Colbert's Irony and Twitter Don't Mix
By Clarence Page
One of the unwritten but widely respected rules of satire is that somehow, somewhere, someone simply isn't going to get the joke.
And if they don't get the joke, you get taken seriously about something you don't really believe.
It is therefore appropriate that he has found himself caught up in a real-time example of a new hazard of the digital age: Satire and Twitter go together like drunks and driving.
"Who would have thought," he lamented on Monday night, "that a means of communication limited to 140 characters would ever create misunderstandings?"
No kidding. Or maybe he was. It's sometimes hard to tell when the real Colbert dives deeply into his self-described role as "
He was responding in this instance to last week's angry Twitter eruptions over a segment in which he satirized
Colbert heard irony in Snyder's use of a racial slur to name a foundation that was created to perfume the slur that many, including me, hear in the pro football team's name. So fake-conservative "Stephen Colbert" responded by announcing his own group: the "
Edgy? Uncomfortable? Yes. But satire is supposed to make you at least a little uncomfortable. In his show's context, the joke worked. The audience laughed with Colbert and groaned at Snyder's tone-deaf -- or tone-indifferent -- cluelessness.
Trouble came later, Colbert explained this week, when "a web editor I've never met" tweeted his Ching-Chong punch line without its set-up or even posting a link to any mention of Snyder's foundation.
Among those who were outraged by that naked tweet was
Park rocketed to Twitter stardom in December with #NotYourAsianSidekick, a provocative invitation to a much-needed debate about Asian-American stereotypes that trended for several days. She since has been named one of The Guardian's "top 30 young people in digital media," an international fame that would make
Her new cause, #CancelColbert, outdid her previous campaigns, triggering frontlash and backlash in every direction. Critics blasted Colbert and were blasted back by Colbert fans, political-correctness opponents and a broad zoo of general-purpose haters.
Genuine right-wingers in some cases used #CancelColbert as a golden opportunity to vent their long-held outrage at Colbert's fake conservatism. Snyder's R-word controversy was lost in the Twitter storm.
To his credit, fake "Colbert" asked people to stop attacking Park. "She's just speaking her mind," he said. "That's what Twitter is for, as well as ruining the ending of every show I haven't seen yet."
Quite right. For that, I give what the fake "Colbert" would call a "tip of the hat" to the real Colbert and a "wag of the finger" to the haters. We can disagree without being disagreeable, as President Obama likes to say, although you wouldn't know it from some of his critics either.
Satire is not dead, as some grumps have tweeted in response to this dust-up. But Colbert demonstrates that good satire does require a tad more than a birdbath's depth of thinking to create or appreciate.
It requires context to be provided by the satirist and understood by the audience. Context, more often than not, exceeds the capacity of a Twitter tweet, unless it includes a link to something longer than 140 characters.
Park has said in interviews that she usually likes Colbert's show, but hates the ways in which Asian Americans too often become a go-to group for comedians to ridicule. As an American, not just an African-American, I sympathize. When your only way to talk back is offered by social networks, every problem becomes a potential tweet.
Just keep it short, please. And if you're joking, let us know it.
#CancelColbert: Stephen Colbert, Mocks Redskins Owner Dan Snyder, Now The Target Of Outrage
- Fake Royal TV Show Among Bottom of the Heap
- Malaysia Airlines Flight 370 - CNN: Overkill News Network
- Colbert's Irony and Twitter Don't Mix
- News Candy for the Ears
- What to Do When Your Favorite TV Show Ends
- Oscars Host DeGeneres Sets Retweet Record
- Jay Leno: Mr. Nice Guy
- What 'Teen Mom' TV Shows Don't Show
- Hate-Watching Fake DC on TV
- Greatest 90s TV Theme Songs You Almost Forgot
- Find Out How Many Days It Takes To Binge Watch Your Favorite Shows
- 'Silicon Valley' Cast Answers: Who's the Greatest Nerd of All Time?
- The Daily Show on Beyonce's Sexy Videos
- Grey's Anatomy Exclusive Clip
- Top 10 Cartoon Dads from TV
- TV Show Cancellation and Renewal Predictions
- The Definition of Love That Made Oprah Say "Wow"
- Michel Gill of 'House of Cards' Talks About Being President
- 'The Bachelor' Juan Pablo Reacts to Haters
- J.J. Abrams Wants Us To "Believe"
- Is There Too Much Sex and Nudity on 'Game of Thrones'?
- The Most Awkward 'Bachelor' Finale Ever
Article: Copyright © 2014, Tribune Content Agency.
"Colbert's Irony and Twitter Don't Mix"