Q: We purchased a home in 2006 for
Our home is now worth only about
In addition to our first mortgage, we also have a
My husband is in military, and it looks like he's going to get orders to move in this summer. Rather than sell the house and lose money we will rent it. But homes in our neighborhood rent for about
We're worried when the interest rate adjusts on our mortgage, the payment will be more than we can pay, once you factor in housing costs in our new location (likely overseas), rental property management fees, and the
We'd like to refinance before we move, so the mortgage will be on our primary residence, not a rental property, as the rates are lower. But of course, we are way upside down on the loan.
Will any bank even touch us? We haven't missed a payment, have been paying extra principal, don't have any other debt except a car payment, and have excellent credit scores (both of us are over 760).
What are our options, if any?
A: You're in a tough spot, although you're better off than many simply because of the enormous amount of cash you put down on your home.
In evaluating what to do, you might consider a Home Affordable Refinance Plan under the Obama Making Home Affordable program. If you qualify, you can have your lender refinance your loan. If you are current on your loan, live in the home and it's a one-to-four family building, and your loan is serviced by
You can get more information about the Home Affordable Refinance program by going to MakingHomeAffordable.gov.
If you are unable to refinance your loan through the program, you'll have a tough time refinancing. Why? You owe
If you're in jumbo loan territory at that amount, you'd need to find a lender willing to give you two loans: One for
But here's the rub: To get that much money, with most lenders you'd need to have 25 to 30 percent in equity in your home. Right now, you're about 25 percent underwater with your mortgage. Your home is worth substantially less than what you owe. I don't think any lender will touch you at the moment, although you should call some local, reputable lenders and have a conversation about your situation.
There are very few 100 percent loans available, although the VA offers one, as does USDA.
But I believe the VA tops out at
For a USDA loan, your home has to be located in a qualifying area. Big cities and most suburban areas are out as these are rural development loans.
If you can't refinance, then you have to look at renting your property. It's clear that you're going to lose money. But if you can swing a
What you're looking at is a
What you have to hope is that when your interest rate adjusts next year, it goes lower, and that thereafter increases are capped by 1 to 2 percent per year, which will help keep things slightly more affordable. Take a look at your mortgage documents to see where you might end up if interest rates stay where they are today or go up a point or two.
Like so many others, you're in between a rock and a hard place. Another option is to find a way to bring in more income. I don't know how realistic that option is for your family, especially if you're going overseas, but this option should be part of your conversation.
I know I'll receive letters from readers asking whether President Obama's newly revised mortgage modification program will help borrowers like these. The new programs are supposed to encourage lenders to write down the principal of a loan to the current loan value. FHA is supposed to step in and write new mortgages, even if there is no equity in the property. And borrowers who lose their jobs are supposed to qualify for forbearance of up to six months, allowing them to skip mortgage payments while looking for a new job.
It's possible that these borrowers would qualify under the new rules, but it will take months for the new programs to get up and running.
In the meantime, if you're underwater and don't want to walk away from your mortgage, you might call the HOPE for Homeowners hotline at 888-995-HOPE and speak to a HUD-certified housing counselor.
- Confused About New World of Mortgage Finance? You're Not Alone
- Underwater on Mortgage But Too Much Skin in Game to Walk Away
- 7 Reasons to Downsize in Retirement
- Investment Property Costs: Add These Real Estate Expenses to Your Budget
- Don't Make These Real Estate Investing Mistakes
- Don't Make These Real Estate Investing Mistakes (Part 2)
- 12 Hidden Costs of Homeownership
- Don't Sign Over Title Until Your Name's Off the Mortgage
- Quitclaim Deed Not a Way to Get Mortgage Modification
- Nine Ways to Make Your Home More Appealing to Buyers
- Loan Modification Angst
- Obama Housing Rescue Tackles Unemployment & Underwater Loans
- How Much House Can I Afford? Calculating Home Affordability
- Home Sales Flat Before Spring Buying Season
- More Homeowners Pursue Remodeling Projects
- America's Most Underwater Housing Markets
- Energy-Efficient Updates Help Homeowners Save Cash
- Home Buying Checklist: What Savvy Home Buyers Need to Know
- Social Networking for Realtors Mortgage Lenders Buyers and Sellers
- Home Affordable Program Failing Homeowners
- Rate of Home Price Declines Slows, But More Drops May Be Ahead
- The Future of Home-Price Appreciation
- What Tanking Home Sales Mean for Economic Recovery
- Home Foreclosures Approach Peak Range
Real Estate - Underwater on Mortgage But Too Much Skin in Game to Walk Away
(c) 2010 Real Estate Matters, Ilyce Glink