To critics of Uzbekistan, it was a disturbing phone call, disturbingly timed.
The White House on September 28 confirmed that U.S. President Barack Obama had earlier in the day telephoned Uzbek leader Islam Karimov to congratulate his country on 20 years of independence.
The phone call came nearly a month after the actual anniversary at the beginning of September, when Obama sent Karimov a commendatory letter, in which he said he looked forward "to developing even closer ties between our nations."
The belated phone call, however, fell on the same day that human rights organizations publicly urged the U.S. government not to proceed with a plan to restore military assistance to Karimov, who is accused of torturing perceived political opponents and turning a blind eye to the widespread use of child labor in the country's lucrative cotton industry.
It also comes at a time when Washington's bitter dispute with Pakistan is forcing it to reconsider its strategic alliances in the war in Afghanistan.
Lilit Gevorgyan, a Russia and CIS analyst for Jane's Information Group, suggests the United States is now looking to northern supply routes in Central Asia to bypass or entirely replace the southern Pakistani corridor as the main channel for supplying the Afghan campaign.
Political Realities Forge Uneasy Friendships
"Of course, with the troubles in Pakistan, the U.S. and NATO-led forces are looking for alternative options," she says. "In recent years, we've seen gradual deterioration of the safety and reliability of the Pakistani route, and obviously this makes the U.S. and NATO revisit the options in Central Asia."
The political realities presented by the ongoing row with Pakistan over its alleged complicity in Afghan terror attacks are not the first time that the U.S. has found itself forging uneasy friendships as a result of the war on terror.
After the 9/11 terror attacks, the U.S. government in late 2001 opened military bases in Kyrgyzstan and Uzbekistan to help support its war in Afghanistan. After meeting Karimov in February 2004, then-Defense Secretary Donald Rumsfeld praised the blossoming partnership, and dismissed concerns about Uzbek human rights, saying Washington's relations could not be based on a "single pillar."
Local residents carry the body of a victim killed in a brutal crackdown by government forces on protesters in the Uzbek town of Andijon in 2005.
But the open brutality of the 2005 Andijon massacre forced a rethink in U.S. policy. After calling for an international investigation into the incident, Washington was asked to vacate its Uzbek base at Karshi-Khanabad. Now, with the Pakistan relationship in tatters, Gevorgyan says Uzbekistan is regaining its appeal.
"At the moment, the U.S. hasn't got a base in Uzbekistan, so in comparative terms, neighboring Kyrgyzstan is much more important," she says. "However, in terms of potential, [Uzbekistan] is quite important. Compared to the [Manas] military base in Kyrgyzstan, it offers better conditions, because it offers an overland route to Afghanistan, and the transportation costs will be significantly less compared to the current terms in Kyrgyzstan."
Moving Toward A 'Multidimensional Relationship'
The United States must come bearing gifts before it can proceed with any reactivation of its Uzbek supply activities, however.
Accordingly, an appropriations committee in the U.S. Senate last week approved a motion to lift human rights restrictions that currently prohibit the United States from offering military assistance to the Uzbek government.
That motion will now become part of a broad foreign operations bill set to be voted on later this year.
The Obama administration has already called on Congress to support the waiver. (In perhaps an unwitting echo of Rumsfeld's remarks, the White House said Obama and Karimov in their phone conversation discussed their shared desire for a "multidimensional relationship.")
It is not clear what Uzbekistan would do with U.S. military aid. Tashkent has done most of its military spending with Moscow, buying $300 million worth of Russian-made equipment in the past decade.
But Gevorgyan says the United States is likely to make any aid conditional on its being spent on U.S.-approved equipment, and that Washington would be likelier to support the purchase of infantry weapons and armored personnel carriers, which could be used to support Afghan-supply efforts, rather than the air force upgrades and missile delivery systems that Uzbekistan craves.
Human Rights Vs. Military Concerns
Twenty rights organizations, including Human Rights Watch, Amnesty International USA, and the International Labor Rights Forum on September 28 signed a letter to U.S. Secretary of State Hillary Clinton asking her to put human rights before military concerns. The letter "strongly" urged Clinton "to oppose passage of the law and not to invoke this waiver."
In addition, some 60 activists staged a protest the same day outside a Washington business forum sponsored by the American-Uzbekistan Chamber of Commerce.
