Arieh O'Sullivan
Jerusalem, Israel
It turns out that the Western Wall of the ancient Second Temple Mount wasn't built during the reign of King Herod after all and that the place was a building site even when Jesus visited it.
Archeologists have uncovered what they say is evidence that the massive retaining wall of the ancient Temple Mount wasn't even started until at least 20 years after Herod died in 4 B.C. The new findings challenge the perception that the enormous edifice, the largest construction endeavor in the ancient Holy Land, had been solely the work of the ancient king, known as Herod the Builder.
Herod is known as one of the great project engineers of the ancient world as well as for his legendary efforts to hunt down baby Jesus. Halfway into his reign, he decided to renovate the Temple in Jerusalem and greatly enlarge the mount it stood on in one of the biggest construction projects in the Roman Empire.
Clearing out an ancient drainage channel 2,000 years later, archeologists got a glimpse of the ancient construction methods when they reached the foundation stones of the massive wall. Because the stones, some weighing as much as 50 tons each, needed to rest on firm ground, a residential neighborhood that existed at the time was razed in order to reach the bedrock. Remnants of this wall above ground are revered as Judaism's most sacred sight.
Excavations revealed a rock-hewn ritual bath under a foundation stone that had been filled with debris. This allowed archeologists for the first time to examine directly underneath the wall where they found 17 simple bronze coins and three oil lamps from the first century A.D. That bewildered them.
"Four of the latest coins were minted under the Roman governor of Jerusalem, named Valerius Gratus in the 15/16 C.E. This is 20 years after Herod's death so at least the western wall, or this segment of the western wall, was constructed long after Herod passed away," archeologist Ronny Reich told The Media Line.
"It took generations to build, not a few years. It adds something to history of construction of the largest edifice ever built in this country," he said. "The project is Herod's. We will not take it away from him. He foresaw it. He planned it. He provided the means for 18 years of construction. But he didn't see its completion."
Reich said Herod had apparently been motivated to take on the massive complex because Jerusalem was growing and more room was needed for the tens of thousands of pilgrims who would converge on the city with thousands of animals to sacrifice.
"It also matched his own glory and that suited him," said Reich, a Haifa University professor who has been excavating in Jerusalem for over 40 years.
Until now, archeologists have only had the written record of Jewish-Roman historian Josephus, who said the construction of the Temple project was only completed during the reign of King Agrippa II, Herod's great-grandson, in the 50s A.D., meaning the whole project took over 70 years.
"Josephus and his figures are controversial among scholars. So here we have an independent archeological datum telling us that indeed it took a long time," Reich said.
The excitement among the archeologists is still apparent because the greatness of this discovery wasn't a treasure, but knowledge. It was always assumed that the construction was a running project for generations, and their find finally proved it.
"Discoveries are never spectacular, like items of silver or gold," Reich said. "But if I learn something else and close the gap of knowledge on Jerusalem, then I am satisfied."
Historians say that Herod took on the project in the 18th year of his reign (22 B.C.). The new temple structure itself, built around an older one that had been standing for hundreds of years, took about a year and a half to build. It originally stood on a platform measuring some 250 meters (yards) by 250 meters built by the Hasmonean kings.
Herod's plans called for a magnificent new massive platform more than double the size about 500 meters long and 280 meters wide with huge retaining walls creating an artificial surface for worship.
Reich said the evidence also indicated, in his eyes, that construction probably began on the eastern side, followed by the southern and northern walls built, and ending with the western wall. Their excavations were directly underneath the Robinson Arch, which served as a major entryway into the Temple Mount, meaning that it too must have dated from well after 15 C.E.
The findings even indicate that during the time of Jesus, the Temple Mount was a construction site. Reich said that the Gospel of John even indicated that it took a long time to build.
"Jesus answered them, 'Destroy this temple, and in three days I will raise it up.' The Jews then said, 'It has taken forty-six years to build this temple, and will you raise it up in three days?' (John 2:19)
"I don't know if this figure is accurate but it does corroborate our findings. It took more than the days of Herod, more than twice the time to construct. The archeological evidence now corroborates these texts," Reich said.
For all the time it took to build, tragically, the edifice stood for less than a generation. The Romans destroyed it during the revolt of the Jews in 70 A.D.
Twitter: @ihavenet
- Major Economies Headed for Slowdown
- Is the National Security Complex Too Big to Fail?
- Squeezed By Israel, Palestinians Aim to Collect More Taxes
- Herod Started The Temple But Great-Grandson Finished the Job
- Are Israelis Less Willing to Make Sacrifices?
