Robyn Blumner
"As long as the crime comic books industry exists in its present forms, there are no secure homes."
This overheated warning of the insidiousness of the comic book threat came from psychiatrist Fredric Wertham in 1954 during hearings on juvenile delinquency before the
As foolish as he sounds now, Wertham's crusade was a hit with lawmakers. He succeeded in getting the legislature in
The First Amendment has stayed the hand of many a would-be censor. When this liberty isn't strongly enforced, however, terrible misjudgment reigns. Remember
We look upon these moral dictators now as naive and quaint. But their kind still exists. Tipper Gore launched her crusade targeting heavy metal bands like Twisted Sister only 28 years ago. Her ilk then turned to rap music, as if song lyrics caused rather than reflected the violence and misogyny in urban homes and neighborhoods.
Today that same impulse has its attention focused on violent video games, particularly after news reports that the
Think the
I can save the NAS a lot of time. Lanza is a tragic case, but he's an outlier. There is no body of social scientific evidence demonstrating that violent video games are the cause of violent acts or that they turn a peaceful person into an aggressor in real life.
Just as watching "Natural Born Killers," playing paintball (or whatever is today's modern equivalent to cops and robbers), listening to Eminem or reading "Lord of the Flies" doesn't cause harm or provoke violence, neither does using a controller to mow people down with a chainsaw. It may not be the most productive use of time, but at a very young age, children know the difference between real and pretend. As
Research on the topic was well-considered just two years ago by the
In the real world, as video games get more startlingly realistic and depraved, rates of violence by young men have gone down, not up. Arrests for violent crime for males between 10 and 24 years of age have plummeted from 850 arrests per 100,000 in 1995 to 516 per 100,000 in 2009, according to the
There have always been people in power who blamed juvenile delinquency and crime on exposure to certain media. They have always been both wrong and dangerous to our freedoms.
- United States Heads Toward Gun Control Debate
- Freedom to Live in Fear
- Plotting an Uncivil War
- The Social Context of Mass Murder
- Video Games Not to Blame for Mass Shootings
- Hollywood Film Brings Torture Back Into The Light
- The Other Cliffs
- A Holiday Letter from America
- Take Care of the Children
- Newtown: The American Paradox
- The NRA vs Common Sense
- NRA 'Solutions' are Straight Out of a Stallone Movie
- Put Prospective Gun Owners Under the Microscope
- Too Many People Who Should Not Have Guns Do
- Newtown Shines Spotlight on Mental Health
- After Newtown: Will We Finally Act?
- Sandy Hook: Explaining Evil
- Fine Words, Delayed Action
- On Newtown, Mourn First, then Act
- School Shooting a Watershed Moment
- News and Social Media Amok
- In Colorado, Empty Gun Dorm Sends a Message
- Who Moved My Twinkie?
- The 'Land of Opportunity' is Becoming Hollywood Fiction
- Our Endless State of War
- Name that Foreign Policy Legacy
- A Date with History: The Cuban Missile Crisis
- False Tweets, Future Jailbirds?
- Hurricane Sandy's Wakeup Call
- Principled Pragmatism Beats Bush-style Bluster
- Empire and Its Consequences
- Netanyahu Foolish to Take Sides in American Election
- Hurricane Sandy and the Living Planet
- Hurricane Sandy Aftermath: New Jersey's Even-Odd System
- Hurricane Sandy Aftermath: Mamaroneck Damage
- Hurricane Sandy Aftermath: Brooklyn Looters Beware
- New York Cancels Marathon for First Time Due to Sandy
- Canceled NYC Marathon Disappoints Runners
- Hurricane Sandy Retrospective
(c) 2012 Tribune Media Services, Inc.