Igor Torbakov
Dmitry Medvedev's and Vladimir Putin's apparently amicable decision to swap jobs is being touted by the Kremlin as a way to ensure Russia's stability. Yet if Russia's historical tradition is any guide, changing places is a move fraught with uncertainty.
When Putin, the incumbent prime minister, announced his intention in late September to reclaim the presidency in 2012, it confirmed a Russian leadership pattern: whether a divine-right monarch, a Communist Party boss or an "elected" president, Russia's rulers have tended to be authoritarian-minded in outlook and inclined never to relinquish power willingly.
For many in Russia's sprawling bureaucracy, a Putin administration redux will come as a relief because it eliminates the possibility of a dvoevlastie (dual power) scenario from developing. The last time Russia grappled with dual power, back in 1993, scores of people in Moscow ended up being killed in street fighting and the parliament building went up in flames. Most Russian bureaucrats desire the relative stability that comes from edinonachalie, or "one-person management." And Putin is seen as the embodiment of edinonachalie.
It's important to keep in mind that Putin's strong-hand governing style, which now is marketed to the masses as "managed democracy," has a flip side. And that other side of the coin isn't so pretty to look at.
The obverse of political stability, in the Russian concept, is what's known as Smuta -- a term for a time of troubles. The two parts of the Russian political tradition are intimately interrelated. Throughout Russia's history, a combination of factors -- including rulers who cling to power, oligarchs who act arbitrarily and without regard for the social ramifications of their actions, and the general weakness of political institutions -- have repeatedly revealed the country's power structure to be brittle and prone to sudden collapse.
In a situation where Russian "commoners" are unable to protect their individual rights via legal means, while Russian "boyars" come to believe that they are above the law, the state remains at constant risk of upheaval, even revolution.
Putin and his supporters appear to take pride in how expertly they managed to pull off the trick of "tandemocracy," in which, to nominally conform with the Russian constitution, the president took a four-year sabbatical, albeit as prime minister, and let Medvedev keep the Kremlin seat warm. The "dual power" potential created by Putin's anointment of Medvedev in 2008 was indeed real. But Medvedev wisely chose not to challenge Putin -- the "true tsar" -- and thus escaped being labeled a False Dmitry or samozvanets (false tsar, impostor). Rather, Medvedev was content to play a role akin to that of Simeon Bekbulatovich, a khan of the minor Khanate of Qasim, whom Ivan the Terrible appointed in 1575 as the Grand Prince of All Rus', while he himself supposedly stepped aside as Russia's autocrat. A year later, however, Ivan returned to the throne and made Simeon, for his good services, the Grand Prince of Tver', at the time an important Muscovite principality.
Russia managed to avoid Smuta the first time Putin and Medvedev changed places in 2008. But that was then. Economic conditions are more volatile these days, and Putin may well discover that enforcing stability during his second go-round in the presidency is far more difficult than it was during the first eight years of the millennium.
The truth is that Russia's present-day socio-political system is extremely vulnerable to external economic pressure. Given Russia's deplorable investment climate due to rampant corruption and shaky property rights, the only source of growth is the perpetuation of high oil prices. According to various estimates, Russia's budget can be balanced only if the price for crude hovers around $125 per barrel. However, this cannot be guaranteed.
Given that elections in Russia are a sham, the Putin administration, although admittedly popular, lacks legitimacy. Thus, it can count on popular support only so long as it can sustain at least modest growth in living standards. This, or course, cannot be guaranteed either.
As it tries to maintain an iron grip on power, the Putin administration appears intent on leaning on radical Russian nationalism. Such a strategy is a recipe for disaster in a multiethnic country that is becoming ever more culturally diverse due to the massive migration flows of immigration -- mostly from the formerly Soviet Caucasus and Central Asia.
Keeping nationalist sentiment in check is notoriously tricky. Thus, Putin may end up finding that flirting with nationalism paves the way for the emergence of truly nationalist political forces, the kind that places Russia on a path toward a fascist-type dictatorship.
Already, the ultra-right is starting to assert itself.
"Struggling for survival, Russia's authorities will be forced to accept the program of Russian nationalists. They have only one alternative -- to lose power," asserts one Russian nationalist ideologue in an essay posted on the APN.ru website. "The time for the Russian national state has come."
It would appear, then, that the possibility of Russia experiencing another bout of Smuta can't be taken lightly. It may be that the individual who eventually replaces Putin will be the one who has to deal with the fallout from current policies. But it also could be Putin 2.0 himself who will be faced with the unpleasant consequences of his administration's desire to avoid any meaningful reform, along with its intent to preserve the status-quo of unchecked rent-seeking.
