Why We're Shunning the McMansion
More home buyers are drawn to accessibility and convenience rather than square footage
An increasing number of Americans are opting to buy smaller homes or even rent, experts say, as uncertainty about the struggling housing market, energy prices, and a lackluster domestic economy persists.
"Despite home prices that have really rolled back about 10 years and historically low interest rates, buyers are cautious for a variety of reasons," says
"Home buyers are thinking, 'Maybe we don't need that 7,000 square foot home like we thought we did in 2004 or 2005 when the market was approaching its top,'" says
Only 9 percent of consumers surveyed said they wanted a home 3,200 square feet or larger, according to a recent study by the NAR, while the majority of house hunters -- about 55 percent -- preferred homes in the 1,400 to 2,600 square-foot range. Builders also plan to scale back new home sizes as well, with 9 out of 10 builders expecting to build smaller, lower-priced homes in the coming years, according to a study by the NAHB.
Despite the drop in desired median home square footage, Melman says it's not so much a matter of downsizing as "right-sizing" -- forgoing larger homes with unused space for smaller, more efficient and well-laid-out homes. Americans are reconsidering the notion of financially stretching themselves to the limit to purchase a large home. "The trend here is shelter value," he says. "Affordability is driving the decisions. If you buy a home that's a little bit smaller, that's one way to get some control over energy costs and the overall costs of the home."
Along with increased awareness about energy costs, consumers are putting more emphasis on elements such a home's proximity to their jobs and accessibility to public transportation. "The recession we've experienced has really made people more in tune with their finances," says
Another demographic consists of Americans who might have traded up for a larger house in the past, but are now deciding to stay put and make do with their existing home. A lot of that has to with the mindset many home owners had prior to the housing bust, when it seemed home prices would always increase, allowing owners to cash out on built up equity and upgrade to bigger and bigger homes. That certainty has been removed in not only home price appreciation, but in the job markets as well -- a key driver in the health of the housing market, says
In lieu of upgrading to a larger home, Bohutinsky says homeowners are getting more creative in figuring out how to make their existing home work for them. "Whether it's remodeling their own home or renting a more appropriate home, there's less of the automatic notion that of course, we're going to sell and go buy a bigger home," Bohutinsky says. "The economy is forcing that psychological shift. People are getting creative and some are just making do with less."
Apprehension about the economy and housing market in general has also translated into increased demand in the luxury rental market, says
Getting more comfortable might mean waiting out some of the volatility seen in the housing market over the past couple of years. With tighter credit availability and a plentiful supply of homes for sale, many would-be home buyers are taking a step back and waiting a year or two to get comfortable and familiarize themselves with their market.
"If you were a consumer thinking about buying or renting, at the high end before you didn't have a lot of choices," Miller says. "If you were on the fence, you might have said, 'Oh, we'll just buy.' But now, maybe [they] can delay a year just to get comfortable, then buy."
Despite the increased demand for luxury rentals, Miller says that trend doesn't represent a larger shift away from homeownership. "It's not seen as a permanent retrenchment of people saying 'I'm not going to buy, I'm just going to rent.' It just provides a platform of alternatives for people to delay the decision," he says.
While experts says the fundamental desire to own a home hasn't changed, the conditions under which consumers are willing to purchase homes has shifted. According to the
While the allure of the McMansion might be waning for consumers, there's another side to the story, too. Mortgage interest rates are at historic lows -- 4.80 percent, on average, as of
Assuming larger homes generally require larger mortgages, nailing down any loan, let alone the "jumbo loans" needed to finance larger, more expensive homes, is tougher than it has been in the past. "The whole McMansion era came about when there was easy access to money and a mortgage. You could get a mortgage with zero percent down, again on the assumption that your home would appreciate," Bohutinsky says. On the other hand, to get a mortgage today, would-be home buyers should expect to put down at least 20 percent. Even tighter credit standards exist for jumbo loans, Bohutinsky says.
Above all, psychologically making the leap of faith this spring may prove to be the strongest deterrent for home buyers. "In thinking about how long you want to hold onto your home, the runway is much longer now. You have to think something around seven years," Bohutinsky says. "When you buy a more expensive home, that's a lot longer to think about having to pay that mortgage every month for seven years. You have to continue to have that good-paying job and not lose that job. It's just a bigger leap of faith to make that commitment than it was before."
- What Home Inspectors Don't Notice
- Buying Beats Renting in 80 percent of U.S. Cities
- What Moves Mortgage Rates?
- Why We're Shunning the McMansion
- The Ultimate Spring Home Buyers Guide
- HUD Drops Harsh Rule on Reverse Mortgages
- Borrowers Have to Jump Through Maddening Hoops Just to Close
- Before Taking a Reverse Mortgage You Need to Know the Costs
- Why the World Caught a Cold When the U.S. Housing Market Sneezed
- HED Reverse Mortgages
- Rising Number of Reverse Mortgage Borrowers Facing Foreclosure
- Now May Be the Time to Buy a Home
- 10 Winter Wonderlands for Retirement
- What Mortgage Lenders Look For When They Scrutinize Your Finances
- Five Things You Should Know About Foreclosure in 2011
- Property Taxes Might Be Higher Than You Thought Before Purchase
- New Year's Resolutions for Home Sellers
- What Lenders Mean by 'Loss Mitigation'
- New Year's Resolutions for Home Buyers
- Decoding the FICO 8 and FICO 8 Mortgage Score
- Why It's Time to Reconsider House-Hunting
- Jobs and Real Estate Tethered for Better or Worse
- Not Wise to Order Your Own Appraisal Before Refinance
- Foreclosure Process In Deep Crisis; Is Government Finally Noticing?
- How Much Should You Pay to Refinance?
- Interest Rates Drop Again But Will Housing Market Perk Up?
- On Sale: Retirement Havens
- Appraisal Problems Kill Opportunity For Lower Mortgage Rate
- Our Big Fat Foreclosure Mess
- What to Expect When You're Closing on Your Mortgage Loan
- Shopping for a Home When There's Too Much to Buy
- Finding Second Home Bargains
- America's 10 Slowest Appreciating Housing Markets
- The Costs of Retiring with a Mortgage
- Prepaying a Mortgage: When Does It Maske Sense
- Shorter-Term Mortgages Make Sense for Some
- Thinking About Refinancing? Get Moving
- 10 Historic Places to Retire
- Do You Live in a High-Debt City?
- How to Get a Government-Backed, Zero-Down-Payment Mortgage
- Housing Demand Evaporates As Stimulus Ends
- Home Prices Likely to Slide After Sales Plummet
- 9 Reasons to Choose a New Home Over a Resale
- What will happen to the housing market?
- Pay Off Investment Property or Pay Off Primary Residence?
- 9 Smart Ways to Come Up with Down-Payment Cash
- More Federal Help for Struggling Homeowners
- Home Builders Not Driving Economic Recovery
- Packing for a Move Is an Art Unto Itself
- An Expert Looks at the Future Of Real Estate
- How Financial Reform Affects Home Buyers
- 10 Best Places to Reinvent Your Life in Retirement
- Housing Market Takes Another Step Backwards
- When Buying Distressed Property Know All Liabilities That Come With It
- 3 Ways to Invest in the Real Estate Rally
- Will the REITs Rally Continue?
Real Estate - Why We're Shunning the McMansion
(c) 2011 U.S. News & World Report