The protest movement against Karimov's regime has been gradually gaining strength. More than 60 prominent clothing labels have pledged to boycott textiles made with Uzbek cotton, which is often harvested using the forced labor of children as young as 10 years old.
And Karimov's daughter, Gulnara, was prevented from showing her new line of designer clothing when organizers of New York Fashion Week bowed to pressure from activists and barred her from participating. She later showed her wares at an alternative, invitation-only location.
Miriam Saage-Maass of the Berlin-based European Center of Constitutional and Human Rights, one of the signatories of the letter to Clinton, says European and American governments alike have an obligation to acknowledge human rights violations in the countries where they seek to do business.
At the same time, she acknowledges many countries, including Germany, have vested interests in Uzbekistan and are not always willing to back up their stated commitment to human rights.
"The German military has their main base for supplies to Afghanistan in Uzbekistan," she says. "And that is oftentimes used as an excuse for why they could not strongly oppose policies and other human rights violations in Uzbekistan. We don't think human rights issues should be less important than economic and military interests."
- Originally published by International Relations and Security Network (ISN)
- Hard Facts: The World Is Getting Better
- United Nations Can't Save the Oppressed, But It Can Give Them a Voice
- Obama's International Outsourcing
- Radical Islamist Cleric Anwar al-Awlaki Killed in Yemen
- Anwar Al-Awlaki's Death Major Victory For Counter-Terrorism
- United States Gaze Turns to Uzbeks
- Fiscal Union for the Euro: Some Lessons from History
- German Parliament Approves Hike in EU Loan Guarantees
- Preparing for Greece's Failure
- Despite Austerity Measures Greece Will Still Miss EU Budget Cut Targets
- Greece Working to Convince EU it Can Meet Austerity Demands
- Greek Parliament Approves New Property Tax
- Greeks to Face Further Tough Measures
- Albania's Unsettled Past
- Balkans Summit Extols Regional Co-Operation
- Erdogan Pushes for Common Future with Balkan States
- Turkey's Sinking Lira Defies Soaring Economy
- Kukan: Dialogue Not Barricades
- Arab Spring Turkish Harvest
- Iran at a Crossroads
- Iran's Support of Syria Is Backfiring
- The Mottled Relationship: Iran and Latin America
- Is It a Mistake to Draw Solace From Iran's Long Bomb Gestation Period?
- Arab Spring Added Pressures to Middle East Peace Process
- Israel Accepts Quartet Proposal to Resume Peace Talks
- Blocking Palestinian Statehood
- The Occupation That Time Forgot
- Israeli Parliamentarians Call for Annexation of West Bank
- U.S. Congress: Standard Bearer for Israeli Expansion
- Michele Bachmann 'Blames' Obama for Arab Spring
- Saudis Tussle Over Textbook
- Saudi Arabia Grants Women Limited Right to Vote
- Egypt Eyes New Arms Suppliers
- Saleh Return Deepens Crisis In Yemen
- Other Leaders Should Copy Brazil's Anti-graft Measures
- Obama's U.N. Omission: The War Next Door
- The Drug War Spreads the Bloodbath South
- Mexican Cartels and Pan American Games: A Threat Assessment
- Mexico: Death by Social Media
- Big Agriculture's Latin American Exploits
- Is Free Trade Good for Colombia
- China in Search of Energy Security
- Cuba's Domestic Reforms Surge Past Immobilized United States
- Fears Over Environmental Affects Prompt Court To Halt Mega-Dam Project
- Bolivian Workers Strike to Protest Controversial Highway
- Afghanistan is Obama's Gordian Knot
- Why Are Pakistan's Militant Groups Splintering?
- Questions Raised About Haqqani Network Ties with Pakistan
- Russia Strives to Clarify Vision for Central Asian Alliance
- Azerbaijan Faces Difficult Choice Between Turkey and Israel
- Azerbaijan Wrestles with Iranian Predicament
- In Post-Soviet Central Asia Russian Takes Back Seat
- Stabilizing Congo
- The Balkanization of Somalia
- Refugees Still Vulnerable in Southern Kordofan
- Al Shabaab Attacks Kill 16 at Key Somali Border Town
- Is Africa New Breeding Place for Terrorism?
