Pixels and Sand
Mike Gonzalez, Crispy Gamer
Several modern shooters like the "Call of Duty" series, the latest "Medal of Honor," and now "Battlefield 3" market themselves as the real hardcore deal, as immersive experiences reminiscent of cordite-choked sands.
I spent some time at a firing range with real-life weapons to see how they buck up to their video game counterparts in terms of measurable stats.
AMMO ORGANIZATION AND RELOADING
Yes, for obvious reasons auto-ammo organization is just one of those evils needed for gameplay. Is it as easy to reload an actual weapon under fire? In a nice quiet room? Yes. Under normal combat conditions? No.
Even expecting the report of a blast, I was still flinching a bit, and that was knowing no one was shooting at me. I know rage (or panic) would be imminent in the case of a jam. Under fire is definitely not the time you'd want anything to stop working.
Picking up extra ammo would be pretty exciting. It would be fantastic to be able to run over a corpse and have those extra magazines Velcro onto you automatically. No, this would mean running out into the enemy firing zone (how else did they get hit?), dropping your weapon and rummaging through straps and bags for extra ammo. So, no, it's not as easy.
We really take for granted the multivariable process undertaken by the left trigger (L2 for you PS3 guys). I especially love the "COD" mechanic of aim-and-release, where aiming is pretty automated one target after another. I've taken down whole squads in a matter of seconds using that, and I even kind of feel bad when they're roping down from a helicopter.
On some factors, aiming can be easy in reality as well. Opposite the Garand, firing the AR-15 (M16) and AK-47 Tactical (Kalash) -- the difference between hard plastics versus solid wood and steel -- was a breeze! They're light and the M16 had a red dot sight while the Kalash had an ACOG.
I even had a mildly badass moment when I blew apart two targets with the Kalash. I can imagine, though, that after holding any heavier weapons awhile and factoring in things like combat fatigue, heat and, of course, being shot at, aiming might not be as easy anymore.
Aiming with pistols was also comparatively as easy. With low kickback and considerably less weight, a steady hand can definitely knock some impressive shots. Though hitting the same spot in succession while rapid firing isn't quite as easy, though. And yes, I had the chance to fire a Desert Eagle. No, I did not dual-wield them like "COD" because I like my wrists, and no, they're not practical. It was like shooting the Garand one-handed.
Again, on some points, shooters were actually accurate. Modern weapons have minimal kickback, not like the manhandling Garand. That results in being able to mark another target quickly after a shot. This also means you can still maintain effective fire at increased rates even on burst firing.
But in terms of firing proficiently, that's when the details really start to count. You have to maintain several variables at a constant -- at this point, R2 and L2 start to look attractive. Even with experience, I would imagine maintaining laser-precise aim in full auto would be more than a challenge.
The most egregious inaccuracy that occurs in all shooters, though, involves shotguns. There's a whole generation of gamers who think shotguns are only effective within 10 feet of your target; a weapon only to be used for intimate candlelit moments with the enemy when things get really close and messy.
I've been disappointed several times in "Modern Warfare 2" online when getting a clean mark on a target with my Striker, and having it be as effective as a confetti cannon outside a range of about 10 feet. I know buckshot spreads -- but it doesn't turn into fairy dust, either.
When firing a Mossberg 590 on the range, I was even hitting targets at around 70 feet out. So, yeah, shotguns will hurt and kill at long distances.
The most interesting piece that I came across in researching for this article was a combat firearms report card from a Marine named
Maybe shooters should consider portraying this problem a little more since it is a reality.
The technical aspects of combat, such as the weapons themselves and all their minutiae, were easy enough to research, but when it came down to how actual combat occurs, it was surprisingly difficult to find sources at first.
In games, combat takes place on the invisible linear path chock-full of bad guys in large standoffs. It wasn't until I thought to type in "firefight" in YouTube that I got a real look at honest combat.
Under fire in these videos, troops were always safely in cover and shooting back while calling in support from fly-bys or armor. In video games you see several of your NPC buddies get shot down running from cover to cover. In real-world videos from the front, preserving life seems to be the priority, with everyone safely in cover.
Notable, as well, is the lack of movement. There will be 10-minute spans of video where troops are just hunkered down, safely providing suppressing fire. When have you ever stood in one spot in a FPS for more than two minutes? There is, however, one exceptional video (http://bit.ly/crispyrocket) where a troop runs out of cover to fire a LAW rocket (Note: This video contains actual war footage and may not be for the faint of heart). With frightening joy, when compared to the majority of video, you'll see this is a very exceptional case, reminiscent more of online antics than actual trained combat.
On the report card,
As opposed to the mass organized engagements we see in "Battlefield" and "COD," actual combat overseas seems to be much more constrained. If anything, what we're presented with echoes more the tradition of large-scale WWII engagements. And no, not once did I see someone jumping onto a helicopter at the last second.
Although I have suggested that developers take some of these realities into consideration, by no means would I want them to try to get every detail of war rendered into 1080p. The core aim of a game is to be a game and provide entertainment, and this will always take priority.
War and combat aren't pretty at all. Shooters sometimes like to play on themes of patriotism to add poignancy to the experience, but from what I've read and seen from troops, their primary goal is to survive. War has been a necessity in the past, but it also involves a lot of kids dying, so, I'm not sure just how real we'd want our games to get.
