David E. Miller
Jerusalem, Israel
As Palestinian unity talks mark their fifth week, Hamas Prime Minister Ismail Haniyah used the funeral of a party official in Gaza on Saturday for a policy statement that underscored the deep ideological rifts with his new coalition partner Mahmoud Abbas.
In the address, the Hamas leader signaled that Hamas - aligned with Iran and opposed to the existence of Israel - would have trouble finding a formula for a coalition with Fatah, which is backed by the West and is committed to reaching a negotiated agreement with the Jewish state. He urged Fatah to follow Hamas in turn to the Muslim world for political and financial support.
"To those who say there is no alternative to our ties with the occupation and the West, I say there is an alternative," Haniyah was quoted by pro-Hamas daily Falasteen as saying. "We have proven over the last five years that there is an Arab and Islamic alternative."
Under popular pressure, the two Palestinian movements are seeking to end four years of acrimony and reunite the Hamas-ruled Gaza Strip with the Fatah-ruled West Bank. But since they surprised the world by saying they had put differences aside and would from a coalition, talks have been bogged down over issues ranging from the staffing of a joint cabinet to ideology.
Analysts, however, said Haniyah's proposal is unrealistic, given how deeply reliant the Palestinian Authority (PA) is on Western financial aid, which is contingent on the PA remaining in the peace process.
"There's no way that the Palestinians can rely only on Arab funding," Mkhaimar Abusada, a political scientist at Al-Azhar University in Gaza, told The Media Line.
Haniyah said the Hamas government in Gaza has a monthly budget of about $25 million from unnamed Arab and Islamic sources, which he said demonstrated that the Palestinians could manage without Western aid. Funding for Hamas comes from Qatar as well as Iran, but other Gulf states such as Saudi Arabia don't help Hamas, said Abusada.
In a Washington Institute policy paper released in January, Ehud Yaari and Eyal Ofer cite the Israeli military intelligence claim that Iran accounts for around $100 million of Hamas' budget. Much of the rest comes from taxes and customs imposed on commodities entering the Gaza Strip through smuggling tunnels and official border crossings with Israel.
Whatever they are, the Hamas budget is tiny compared to the PA's annual budget of some $3 billion, half of which comes from the European Union and the U.S., and the rest from tax revenue, mostly collected by Israel and transferred to the PA. Arab contributions are negligible.
In rhetoric reminiscent of Hizbullah's in Lebanon, Haniyah said that a strategy must be created to protect the "weapons of resistance."
The new unity government is to be announced in Cairo this Tuesday, but no agreement has been reached on the identity of the government's prime minister. Fatah has officially nominated Salam Fayyad, the Fatah prime minister who is backed by the West. But for the same reason Hamas has refused to give him a role even as a cabinet minister.
"I never thought there was any chance of reconciliation between Hamas and Fatah," Hillel Frisch, a researcher at the Begin-Sadat Center for Strategic Studies at Tel-Aviv's Bar Ilan University, told The Media Line. "Today, there are basically two effective states in Gaza and the West Bank."
Frisch said that the notion of two separate political entities uniting is almost unheard of in the Arab world over the last 50 years, with the exception of the unity of north and south Yemen in 1990, which was followed by a bloody civil war in the 1990s.
"The idea of unity is very hard to achieve in reality," Frisch said. "The Palestinian political split of 2007 is a very durable phenomenon. The mainstay of the Palestinian Authority is its linkage with the West; while the mainstay of Hamas is its linkage with Iran."
But Abusada said that as long as the unity agreement is not renounced, Hamas will have no choice but to accept a prime minister who does not belong to the Islamic party and is acceptable to the West.
"Abbas knows that the new prime minister must be accepted by the West or there will be no national unity government," he said. "Abbas will not go back to a situation where the Palestinian government is internationally isolated."
The unity government's chances of success will depend on an agreed candidate for prime minister, Abusada said. Hamas' attitude toward Israel isn't relevant, because there is little prospect of peace negotiations resuming in the foreseeable future.
"Haniyah can say whatever he wants, this is just part of the political discourse," he said.
Sameeh Hammoudeh, a political scientist at Bir Zeit University in Ramallah, said that Hamas cannot publicly renounce its "weapons of resistance" which it considers its source of power on the street. But on the ground, Hamas has shown much more pragmatism than in its public statements.
"Hamas is quite similar to the PA in its willingness to act pragmatically and realistically in its Gaza government," Hammoudeh told The Media Line. "The resistance has failed, and there is no other choice for the Palestinians but diplomacy."
Hammoudeh predicted that Hamas will weaken in the upcoming parliamentary elections in comparison with the 2006 elections in which it won a majority. In the next government, he said, Hamas will not be able to veto negotiations with Israel.
- The Afghan Money Pit
- United States and Pakistan: Afghan Strategies
- Syrian President Bashar Al-Assad Admits Opposition Has Legitimate Grievances
- Syria: The Last Domino
- Turkey in Position to Lead Region Out of Tumultuous Century
- Lebanon's Opposition Feeling Threatened
- New Mexican President, Same Cartel War?