Originally published by EurasiaNet.org
Twitter: @ihavenet
- Opinions Strong About Gaddafi's End and Libya's New Beginning
- Libyans Celebrate Gaddafi's Death
- Wall Street (Unlike)
- Animal Spirits: Shaping Patterns of Economic Growth
- Assessing the Damage of the European Banking Crisis
- Better Ways Forward for the European Union
- Solving A Deadly Eurozone Sovereign Debt Crisis
- Steve Jobs May Have Failed Abroad
- Behind Europe's Debt Crisis Lurks Another Wall Street Bailout
- Sluggish America Can Still Be a World Leader
- US Economic Woes Put China in the Political Crosshairs
- Newspaper Nostalgia
- Veterans: The Human Rubble of Our Wars
- A Devalued Renminbi Makes Wealthier Americans
- US Fears Misplaced When it Comes to China
- United States - South Korea Trade Deal Win-Win for Jobs and Economy
- Predator in Chief
- United States Accusations Turn Up Heat in Simmering Gulf
- Congress, Administration Discuss Next Steps on Iran
- Iran and The Diminishing Returns of Reasonableness
- What if Arbabsiar Was All About the Drugs, Not Terror?
- Terror Plot's Mystery Link to Iran
- What War Between Iran and Saudi Arabia Might Look Like
- Yemen's Turbulent Spring
- Dealing with the Haqqanis
- The Conservative Case Against a Border Fence
- GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012
- Learning From Mexico's Coalition Debate
- Mexican Constitution Now Recognizes Right to Food
- Islamic Plot to Bomb U.S. Embassy Reported in Mexico
- The Suppression of Democracy in Haiti
- Colombia: Human Rights Issues Unanswered
- Chinese Investment Flows Continue to Aid Brazil's Ascendency
- Free Trade Is Not So Free: The Panamanian Case
- Arab Spring, Israeli Isolation
- Israeli - Palestinian Conflict: The Prisoner Swap
- Iran Alleged Assassination Plot: Emboldened by Nuke Program?
- The Real Nuclear Threat From Iran May Not Be Nuclear Weapons
- From the Mediterranean to the Hindu Kush: Rethinking the Region
- Price of the Libya Intervention: Surface to Air Missiles for All
- Exporters Armed Arab Spring Crackdown
- Fighting Escalates in Yemen
- Hamas Gains From Prisoner Swap Likely to Fade
- Mossad Gets Dragged Into Latest British Political Scandal
- Black Magic Widespread in Saudi Arabia
- Syria: Alawites Go On Arms Shopping Spree
- Children Man Barricades in Northern Kosovo
- Macedonia's EU Bid Still Mired in Name Issue
- Turkey Needs Further Reforms
- 'Ottomania' on the Rise in Turkey
- Turkey: Cartoonist Faces Trial for Asserting that 'Religion Is a Lie'
- Turkey - Russia Relations and Missile Defense
- The Black Sea: A Forgotten Geo-strategic Realm
- Central Asia: Russia Grapples with a Security Dilemma
- Russia: Is Moscow Heading Toward the Time of Troubles?
- China and the South China Sea Dispute
- South China Sea Disputes: Why conflict is Not Inevitable
- Burma's Junta: Can a Tiger Change Its Stripes?
- Japan: Ozawa Ichiro on Trial
- India-China Economic Dialogue: A View from Beijing
- India-Afghanistan Partnership Through the Eyes of the Pakistani Media
- India Falters in Countering Terrorism
- The Last Colony in Africa
- Beyond Good Versus Evil: Fighting Somalia's Perpetual War
- Heavy Casualties as Somali Forces Attack Rebel Stronghold
- Somali Forces Seize District in Lower Jubba from Insurgents
- Hard Times Lead Young Somalis to Delay Marriage
- Kenya's Risky Intervention into Somalia
- Children Tempted With a Phone to Carry a Gun
- African Drought Response: Lessons Still to Learn
- Rumpus Over Genetically Modified Food Aid in Africa
- Great Game in the Horn of Africa
- Crowds and Constitutions: Insights from Iceland
- Beyond the Nation-State
- The Human Rights Council: 5 Years On
- United States Prepares Sanctions Against Iran for Bomb Plot
- Iran Denies Alleged Plot to Kill Saudi Envoy
- Cyber Security as a Wicked Problem
- An Alternative Eulogy for Steve Jobs
- Americas to Become Mecca of World's Energy
- Time for United States to Think Big on Latin America
- Latin Universities Index Doesn't Tell Full Story
- Blind Eye to Colombia's Questionable Human Rights Record
- United States - Cuba Policy Staggers from Inept to Pedestrian
- Rick Perry Proposal of American Troops in Mexico Stirs Criticism
- GOP Candidates Look at Narco-Terrorism Risks
- Dexia Bank's Collapse and the European Financial Crisis
- European Crisis: Precise Solutions in an Imprecise Reality
- Slovakia Thumbs Down on Euro Bailout Fund Hike
- Greek Anger and Greece's Survival
- A Win-Win Strategy for Investors in Greece
- Amid Strikes, Greek Workers are Hurting
- Without Textbooks Greek School Year Starts in Confusion
- Putin's Comeback: Fast Forward to the Past
- NATO and Russia: Missile Defense Sticking Point?
