Folks, I've got some good news and some bad news about the nation's ever-elusive quest for a sound energy policy.
The good news: Finally there's some under-the-radar bipartisan consensus in Washington. The bad news: Both parties are dead wrong.
This consensus is so strong that it's chipping away at our freedom of speech.
Consider this: Capitol Hill police officers dragged Josh Fox out of a House Energy and Environment subcommittee hearing on Feb. 1. They arrested Fox, the director of the Oscar-nominated documentary "Gasland," who by all accounts was simply trying to commit journalism. His charge? Unlawful entry to a public hearing on the environmental consequences of natural gas exploration. It turns out he wasn't alone. An ABC News team was also barred.
What's up? An ardent (and well-financed) belief on both sides of the aisle that hydraulic fracturing for natural gas — a process better known as "fracking" — is "cleaner" than coal and will result in greater U.S. energy independence. When President Barack Obama delivered his annual State of the Union address, he pledged his allegiance to continued exploration for natural "shale gas."
Fracking uses pressurized liquids to create cracks in shale deposits located deep underground to force pockets of natural gas to the surface. Recent discoveries in the Marcellus shale, a natural gas deposit that stretches from New York to West Virginia, suggest the U.S. could exploit this energy resource for what seems like an eternity by Washington standards: a century or more, if estimates prove accurate. But this seemingly endless form of energy will only be exploited rapidly and cheaply if critics and expensive regulations are kept at bay.
With mountaintop removal losing favor with the public, coal-fired power plants implicated in a host of health problems, and coal waste a burden no state wants to deal with, this "cleaner" form of energy — natural gas — has gotten a boost in the marketplace at a particularly auspicious time.
But it turns out gas has a host of environmental problems unique to fracking. Recent studies emerging from Cornell University suggest that gas could be far more heat-trapping than previously thought, and gas extracted by fracking could be twice as bad as coal from a climate perspective. This is because about 8 percent of the gas escapes into the atmosphere, where it is 105 times more potent than CO2 over its 20-year lifespan.
Then there's the groundwater contamination. Chemicals considered "trade secrets" for the gas industry (thanks to an energy policy developed in secret meetings by former Vice President Dick Cheney) are killing cattle and deer. Residents living near fracking wells complain of health problems. In some cases, they can literally light the water coming out of their taps on fire.
In addition, scientists have started to link earthquakes — such as the rare ones that have been shaking Ohio, New York, and Arkansas — with fracking.
It's frightening that only a handful of politicians are voicing strong concerns about this increasingly common gas extraction method, including Rep. Ed Markey, a Massachusetts Democrat, and Greg Ball, a Republican member of New York's state senate.
Why is this kind of courage so rare? In a word, money. The natural gas industry has spent hundreds of millions of dollars on campaign contributions over the last decade to smother efforts to regulate fracking, as Common Cause has documented.
We need to stop relying on fossil fuels and instead embrace a bold "Green New Deal" that generates significant jobs for unemployed workers around the country while ramping up already booming investments in wind, solar, and geothermal electricity.
Let's invest in a grid that would allow us to drive electric cars and buses powered by the wind, to heat our homes with the sun, and to totally break our dependence on oil. Imagine full employment, with millions of public- and private-sector jobs developing this clean-energy infrastructure.
This kind of jobs program would both benefit our workers and our local economy — and cut the umbilical cord, finally and completely, from foreign oil. And, unlike fracked gas, these resources would be truly limitless, benefiting us and future generations.
Daphne Wysham is a fellow at the Institute for Policy Studies where, among other things, she's researching alternative economic development strategies that don't include "extreme energy" resources such as fracked natural gas.
- Is the US 'Pivot' to the Pacific genuine?
- America's Constitutional Paralysis
- Those Bad Old Days Are Still with Us
- Fracking Perils
- American Decline Could Worsen with Focus on Iran and China
- Trans-Atlantic Military Cooperation Gets Complicated
- Don't Expect Too Much of the Next American President
- The Dignity of Corpses
- Momentum of Cynicism
- The United States Has Seen Much Worse
- 2011 Not the Very Worst, But Definitely in the Bottom 10
- Government Has Not Failed the People as It Did in 1860
- 2011 Not the Worst, But a Year Americans Would Like to Forget
- 2011 Ups and Downs: Gallup Polls Show Year Full of Pessimism
- American Border Law Enforcement Uses More Military Equipment
- Globalization and the Threat to the West
- When Currencies Collapse
- Balancing the East, Upgrading the West
- Alabama's Immigration Aftershock
- High Stakes for Immigration
- Education Cuts Aren't Smart
- A Nuclear Wake-up Call
- Global Corruption: Party Systems and the Control of Politicians
- International Security: Balanced Transition
- Global Health: The Beginning of the End of AIDS?
- United States and Europe Threaten Their Own Energy Independence
- Humanitarian Assistance: Dead or Live Aid
- With Fracking America Can Escape the Energy Trap
- Renewed Focus on Pacific Region Intended to Distract from Unrest at Home?
- Obama, Harper Stay Apart on Pipeline Issue, Ink Other Agreements
- Alabama Law Against Illegal Immigration Suffers Setback
- Major Economies Headed for Slowdown
- Is the National Security Complex Too Big to Fail?
- United States Hesitant to 'Reckon With Evil' in Syria
- Why Does America Defend the Weak and Small?
- Why We Need Not Envy China
- United States: Iraq Syndrome
- United States: The News of Empire
- Child Poverty and Access to Education: Hidden Costs on the Hispanic Community
- One Nation, Gone Awry
- Statue of Liberty Turns 125: Old Immigration Attitudes Alive as Well
- United States in Decline -- If We Allow It
Distributed via OtherWords (OtherWords.org)