Motorola Cliq - Google Android SmartPhone

Flexibility of the Google software makes these phones anything but clones of one another

Although a year late, the Google phone is living up to its promise. Phones based on the Web giant's Android software appear ready to challenge the iPhone, BlackBerry, and Nokia brands as a leading contender in the smartphone wars. A slew of Google phones have suddenly descended on the market, with dozens more expected to arrive late this year and early in 2010.

[Check out these technology gifts for the holidays.]

No single Android-based phone is likely to match the runaway success of the iPhone. But the wave of Google-supported phones could add up to a broad hit that sells more handsets than Apple, as Nokia and BlackBerry already do. Google's Android could be running on 18 percent of smartphones by 2012, say analysts at Gartner Group. That could put the Google phones second only to Nokia, which for years has been the dominant smartphone maker worldwide.

Unlike Nokia, Apple, and BlackBerry, Google doesn't make the phones themselves (and denies rumors that it ever will). The search company instead rewrote free software to create the Android system that gives handsets the smarts of a low-end PC. The software first appeared to much fanfare and good reviews on a single handset in October 2008. Then it appeared to stall.

In the past month or so, the system has blossomed. It's now on more than two dozen phones. And to firmly establish itself, Google's Android needs only a few more hits like the Verizon Droid. More than a million buyers are expected to snap up the Droid by year's end, less than two months after its introduction. Troubled Motorola, meanwhile, is betting heavily on Android and is said to be readying a new class of cheap smartphone running the Google software.

No doubt, the iPhone has a huge lead with more than 100,000 applications available for download. Just like with PCs, it's the apps that make smartphones useful to consumers and that will help drive sales. But Android has ample choice in 10,000 available apps, and more are coming.

It's also hard to beat free. The search giant essentially gives away the Android system, which it is using to corner the wireless world much like its free searches captured PCs. These phones make clear what Google is after, with their tight integration into Google apps such as Gmail, maps, and Google Voice.

And it's hard to beat easy. Cellphone makers like Motorola and carriers like Verizon are encouraged to change the Android software, lather on extras, or otherwise customize what the system does. That flexibility is attractive to the companies that make and sell the phones. And it can be to buyers.

Android phones that are hitting the market are remarkably different from each other, unlike the consistent--some might argue repetitive--look and feel of phones from Apple, RIM, and Nokia. To get a flavor, we took a look at three very different Android handsets that hint at what's to come:

Verizon Droid ($200 with contract).

The handset has a beautiful, 3.7-inch touch screen and hardware keyboard that slides out from underneath. The Motorola-made handset itself feels heftier and sturdier than other models; with its metal components and hard, squared corners, it's more industrial and practical than pretty.

The software, too, is more straight forward. It's a fast, clean implementation of the Google-designed Android. The keyboard is better than a software keyboard, though it's disappointing with almost-flat keys that seem harder to find than on competing Android phones.

With that said, it's the only phone so far that's running the latest version, Android 2.0, with its added capabilities. The Droid, for example, can sync with multiple Gmail accounts and merge multiple E-mail accounts from a variety of providers into a single in-box. All in all, the Droid is easy enough for anyone to use out of the box.

But even its name suggests an orientation to someone who wants a fully powered companion at their fingertips. The Droid, more than other phones, bares Android's techy feel. It's more for a tinkerer than, say, the iPhone or Palm Pre. The Droid is for someone who wants to fully tap a phone's potential and who isn't beholden to style and soft edges.

T-Mobile Cliq ($100 with contract).

T-Mobile calls this Motorola handset "the first phone with social skills." And the Cliq is all about social networking, with "Motoblur" software that blends Facebook, Twitter, MySpace, and a variety of other Web sharing services into a single space. The phone gives the networks top billing, throwing the latest Tweets and Facebook updates onto its home screen.

The hardware itself is chic, with a 3.1-inch screen that is smaller than competitors but that allows for soft, rounded corners and an overall size that slips easily into a hip pocket. The hardware keyboard slides out from underneath and is one of the best on any phone. The raised keys are well marked with bright lettering and easy to distinguish from each other. One quibble is that the bottom row, including the important space bar, can be hard to reach past the raised lip of the enclosing case. The phone can also seem sluggish at times, and battery life is short. (Motorola has said a software fix is coming.)

It is networkers who will best like the Cliq. Updates from friends flow across the home screen, which at times can appear cluttered and overwhelming for the less-energetic butterfly. There's no limiting updates, for example, to a subset of your 500 Facebook friends. Updates are just as easy to contribute, with the Cliq spreading a message across multiple accounts in one swoop.

Sprint Hero ($100 with contract).

Another sexy case with rounded corners encloses this 3.2-inch touch screen. Handset maker HTC did away with the hardware keyboard that is popular among Android phones but has packed in more software features than any other model.

HTC has layered a whole new skin that it calls "Sense" across the Android software, giving it a flexible look that's easy to tailor to a user's liking. Sense pumps the Hero full of customized and standard Android widgets, little bits of software that are like the apps that might be later downloaded to other phones and that display their information immediately on the home screen.

The phone, for example, offers out-of-box syncing with Microsoft Outlook's contacts and calendar, an obvious app given HTC's long experience with Windows Mobile. Other apps customize information to a user's liking, be it weather, sports, or E-mail. A custom widget called "Footprints" makes it easy to geotag photos, add voice memos, and post them to Google maps.

All this can be overwhelming, especially for someone used to the iPhone's emphasis on simplicity. But the Sense software helps with a generous seven home screens for organizing widgets and apps. The Hero also lets users redesign the phone's look for different times. Innovative "scenes" flip weather and the Footprint app to the front for traveling, or Outlook appointments and E-mail while at the office.

 

 

Can't-Miss Holiday Gifts For the Traveler in Your Life
Christopher Elliott

Shopping for someone who's on the go isn't easy. Travelers -- especially frequent travelers -- can be particular about their likes and dislikes. They wouldn't be caught dead with a certain headset, phone, or piece of luggage. Here are options the traveler in your life might like ...

Give A Gift From the Heart This Year - To A Charity That Benefits Pets
Steve Dale

Let's face it, lots of people don't need a thing this holiday season. They have plenty of bottles of wine, more pairs of pajamas than they can wear and all the latest electronic gadgets. So, what can you do?

The War on the Book
Paul Greenberg

In Ashburnham, Massachusetts, a prep school has just given up on books. The headmaster of Cushing Academy, one James Tracy, doesn't see any need for them. Not any more. Anybody who's anybody or wants to be now has an iPhone with apps, a Kindle or whatever the Next Big Thing turns out to transiently be. Who needs books?

FCC 'Net Neutrality' Rules Would Keep the Web Free for Speech and Trade
Andrew Jay Schwartzman

If the federal government does nothing -- that is, if it does not adopt network neutrality rules -- it will be allowing telephone and cable companies to block, degrade, or slow down any content on the Internet for any reason. Without such rules, the Internet will not live up to its full potential for fueling economic growth and serving as a vehicle for artistic, political, and social expression

FCC Could Mess Up Internet With 'Net Neutrality' Rules No One Needs
Barbara S. Esbin

The FCC's proposed rules codify and expand its 2005 Internet policy principles -- intended to preserve 'openness' while giving ISPs flexibility. Despite its recognition that these principles have helped preserve Internet openness, the FCC is now poised to take far more intrusive action. Simply put, the case has not been made for regulating at this time. Here's why ...

(c) 2009 U.S. News & World Report