- Russia's Arctic Embrace: Cold War Reloaded
- Putin Calls For Eurasian Union In Former Soviet Space
- United Kingdom Riots: State of Denial
- UK Unemployment Rises to 17-year High
- Study Estimates 3 Million British Children in Poverty by 2013
- Bank of England Pours More Money Into Quantitative Easing
- Britain Shuts Down Family Access Immigration Route
- EC Recommends Serbia Gain EU Candidate Status
- Spanish Court Won't Let Cameraman Couso Killing Die
- Poland's Tusk Wins Historic Second Term
- Turkey: Making Room for Religious Minorities
- Cyprus: Waters Roil in Eastern Mediterranean
- A Nuclear Retaliation Alternative for India
- Strategic Partnership with Afghanistan: India Showcases Soft Power
- The India - Bangladesh Border: A New Beginning
- Pakistan's Sponsorship of Terrorism Is Undeniable
- Energy Crises and Riots in Pakistan
- Dante in Karachi: Circles of Crime in a Megacity
- Children in 2005 Pakistan Earthquake Zone Still Lack Schools
- Afghanistan: The Regional Complex
- Afghanistan's Energy War
- Afghanistan War Marks 10th Year Quietly
- Bono's African Philanthropy Could Use a Remix
- The Dadaab Camps: The Daemon in the Detail
- Dadaab Camps: A Day in the Life of a Refugee
- Senegal: Demining Machine Clears Path For Better Future
- Somalia: African Union Forces Attack Al Shabaab's Strongholds
- Worst Forms of Child Labor Still Widespread in Africa
- South Africa: Deportations of Zimbabwean Migrants Set to Resume
- Uganda: New facility to Concentrate on Cancer
- Africa: Why Involving Men is Crucial
- Zimbabwe: Poverty Alleviation Program Targets Kids
- The Economics of the Arab Spring
- Many Arabs Stay Hopeful Even as Economies Sag
- Arab World Poised for Economic Growth Spurt
- Fear of an Islamic Planet
- Riots in Cairo
- Egyptian Army Turns Guns on Its Citizens
- Timeline of Egyptian Sectarian Violence
- A New Phase in Post-Mubarak Egypt
- Boycott Looms as Egyptian Elections Near
- Anxious Campaign Season Opens in Tunisia
- Saudi Security Force Ramps Up
- Sectarian Rifts Erupt Again in Saudi Arabia
- Libya: Winning the Peace Collectively
- Concerns Over 'Rampant Torture' Rise in Syria
- Syria: Redrawing the Political Foundations
- Lieberman Calls for No-Fly Zone Over Syria
- Syrian Crackdown Reaches London and Paris
- Anwar Al Awlaki Death Doesn't Solve Yemen's Problems
- Yemen: Fallout from the al-Awlaki Airstrike
- Why America Should Pay Attention to Egyptian Elections
- Boxed in on the Middle East
- Even Non-Violent Palestinian Intifada Seems Unlikely Now
- Art Comes to Jerusalem Open Market
- Israel: Bittersweet Reunion of Righteous Gentiles
- Jewish Extremists Burn Mosque in Israel
- Israeli 'Price Tag' Vandals Mark Up Violence
- Rise of the Renminbi as International Currency
- China: Significance and Implications of Tiangong 1
- China Orders Closure of 13 Wal-Marts for Selling Mislabeled Pork
- China Launches Own Iron Ore Price Index
- South Korea's Naval Base on Ulleung Island
- Why 2012 Will Shake Up Asia and the World
- Rights Groups Moves High Court on Beheading of 8 Bangladeshi
- Bangladesh World's 5th Most Vulnerable Country for Climate Change
- Bangladesh's Grameenphone and Teletalk Partner on Cell Phone Early Disaster Warning System
- How Space Technology Aids Flood Response
- Philippine Supreme Court Reverses Ruling Favoring Fired PAL Cabin Crews
- Malaysia Refugee Swap Deal Gets Support from UNHCR
- Australian Alps Could Be Bare of Snow by 2050
- Qantas Orders 110 Jets from Airbus
- Coal Exports Boost Australian Trade Balance
- Hard Facts: The World Is Getting Better
- United Nations Can't Save the Oppressed, But It Can Give Them a Voice
- Obama's International Outsourcing
- Radical Islamist Cleric Anwar al-Awlaki Killed in Yemen
- Anwar Al-Awlaki's Death Major Victory For Counter-Terrorism
- United States Gaze Turns to Uzbeks
- Fiscal Union for the Euro: Some Lessons from History
- German Parliament Approves Hike in EU Loan Guarantees
- Preparing for Greece's Failure
- Despite Austerity Measures Greece Will Still Miss EU Budget Cut Targets
- Greece Working to Convince EU it Can Meet Austerity Demands
- Greek Parliament Approves New Property Tax
- Greeks to Face Further Tough Measures
- Albania's Unsettled Past
- Balkans Summit Extols Regional Co-Operation
- Erdogan Pushes for Common Future with Balkan States
- Turkey's Sinking Lira Defies Soaring Economy
- Kukan: Dialogue Not Barricades
- Arab Spring Turkish Harvest
- Iran at a Crossroads
- Iran's Support of Syria Is Backfiring
- The Mottled Relationship: Iran and Latin America
- Is It a Mistake to Draw Solace From Iran's Long Bomb Gestation Period?