- Limited Options for United States in Yemen
- Yemenis Look To Tribes As Force For Change
- In Arab Spring Chill United Arab Emirates Puts Bloggers On Trial
- Hamas Leader Urges Fatah To Abandon West
- Somalia Power Struggle Could Intensify As Premier Quits
- Ousted Tunisian Leader Denies Charges Before Trial Begins In Absentia
- Tunisia Risks Controversy with Travel Ads
- New Insight Into Male Sex Work and HIV Epidemic in Africa
- Angola's 'Sans Papiers' Violently Deported In New Wave Of Expulsions
- Severe Drought and High Food Prices Hit Pastoralists In Africa
- The Hidden Cost Of Piracy In Somalia
- Flood-hit Mindanao Battles Water Lilies
- No Clear Route Out Of Servitude For Indentured Girls
- IMF Urges EU Leaders to Act Now on Greece Bailout
- European Finance Ministers Delay Second Greek Bailout To July
- European Union Assures Greece Bailout Funds
- Spaniards Protest Against Euro-Pact and Austerity Measures
- Greece Is The World's Least Credit Worthy Nation
- A World of Three Reserve Currencies -- Good or Bad?
- Europe Is Warning Us
- United States Has Trust Issues With China
- The United States - Russia Missile Defense Impasse
- Al Qaeda's New Video: A Message of Defeat
- Why Sudan's Peace Is in Jeopardy
- Egypt's Interim Rulers Learn the Democracy Game
- Egyptians Back Keeping Clerics Out of Politics
- House Pushes Obama on Libya
- Ignoring the War Powers Act
- Congress' Bipartisan Vice Is Cowardice
- Outgoing Robert Gates Outlines Future US Presence in Asia
- Robert Gates: Parting Shot on Afghan Policy
- An Invitation to Leave Afghanistan
- Obama Undermines Prospects for Middle East Peace
- Forty-Four Years Later, Israeli Attack on USS Liberty Provokes Strong Response
- Saudi Arabia Orders Men Out of Women's Clothing
- Gulf Becomes Fault Line for Sunni - Shiite Tensions
- Double Whammy for Bahraini Peace and Prosperity Drive
- The Human Cost of the Yemen Conflict
- Yemeni President Saleh Is Out But Yemen's Future Uncertain
- Turkey's Dilemma: Economy or Constitution
- Turkey: Elections and Strained U.S. Relations
- A Bad Day That Never Changes
- G8 Leaders Vow Billions in Aid to Egypt and Tunisia
- What 'Arab Spring'?
- Egyptian Muslim Brotherhood on the March -- Cautiously
- International Law, Palestinian Statehood and Israel's Security
- The Palestinian Move
- Israel's Borders and National Security
- Netanyahu's Message Is Self-Defeating
- Justice for a General -- At Last
- Protective Intelligence Lessons from an Ambush in Mexico
- Corruption: Why Texas Is Not Mexico
- Politics Behind Thai - Cambodian Conflict
- Re-examining the U.S. Withdrawal from Afghanistan
- The Bin Laden Operation: Tapping Human Intelligence
- Inside Pakistan After bin Laden
- The Kaspersky Kidnapping - Lessons Learned
- A Political Vision for Israel
- 3 Ongoing Conflicts You May Not Be Paying Attention To But Should
- Visegrad: A New European Military Force
- Turkey Setting Poor Example for Other Arab Nations
- IMF's Crisis-Management Challenge
- Dominique Strauss-Kahn Scandal an Embarrassment for France
- Going Cold on Bin Laden
- Chinese Investors Are Coming to Latin America
- Bin Laden's Death a Rorschach Test for the World
- Tough Times for Radical Islam
- China No. 1 in Five Years? Not so Soon
- Global Demography: Population Inflation
- Smallpox Threat Resurrected
- What's Next for al-Qaeda?
- Bin Laden's Death and U.S. Afghan Policy
- Engineering Programs React to Japan Nuclear Crisis
- Syria: At A Crossroads
- Iran: Authority Deficit
- NATO: Lessons From Libya
- United Kingdom: Forged In The Crucible Of Austerity
- United Kingdom: Democracy As Conflict Prevention
- United Kingdom: Military Defense Test Case
- British Defense Policy: MoD Mess
- United States - Pakistani Relations Beyond Bin Laden
- Bin Laden Death Raises Big National Security Questions
- Where the United States Goes from Here
- Welcome to Paybackistan
- Osama Bin Laden: Got Him!
- Will Bin Laden Death Affect Afghan Exit Timetable?
- Pakistan Unaware of Osama bin Laden Presence? Don't Believe It
- Congress Praises Obama and Troops After Bin Laden Death
- Strategic Implications of Osama bin Laden's Death
- Hamas Leader Urges Fatah To Abandon West
- Final Letter to Osama bin Laden
- Justice Has Been Done
- President Obama on Osama Bin Laden
- Bin Laden and the Return of Common Sense
- Osama Bin Laden Dead
- Osama bin Laden Aftermath
- The Future of the Liberal World Order
- Why DOHA Trade Negotiations Are Doomed and What We Should Do About It
- Who's Afraid of the International Criminal Court?