Available at Amazon.com:
Videogaming & Video Game Reviews
- 'PixelJunk Shooter 2: The Belly of the Beast'
- Pixels and Sand
- Sneak Peek at DC Universe Online With Chris Cao
- Thought Leaders: Orion Granatir
- Combat Duality in 'Dragon Age II'
- 'Jikandia: The Timeless Land'
- Exclusive Look at Homefront
- GDC 2011: Sneak Peek of Battlefield 3
- Talking Portal 2 With Valve Software's Erik Wolpaw
- Nathan Camarillo of Crytek Talks Crysis 2 and CryEngine 3
- 'Two Worlds II'
- Peter Molyneux Talks Fable III and Commitment to PC Gaming
- There's an App for That Game
- Talking Tech Tactics With Football Manager 2011
- 'Kingdom Hearts Re:coded'
- 'Dead Space 2'
- 2K Sports Announces 'NHL 2K11' for Apple iPad
- 'Dead Space' for iOS
- Why are Video Games for Girls so Lame?
- The Muddy Beauty of DiRT 2
- The Reality of Indie Game Development
- Using Artificial Intelligence in Game Development
- Top 10 Most Anticipated Video Games of 2011
- Need for Speed Drives Back to Roots
- Developing and Optimizing Games for Netbooks
- 'Bejeweled 3'
- Rolling Thunder, Analytics and Performance Drive Need for Speed World
- Who You Gonna Call? Ghostbusters Challenges
- Dude! Who Killed My First-person Shooter?
- Racing to the Finish Line: Chris Southall Talks Total War and Sonic
- The Force Remains Strong with LEGO Star Wars III: The Clone Wars
- Unreal Engine 3 Brings Chadam to Life on Web Video
- 'Infinity Blade'
- 'Pac-Man Championship Edition DX'
- TRON: Evolution -- Game Developers Go Hollywood
- EA Sports Moves Graphics-rich Gaming Online
- Humble Opinions: From The Sims to Indie Games
- Meet Mr. Industrial: Justin Lassen's Music Machine
- 'Assassin's Creed: Brotherhood'
- 'Mario Vs. Donkey Kong: Mini-Land Mayhem'
- 'Time Crisis: Razing Storm'
- 'Arcania: Gothic 4'
- 'Disney Epic Mickey'
- 'Final Fantasy: The 4 Heroes of Light'
- 'Ace Combat: Air Assault'
- 'Game Dev. Story'
- Epic Games Unveils 'Gears of War 3' Multiplayer Details
- 'Castlevania: Lords of Shadow'
- 'Sonic the Hedgehog 4: Episode 1'
- 'Amnesia: The Dark Descent'
- 'Enslaved: Odyssey to the West'
- 'Valkyria Chronicles II'
- 'Dead Rising 2'
- 'Kingdom Hearts Birth by Sleep'
- 'Halo: Reach'
- 'Mafia II'
- 'Scott Pilgrim' vs. Its Video Game References
- 'Madden 11'
- 'Metroid: Other M'
- 'Scott Pilgrim vs. The Games'
- Burn Zombie Burn
- Scott Pilgrim Vs. The World: The Game
- Starcraft 2
- Dolby's Axon Software
- What Video Games Could Teach
- Valkyria Chronicles II
- Metal Gear Solid: Peace Walker
- Monkey Island 2: LeChuck's Revenge
- Clash of the Titans
- Alien Spawn
- Halo: Combat Evolved - Failure is an Option
- Sin and Punishment: Star Successor
- Medal of Honor
- ModNation Racers
- 3D Dot Heroes
- The Sims 3: Ambitions
- Lost Planet 2
- Star Trek Online
- Coming of Age in Video Games
- Putting Down Video Games And Picking Them Back Up Again
- Government Should Stop Kids From Buying Violent Video Games
- Video Games Don't Cause Children to be Violent
- 'Monster Hunter Tri' (Wii)
- 'Dead to Rights: Retribution' (Xbox 360)
- Deus Ex Focuses on the Play
- 'Sam & Max Season 3: The Penal Zone'
- Sleep is Death
- 'FarmVille': A Love Story
- 'Battlefield: Bad Company 2'
- 'Assassin's Creed II: Bonfire of the Vanities'
- Assassin's Creed II - Xbox 360
- 'Avatar: The Game'
- 'WWE SmackDown vs. Raw 2010' - Xbox 360
- NCAA Basketball 10 - PS3
- Disney Jonas - DS
- 'God of War' Collection - PS3
- How to Beat the Hydra in 'God of War' - PS3
- 'Left 4 Dead 2' - Xbox 360
Video Games: Pixels and Sand
COPYRIGHT (C) 2011 CRISPY GAMER. ALL RIGHTS RESERVED. DISTRIBUTED BY TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.
Your Favorite Comic Strips Online
Your favorite comics strips Animal Crackers, Annie, Bound & Gagged, Brenda Starr, Brewster Rockit: Space Guy, Broom-Hilda, Dick Tracy, Gasoline Alley, Gil Thorp, Housebroken, Loose Parts, The Middletons, Pink Panther, Raising Hector, Sylvia, 9 to 5, Bliss, Bottom Liners, Love Is..., Pluggers all online at ComicStripNation.com