- Israel Faces Chill Wind from Europe, Central Banker Warns
- Palestinians Evoke '60s Freedom Riders in Bus Protest
- Egyptian Elections in Doubt as Violence Returns to Tahrir
- Egypt's Generals Fail to Stem Human Rights Abuses
- Egyptian Citizens Take Up Arms Amid Insecurity
- Rule of Law Under Siege in Egypt
- Sinai Bedouin Join Al-Qaeda Out of Bitterness, Not Ideology
- Tunisia's New Premier Faces Islamic Test
- Rebuilding Libya
- Syria, Iran and the Balance of Power in the Middle East
- How United States Could Encourage Peace in Syria
- Lebanese Ready to Take Up Arms Against Syrian Incursions
- Jordan to Erect Refugee Camps for Fleeing Syrians
- Countering Iran in the Covert World
- Is Iran Iraq All Over Again?
- Military Action Might Be The Only Option With Iran
- An Attack Would Only Strengthen Iran's Influence
- Diplomacy Best Option in Dealing with Iran's Nuclear Aims
- Only Threat of Military Action Will Stop Iran
- Incite Change From Within Iran
- Iran: Learn the Lessons from Iraq
- Iran: Let Opposition Groups Do the Hindering
- Jordan in Bid to Create Hub with Airport Expansion
- United States Hesitant to 'Reckon With Evil' in Syria
- Surprise! Iran Has Nukes
- As The World Turns and The Centrifuges Whirl in Iran
- Two-State Solution is Only Solution in the Middle East
- A Silver Lining for Palestine?
- Gilad Shalit's Release Emboldens Netanyahu's Iran Mandate
- Iran Plot: A Pretext for War
- Israel: Iranian War Fever-Pitch Debate Blasted Wide Open
- Israel: In Quest For Cool, Tel Aviv Taps Tech
- Middle East: Buffeted by the Winds of Change
- Tunisia Elections: The Real Thing This Time
- Libya: Victory, Tragedy, Legacy
- Fitting End for Libya's Bloody Dictator
- Bahrain's Courageous Doctors
- Syrian City Of Hama Under Attack
- Syria Agrees to Withdraw Military from Streets Under Arab League Deal
- United States: Iraq Syndrome
- French Push Hard to Clinch Jet Deal with UAE
- Israel: Where Pilgrims Once Trod, Sewage Flows
- Dead Sea's 7 Wonders Bid Spurs Politics and Patriotism
- Europe's Woes Make Their Way Across the Mediterranean
- Egypt and Tunisia Try to Lure Back Their Tourists
- Guide to Egypt's First Post-Revolution Elections
- Egyptians Feel Less Secure on Streets and in Wallets
- Seven Billion People: So Why Do Some Fear Population Decline?
- Democracy in Revolution: the Mediterranean Moment
- Riots and Revolutions in the Digital Age
- When Do You Know You Have Crossed a Watershed?
- Global Financial Regulation: Goal Many Espouse But Can It Be Done?
- Forging a Lasting Peace
- Why We Still Need Nuclear Power
- Arab Spring: Fall Update
- Libya and Iraq: The Price of Success
- Libya and Tunisia Still Face Obstacles on the Road to Democracy
- Tunisians Celebrate Elections, Worry What Follows
- Powder in the Eyes in Algeria
- Gaddafi Took Knowledge of Where Bodies Were Buried to the Grave
- Gaddafi's Death: Mission Accomplished!
- Gadhafi Bites the Dust ... What's Next?
- What's Next for United States - Libyan Relations?
- Qadhafi's Death Leaves Libyan Oil Industry Uncertain
- Obama Sets New Precedent with Role in Getting Gadhafi
- Libya: Now the Hard Part Starts
- Post Gaddafi Libya: What Happens Next?
- Libya: The True Costs of Humanitarian Intervention
- Libya: Humanitarian Intervention Comes of Age
- As Arab Awakening Gets Messy, US Involvement Weakens
- Obama Risks an Oil Opportunity
- Gaddafi's Grim End
- Gaddafi Just Another Tyrant Who Painted Himself Into a Corner
- Lack of Education Hinders Arab Economies
- Mecca Pilgrimage Ripe for Sectarian Clash
- Iraq: American Imperialism? Please
- Mixed Emotions as the United States Leaves Iraq
- United States Iraqi Pullout Whets Iranian Appetite for Trouble
- The Broken Contract: Inequality and American Decline
- The Wisdom of Retrenchment: America Must Cut Back to Move Forward
- Putting a Face on Iran Policies a Study in Frustration
- UNESCO Vote to Admit Palestinian Authority Stirs Tempest
- A Shift in Israel-Hamas Relations?
- The Problem Is Palestinian Rejectionism
- Israel's Bunker Mentality
- United States Law Enforcement Chiefs to Israel
- Israelis and Palestinians Deploy New Technology in Fighting
- Senator Landrieu: Don't Cut Aid to Israel
- NATO Reluctant for Military Intervention in Syria
- Why Syria is Not Libya
- Egyptian Blogger Finally Becomes Cause Celebre
Copyright 2011, AHN - All Rights Reserved