- Somali Media Press on with Work Despite Deadly Challenges
- China-Indian Trade: Smoothening the Rough Edges
- The Survival of North Korea
- The 'Orchid Revolution' in Singapore
- Counterinsurgency and 'Op Sadhbhavana' in Jammu and Kashmir
- Indian Foreign Policy in Search of a Balance
- Philippines Struggles After Two Typhoons
- Typhoon Nesat Death Toll Rises to 20
- Obama's Dilemma: Foreign Policy and Electoral Realities
- The Theology of Armageddon
- Why Al-Qaeda Won
- Anti-Globalization Movement Endures
- WikiLeaks: The Game Changer
- Israel's Truths and Omissions on Vote for Palestine State
- How to Save Israel and the United States from Themselves
- Obama's Middle East Dilemma
- Palestinian Leader: Obama Wrong to Take Israel's Side
- Israeli Settlers: Never Shy About Taking Law Into Own Hands
- Israel: The Cost of Arrogance
- For Israeli Tycoons: New Strings Attached
- Israeli Innovation on Display
- Saudis to United States: You're Sleeping on the Couch Tonight
- Over 5,000 Killings In Syria Since March
- Iran Arrests Six for Supplying Information to BBC
- Iran: Naval-Gazing More Political Than Military
- Oman Assisting United States to Release Hikers in Iran
- Al-Jazeera: You're Not Alone
- Controversial Comeback For Egypt's Emergency Laws
- Turkish PM Erdogan Encounters Two Egypts on Historic Visit
- Turkey: Violence Casts Pall Over Constitutional Reform Efforts
- Turkey: How Much of a Safe Haven for Political Dissidents?
- Turkey's Neo-Ottoman Foreign Policy
- Libya to Have a New Government within 7-10 Days
- Libya Could Break Up Like Somalia
- Libya and the Bully Problem
- The Difficult Bit: The Arab Spring After Libya
- Middle East and North Africa Face Shortfall of Affordable Homes
- Lean Season Awaits Migrants Escaping Libya
- Kenya: NCDs and HIV Fight for Limited Resources
- Kenya: Thousands of Children to be Immunized Amid Polio Outbreak
- Horn of Africa Migrants Beaten, Deported, Imprisoned
- Rights Groups Report on Somalia Downplayed
- Congo Refugees Unwilling to Return Home
- The New Scramble for Africa
- Japan's PM Must Quell China's Fears About His Nationalism
- Fukushima Evacuees Slam Compensation Requirements
- Nuclear Data Feared Stolen in Hacks of Japanese Sites
- Second Lovers' Shooting Hits Largest Philippine Mall Operator
- Aquino Off to U.S. for Open Government Partnership Launch
- Aquino Orders Imprisonment of Former Philippine Military Comptroller
- Timeline of Australian Asylum-Seeker Debate
- Australia's Military Capabilities Up in the Air
- Islamist Rampage Blamed in Bangladesh Riots
- United States to Help Bangladesh Combat Bird Flu
- Indian Earthquake Prompts 'Wake-Up Call'
- Germany and the US: Toward a 'Special Relationship'?
- Britain - Russia: Beyond Politics
- Central Banks Lend Dollars to European Banks
- Eurozone Pushes Greece to Speed Up Economic Reforms
- S&P Downgrades Italy's Debt Rating
- Libyan Relationship With Italy Expected to Survive Regime Change
- UK Official Favors More Worker Say on Boardroom Pay
- London Court Charges UBS Trader With Fraud
- Denmark Elects First Woman Prime Minister
- Serbia's Markovic Fights Corruption and Public Skepticism
- Kosovo to Boost Privatizations
- Italy and Greece Ask Albania to Unify on European Agenda
- State Department Answers For Congressman's Criticism Of Mexico Policy
- Central American Migrants in Mexico
- Mexico Shock: Gunmen Dispose of 35 Bodies in Two Trucks
- Chevron Charged $18 Billion in Reparations to Ecuador
- Evolution of a Pakistani Militant Network
- Afghanistan: Rabbani Assassination May Peel Tajiks Away from Kabul
- United States Gaze Turns to Uzbeks
- Light at End of Afghan Tunnel Recedes
- Karachi's Long Summer of Violence
Available at Amazon.com:
Copyright 2011, iHaveNet.com - All Rights Reserved