The eyes of the world were turned to the fishing village of Wukan in
But instead of the expected police crack-down, after 11 days of siege the
For others, it was confirmation of the widely held belief that while local officials are often venal, the party's top leaders still have the wisdom of Solomon - if you can attract their attention.
Even more surprising was the promise that villagers of Wukan would be allowed to elect their local council in a free and fair poll. In principle, villages have this right, but in practice, the result is always decided by the party hierarchy. Images of the Wukan ballot box circulated through the Chinese internet, often with a simple message attached: "I support."
"But the villagers have begun to vote, governing themselves. Does this not tell us that Chinese in other areas can do this too? I want to ask everyone why they can't."
In the end, on
I was one of the first foreign reporters to reach Wukan in December, and recently I returned to the area. There is plenty of anger around, as villagers and farming communities bear the brunt of
Another nearby village, Wanggang, rose up in January for a similar reason to Wukan: corrupt local officials had stolen from the village fund, they said.
But the uprisings in Haimen and Wanggang have had very different outcomes to Wukan. In Haimen, at least three people were still in detention three months after the unrest, according to villagers who said the authorities had threatened to imprison anyone who talked about what had happened.
Unlike in Wukan, the root of the complaint in Haimen is environmental. The government wants to build a second, giant, coal-fired power station outside the village. But residents believe the effluent from the first plant is poisoning their water and triggering unusually high rates of cancer.
"Life here cannot get any worse," said one fisherman. "There are no fish, just look at the water. Our catch has fallen by 80 per cent and we are left sitting here, waiting to die. Some of us are actually starving and that is no exaggeration."
Since the protest, plans for the second plant have been suspended, but not terminated. Construction workers are now employed at the first plant, adding two additional generators. Villagers do not believe the government will back down. The project is worth
"The difference between Haimen and Wukan is that Haimen does not have a strong protest leader, like Wukan," said Fu Ronghua, an NGO researcher. "Other villagers fail to stand firm and united for a long time, or when under pressure."
In the second protest village, Wanggang, a government team is investigating grievances, and the former party secretary has been suspended. "The government has not detained or threatened us, and we are not worried about a crackdown, we are only worried they will not solve our complaints," said Li Zhikai, 37, an activist. "Lots of villages have recently gone on protests to try to win more benefits for themselves. We want to keep our heads up and fight for our rights."
There are many reasons why the Wukan protest succeeded and other failed, said Zhang Jiancheng, 26, one of the village's leaders. "Our village is full of Chinese from
Wukan has laid a blueprint for other villages to try to follow, including one for holding credible elections. But ultimately Wukan's legacy may be symbolic. Other villages have seen their protests fail for lack of unity and focus, and because villagers can often be placated by a combination of compensation and intimidation.
The fall of Bo Xilai
Charisma is in short supply among modern Chinese leaders, but Bo Xilai, the
He courted publicity with an anti-corruption drive. To please the older generation, he made the 32 million people of the municipality of
To western observers, Bo seemed a dead cert for a place in the Politburo Standing Committee, the heart of Chinese power. But in a party which values consensus and preserving the status quo, he stood out.
It is said that the chain of events which led to his dismissal began when he learned that his family was being investigated for corruption.
According to reports on the internet, he is said to have fired his police chief and right-hand man, Wang Lijun, who then sought refuge in the US consulate in
No one can be sure what information about his boss Wang handed over to the US diplomats. That uncertainty alone would have been enough to destroy him.
Much has been made of Bo's leftist leanings, his revival of Mao-era songs and ideology. Since his toppling, the 'red' songs have largely stopped, and some Maoist websites have been blocked by the censors.
But Bo gave the impression of a man playing to the crowd, rather than a genuine ideologue. Perhaps it was this, his popularity, that worried his colleagues.
With such a shining star on the Politburo Standing Committee, perhaps
- China's Social 'Harmony' More Fragile Than It Appears
- Reassessing the Wukan 'Revolution'
- China: The Next Great Leap
- America's Pacific Logic
- The United States in Korea: A Strategy of Inertia
- Despite Missile Failure, North Korea is Still the Big Winner
- North Korea's Failed Fireworks
- On Iran, India Is of Two Minds
- Frightening Prospects for Afghan Women
- Afghanistan: Living in the Kabul Bubble
- Laos: Communal Land Titles Could Save More Than Forests
- Asia Is Up in Arms
- Inching Toward Progress on the North Korean Nuke Problem
- Kim Jong-il and the Normalization of Japan-North Korea Relations
- Japan and Mongolia: Geographic Challenges to Free Trade
- How Myanmar Liberates Asia
- Reassessing International Access in Myanmar
- The Kachin's Role in Myanmar - Chinese Relations
- Afghanistan and the Long War
- Death and Public Relations
- Indonesia: Facing the Stigma of Leprosy
- Learning from Japan's Tsunami
- North Korea's Pivot
- Divided Over North Korean Refugees
- Japan and India: Making Up for Lost Time
- Assessing China's Strategy
- Chinese Computer Games
- Beating China, Corporate Style
- The Future of U.S. - Chinese Relations
- How to Mend U.S. - China Ties
- Afghanistan: War Downsized
- A Look at Central Asia's Drug War
- Pakistan: No Road Home for Sindh Flood Victims
- Maoist Ex-Combatants Threaten to Step Up Protests
- Nepal Celebrates Less-Rowdy Festival of Colors
- Isolation and Poverty Loom for Asia's Aging Population
- Piracy, not China, the Real Issue in Indian Ocean
- Chinese Benefits from Investing in Rason
- China's Looming Pension Crisis
- Don't Expect India to Come to the Rescue
- Burma: After 50 Years of Military Rule Signs Of Real Hope
- Afghanistan: Moving Toward a Distant Endgame
- Drug Problem Adding to Challenge in Afghanistan
- Philippines Weighs Increased U.S. Military Presence
- Philippine Airstrike Targets Militant Network
- Indonesia's Fuel Subsidy Problem
- Australia Rises Up
- Japan's Energy Vulnerability After the Nuclear Disaster
- Henoko and U.S. Military: History of Dependence and Resistance
- Indonesia: No Rice, No Way
- Philippines: Mapping 'Blind' Fault Lines
Copyright © 2012 Tribune Media Services