- 5 Economies Worse Off Than the United States
- The Rise of the Islamists
- The Black Swan of Cairo
- Understanding the Middle East Revolutions of 2011
- Parsing the Differences Between Tunisia, Egypt and Libya
- The Heirs of Nasser
- Terrorism After the Arab Revolutions
- Egypt Can't Seem To Shed Bad Habits
- How Hosni Mubarak's Reign Came to an End
- Libya: The Two Obamas
- How to Save the Euro and the European Union
- Recalibrating Homeland Security
- Getting the Military Out of Pakistani Politics
- Power and Politics in an Autonomous Latin America
- The Sacred and the Dead
- China and the End of the Deng Dynasty
- United States - Pakistan Partnership in Peril
- Islamist Militancy in a Pre- and Post-Saleh Yemen
- Iraq, Iran and the Next Move
- World's Most Dangerous Man? Syrian Leader Makes Strong Case
- A View from Syria
- Libya and Beyond: Why not Every Nation for Itself?
- Confidence Remains Strong in Global Markets Despite Crises
- Latin America Provides Cautionary Tale for Middle East
- The Arab Risings, Israel and Hamas
- America Should Exercise Pragmatic Idealism in the Arab World
- Richard Goldstone Recants His Report Attacking Israel
- Middle East: Autocratic Deafness
- A Brave Libyan Stands Up Against Rape
- Is Pacific Fish Safe to Eat After the Disaster in Japan?
- Demand and Disasters Complicate Global Energy Picture
- Global Arms Trade: A Vortex of Death and Wealth
- Arms Trade: a Filter, Not a Dam
- Organised Crime: Joint Responsibility
- It's Time, Mr. President: A Time for Clarity
- Chances for a New US Foreign Policy Not Taken
- Did the United States Give Up on Libya?
- The Gulf Region: Anger Management
- Saudi Arabia: Guarding The Fortress
- Israel's Recent Political Actions Aren't Going Over Well
- Israel: If Not Now, When?
- A 'Reverse Beauty Pageant' for Tyrants
- African Hydropower: Damming at What Cost?
- United States - Pacific Relations: Pacific-Minded
- 7 Problems That Could Derail the Global Economic Recovery
- Technology Powers Revolutions and Saves Lives
- Russia Stocks Soar on Rising Oil Prices
- Japan: Heavy History
- China: Weak Impetus for Change
- China Sees the Evil of Plastic Bags
- Pakistan: Educating For Tolerance
- Immaculate Intervention: The Wars of Humanitarianism
- AQAP and the Vacuum of Authority in Yemen
- Japan Quake and Tsunami Among Most Costly of All Time
- China's Economy the Key to Quelling Social Unrest
- Syria's Stalled Revolution
- Prudent Multilateralism in Libya
- The Thinly Veiled Campaign for Regime Change
- Unexpected Revelations in Libyan Intervention
- President Obama's Most Amazing Libyan Achievements
- Libya: Insanity Dawn
- Obama's Half-a-Loaf War
- Obama Said He Doesn't Mind Criticism on Libya Mission in Latin America
- What Happened to the American Declaration of War?
- The Power of Giving Back
- Safety on the Cheap
- Egyptian Elections: the Sooner, the Better
- The Libyan Question: What Now?
- Obama's 'Goldilocks' Doctrine
- War Number Three
- Un-Unified Oppositions in Bahrain and Yemen
- Japanese Earthquake Brings Back Sad Memories
- 5 Reasons Investors Should Not Bail on Japan
- Japan's Nuclear Crisis Reignites Safety Debate
- Military Involvement in Libya Costs Taxpayers Millions
- United Nations Relevance
- A Mother's Confession on Mothers' Day
- Middle East Crisis: Today's Events in the Middle East
- World's Costliest Disaster
- Japan Crisis: Video Reports 3/23/2011
Available at Amazon.com:
Aftermath: Following the Bloodshed of America's Wars in the Muslim World
Displacement and Dispossession in the Modern Middle East (The Contemporary Middle East)
The End of History and the Last Man
The Clash of Civilizations and the Remaking of World Order
The Tragedy of Great Power Politics
The End of the Free Market: Who Wins the War Between States and Corporations?
Running Out of Water: The Looming Crisis and Solutions to Conserve Our Most Precious Resource
Bottled and Sold: The Story Behind Our Obsession with Bottled Water
Water: The Epic Struggle for Wealth, Power, and Civilization
At War with the Weather: Managing Large-Scale Risks in a New Era of Catastrophes
Friendly Fire: Losing Friends and Making Enemies in the Anti-American Century
Dining With al-Qaeda: Three Decades Exploring the Many Worlds of the Middle East
Uprising: Will Emerging Markets Shape or Shake the World Economy
Copyright 2011, AHN - All Rights Reserved