginning
  • Pakistan's Sponsorship of Terrorism Is Undeniable
  • Energy Crises and Riots in Pakistan
  • Dante in Karachi: Circles of Crime in a Megacity
  • Children in 2005 Pakistan Earthquake Zone Still Lack Schools
  • Afghanistan: The Regional Complex
  • Afghanistan's Energy War
  • Afghanistan War Marks 10th Year Quietly
  • Bono's African Philanthropy Could Use a Remix
  • The Dadaab Camps: The Daemon in the Detail
  • Dadaab Camps: A Day in the Life of a Refugee
  • Senegal: Demining Machine Clears Path For Better Future
  • Somalia: African Union Forces Attack Al Shabaab's Strongholds
  • Worst Forms of Child Labor Still Widespread in Africa
  • South Africa: Deportations of Zimbabwean Migrants Set to Resume
  • Uganda: New facility to Concentrate on Cancer
  • Africa: Why Involving Men is Crucial
  • Zimbabwe: Poverty Alleviation Program Targets Kids
  • The Economics of the Arab Spring
  • Many Arabs Stay Hopeful Even as Economies Sag
  • Arab World Poised for Economic Growth Spurt
  • Fear of an Islamic Planet
  • Riots in Cairo
  • Egyptian Army Turns Guns on Its Citizens
  • Timeline of Egyptian Sectarian Violence
  • A New Phase in Post-Mubarak Egypt
  • Boycott Looms as Egyptian Elections Near
  • Anxious Campaign Season Opens in Tunisia
  • Saudi Security Force Ramps Up
  • Sectarian Rifts Erupt Again in Saudi Arabia
  • Libya: Winning the Peace Collectively
  • Concerns Over 'Rampant Torture' Rise in Syria
  • Syria: Redrawing the Political Foundations
  • Lieberman Calls for No-Fly Zone Over Syria
  • Syrian Crackdown Reaches London and Paris
  • Anwar Al Awlaki Death Doesn't Solve Yemen's Problems
  • Yemen: Fallout from the al-Awlaki Airstrike
  • Why America Should Pay Attention to Egyptian Elections
  • Boxed in on the Middle East
  • Even Non-Violent Palestinian Intifada Seems Unlikely Now
  • Art Comes to Jerusalem Open Market
  • Israel: Bittersweet Reunion of Righteous Gentiles
  • Jewish Extremists Burn Mosque in Israel
  • Israeli 'Price Tag' Vandals Mark Up Violence
  • Rise of the Renminbi as International Currency
  • China: Significance and Implications of Tiangong 1
  • China Orders Closure of 13 Wal-Marts for Selling Mislabeled Pork
  • China Launches Own Iron Ore Price Index
  • South Korea's Naval Base on Ulleung Island
  • Why 2012 Will Shake Up Asia and the World
  • Rights Groups Moves High Court on Beheading of 8 Bangladeshi
  • Bangladesh World's 5th Most Vulnerable Country for Climate Change
  • Bangladesh's Grameenphone and Teletalk Partner on Cell Phone Early Disaster Warning System

 

Copyright 2011, U.S. News & World Report

 

Share / Recommend

Search Powered By Google

Google Search   

ADVERTISEMENT

Advertisement

Advertisement

ADVERTISEMENT

Job & Career Search

career & job search                    job title, keywords, company, location
  • HOME
  • WORLD
  • USA
  • BUSINESS
  • WEALTH
  • STOCKS
  • TECH
  • HEALTH
  • LIFESTYLE
  • ENTERTAINMENT
  • SPORTS

World - GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012 | Global Viewpoint

  • Services:
  • RSS Feeds
  • Shopping
  • Email Alerts
  • Site Map
  • Privacy