A Kuwaiti man accused of using Twitter to defame the Prophet Muhammad has ignited a debate in the tiny but wealthy Gulf country about imposing the death penalty for the crime of blasphemy.
Muslim preachers, lawmakers and international human rights groups have all jumped into the debate, which erupted after Hamad Al-Naqi, a member of the country's Shiite minority, was arrested March 28 on charges of "defaming the Prophet" in tweets posted on the social-networking website. He has denied making the posts, claiming that somebody hacked into his Twitter account.
Under Article 111 of Kuwait's penal code, which prohibits defamation of religion, Al-Naqi faces up to one year's imprisonment and a fine. But soon after he was arrested calls emerged for Kuwait to follow its bigger neighbor, Saudi Arabia, and impose the death penalty for such crimes.
Within days, Kuwait's parliament responded to the public outcry and gave preliminary backing to a capital punishment amendment last Thursday. Forty six out of 52 deputies voted in favor. But the fight is still on: The amendment must go to a second vote two weeks after the first and then be approved by the government and Kuwait's ruler Sheikh Sabah al-Ahmad Al-Sabah.
On Tuesday, the London-based human rights group Amnesty International weighed in against the change.
"All eyes are on Kuwait's recently-elected legislators. They must immediately scrap any plans to introduce the death penalty for blasphemy," said Ann Harrison, deputy director of Amnesty's Middle East and North Africa Program. "On no account should he be sentenced to death."
Al-Naqi's case echoes that of Hamza Kashgari, a Saudi journalist accused of insulting the Prophet Mohammad over Twitter last February who faces possible beheading. In both cases the accused either denied the crime or in Kashgari's case quickly repented, but in each case they had set off a firestorm of public anger because their remarks had been broadcast on one of the world's biggest social media platforms.
Many politicians, journalists and public figures use Twitter to debate events and share gossip. The most popular figures have hundreds of thousands of followers.
Although local media have quoted what they say are Al-Naqi's remarks about Mohammad, they have been erased from Twitter and can't be verified, according to the Reuters news agency. "I would never attack the Holy Prophet," Al-Naqi, who is now being held in pre-trial detention, was quoted as saying.
Kuwait, whose population is about 70% Sunni and 30% Shiite, practices a more mild form of Islam than Saudi Arabia. Its constitution protects freedom of belief, even if individual laws impose limits and Islam is designated the state religion. In addition to laws against blasphemy, others ban apostasy and especially proselytizing.
"While the number of situations to which these laws applied was extremely limited, the government actively enforced them, particularly the prohibition on non-Muslim proselytizing of Muslims," the U.S. State Department said in it latest annual International Freedom of Religion report.
In fact, under Kuwaiti law Al-Naqi should be spared his life no matter what parliament decides. International Covenant on Civil and Political Rights prohibits governments from imposing a heavier penalty than in force at the time an alleged offence was committed.
"If it emerges that Hamad al-Naqi's Twitter account was indeed hacked then he has no case to answer; otherwise he is being held solely for exercising his right to freedom of expression and, unless charged with an internationally recognizable offence, he must be released immediately," said Amnesty's Harrison.
But lawmakers may have trouble holding back the tide of public opinion. At a rally at Kuwait City's Erada Square at the end of March, legislators and others vied with each other over who could offer the biggest promises and most severe penalties for blasphemy, Al-Seyassah daily reported.
Lawmaker Adel Al-Damghi said blasphemers should be punished by public execution. Shafi Al-Ajmi said that anyone who harms the Prophet is indirectly harming God and therefore punishments should be severe. Osama Al-Shaheen said blasphemy is a chronic problem and should be treated severely. Abdullah Al Barghash urged Kuwaiti to demand that lawmakers who oppose the capital punishment amendment to quit parliament.
"Parliament should be dissolved if such a draft law is not approved," added Ahmad Al-Azmi.
But not all the lawmakers are prepared to accept the death penalty. Ahmed Lari said during the parliamentary debate that amendments fail to explain what constitutes blasphemy and that Muslim scholars differ in opinion in that regard. "Issues pertaining to execution should not be hurried until there is definitive evidence of the crime," Lari was quoted as saying, adding that the amendment made no distinction between Muslims and non-Muslims.
Jamal Al-Shihab, the minister of Waqf and Islamic Affairs, urged parliament not to rush to approve of the law because of religious sensitivities. Despite this, all the cabinet members present, including Al-Shihab, voted in favor of the amendment.
- IMF Sees Another Year of Tepid Growth for Middle East
- Rare Glimpse into Middle East Middle Class Angst
- Arab Spring May Not Bring Democracy and Modernization After All
- The Arab World's Democracy Deficit
- Salafists Could Roll Arab Spring Back to Arab Winter
- Tunisia's Rulers Squeezed Between Salafists and Liberals
- Militias Still Have the Run of Libya
- Time to Rein in Libya's Militias
- Al-Qaddafi-Era Rivalries Haunt Libya
- Israel's New Strategic Environment
- Palestinians Ban Sale of Israeli Produce
- Israel's Defense Establishment: Overmanned?
- Egypt is Focus of Israeli Security Worries
- How to Deter an Irrational Nuclear Iran
- The Last Straw for Iran's Economy?
- Iran: The Undersea World of Ali Khamenei
- Iranian Opinion Key to Avoiding War
- Iran's Strategy
- Iran: Dawn of the Female Ninjas
- Like Father Like Son in Syria
- Syria: Kofi Annan Can Do It
- Civil Society at Heart of Syrian Refugee Response
- Is Libya Dissolving?
- Kuwait Debates Death for Blasphemers
- Turkey Weighs Military Presence in Syria
- Rights Activists Aim to Stop Bahrain Grand Prix
- Jordan: No Nukes in Our Backyard
- IMF Aid Becomes Egyptian Political Football
- Death Penalty Stalks the Middle East and North Africa
- Arms Appetite in Middle East and North Africa Remains Strong
- Web Grows in Middle East and North Africa But So Does Censorship
- Al-Assad Revives Father's Torture Techniques
- Military Intervention in Syria is a Bad Idea
- The Great Syrian Divide
- Syria's Systematic Torture
- The Screws Tighten on Syria's Assad
- Assad Is Not All That's Toxic About Syria
- Tales of Horror From Syrian Refugees
Copyright © 2012 AHN - All Rights Reserved