- Arab Spring Added Pressures to Middle East Peace Process
- Israel Accepts Quartet Proposal to Resume Peace Talks
- Blocking Palestinian Statehood
- The Occupation That Time Forgot
- Israeli Parliamentarians Call for Annexation of West Bank
- U.S. Congress: Standard Bearer for Israeli Expansion
- Michele Bachmann 'Blames' Obama for Arab Spring
- Saudis Tussle Over Textbook
- Saudi Arabia Grants Women Limited Right to Vote
- Egypt Eyes New Arms Suppliers
- Saleh Return Deepens Crisis In Yemen
- Other Leaders Should Copy Brazil's Anti-graft Measures
- Obama's U.N. Omission: The War Next Door
- The Drug War Spreads the Bloodbath South
- Mexican Cartels and Pan American Games: A Threat Assessment
- Mexico: Death by Social Media
- Big Agriculture's Latin American Exploits
- Is Free Trade Good for Colombia
- China in Search of Energy Security
- Cuba's Domestic Reforms Surge Past Immobilized United States
- Fears Over Environmental Affects Prompt Court To Halt Mega-Dam Project
- Bolivian Workers Strike to Protest Controversial Highway
- Afghanistan is Obama's Gordian Knot
- Why Are Pakistan's Militant Groups Splintering?
- Questions Raised About Haqqani Network Ties with Pakistan
- Russia Strives to Clarify Vision for Central Asian Alliance
- Azerbaijan Faces Difficult Choice Between Turkey and Israel
- Azerbaijan Wrestles with Iranian Predicament
- In Post-Soviet Central Asia Russian Takes Back Seat
- Stabilizing Congo
- The Balkanization of Somalia
- Refugees Still Vulnerable in Southern Kordofan
- Al Shabaab Attacks Kill 16 at Key Somali Border Town
- Is Africa New Breeding Place for Terrorism?
- Somali Media Press on with Work Despite Deadly Challenges
- China-Indian Trade: Smoothening the Rough Edges
- The Survival of North Korea
- The 'Orchid Revolution' in Singapore
- Counterinsurgency and 'Op Sadhbhavana' in Jammu and Kashmir
- Indian Foreign Policy in Search of a Balance
- Philippines Struggles After Two Typhoons
- Typhoon Nesat Death Toll Rises to 20
- Islamist Rampage Blamed in Bangladesh Riots
- United States to Help Bangladesh Combat Bird Flu
- Indian Earthquake Prompts 'Wake-Up Call'
- Evolution of a Pakistani Militant Network
- Afghanistan: Rabbani Assassination May Peel Tajiks Away from Kabul
- Rabbani Assassination: An Assertive Taliban and America's Dilemmas
- Light at End of Afghan Tunnel Recedes
- Karachi's Long Summer of Violence
- Afghanistan: Patchy Progress on Education
- Kashmir Police Question 3 in Delhi Bombing
- Indian Democracy Gets a Wake-Up Call
- India: No Counter-Revolution Please
- Al-Qaeda Lost the Battle Long Ago
- 10 Years of 9/11 Wars is Enough
- Why Al Qaeda is Unlikely to Execute Another 9/11
- War Costs Greater Than Acknowledged and Continuing to Climb
- Al Qaeda's Challenge
- Leaving Afghanistan to the Afghans
- Balkan Countries Work To Round Up Privately Held Weapons
- Two Million Hit By Floods in Pakistan's Sindh Province
- Assassination as Foreign Policy
Available at Amazon.com:
Aftermath: Following the Bloodshed of America's Wars in the Muslim World
Displacement and Dispossession in the Modern Middle East (The Contemporary Middle East)
The End of History and the Last Man
The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order
The Tragedy of Great Power Politics
Copyright 2011, iHaveNet.com All Rights Reserved