The Trouble With Online Retirement Calculators
How much do you need to save for retirement? You can get an idea by using any of the dozens of retirement calculator tools offered for free on the Internet.
But a recent study by actuarial experts on retirement forecasting shows that many popular calculators have serious flaws. These problems could lead to serious miscalculations when you're plotting your retirement.
The report by the
"These tools take a project that is fairly complex and boil it down to something simple," says
So it's buyer beware when it comes to online retirement calculators. Here's a rundown of the key things to look out for:
1. Social Security Projections.
Most retirees get a third or more of retirement income from
2. Rate-of-Return Assumptions.
Three of the free calculators used pre-set future investment rate-of-return assumptions that you can't change, and their percentages varied widely. One, created by the
3. Life Expectancy.
It's impossible to know how long you'll live, of course. On average, 65-year-old men can expect to live another 17 years, and women another 20 years. Some calculators, the study found, automatically input life expectancy figures. But they fail to account for differences by race, income, and gender. And they also don't take into consideration that you or your spouse might live longer than the averages.
If a calculator forces you to make a longevity prediction, base it on your family history and your health. If you're married, use different life expectancy numbers for you and your spouse, since women tend to live several years longer than men.
The calculators make very different assumptions about what you'll do with your house at retirement. "Some assume you won't liquidate your home; others assume you will sell and downsize," Turner says. Very few of the tools analyze the impact on your finances of carrying a mortgage into retirement.
Among the free calculators reviewed, only the
None of the free calculators -- and few of the professional tools -- listed inflation as a retirement-planning risk. Some of the tools let you plug in just one percentage forecast, even though inflation can fluctuate widely over time. Others put in their own default inflation rate, ranging from 2.3 to 4.6 percent. That spread can make a huge difference in how much the purchasing power of your assets will shrink over a 25-year retirement.
Few of the free calculators helped couples forecast retirement income for a surviving spouse. They rarely let users enter separate information for both spouses and run numbers with differing life expectancies for them, for example. When the calculators recommended annuities for retirement income (most didn't), none suggested buying one with a survivor's benefit.
Some of the calculators allow for separate entry of data for each spouse, but even these typically assume that both people retire at the same time. Spousal issues regarding
If you're married, calculate retirement income needs for you and your spouse together and separately, using different life expectancy scenarios. This will help ensure that the one who lives longer won't run out of cash. "Doing the 'what-ifs' can help you see just how differently things can turn out," says Turner.
You can find a more detailed analysis in an article I wrote recently for CBS MoneyWatch.com (http://tinyurl.com/299faxj).
- Personal Finance Tools You Should Use Now
- 10 Creative Saving Strategies
- Strategy for Charitable Giving Makes Donations Go Further
- 6 Ways Couples Can Maximize Social Security Payouts
- The Trouble With Online Retirement Calculators
- How Divorce Affects Retirement Benefits
- Planning for Retirement Without a 401(k)
- 7 Reasons to Downsize in Retirement
- 6 Advantages to Federal Student Loans
- Tax On Health Benefits
- Make the Most of Health Care Reform
- Flat Tax Is Class Warfare
- Eliminate Tax Brackets and Complicated Forms With Flat Tax
- 10 Problems With the Income Tax
- Save Time Filing Your Taxes
- How to Be a Savvy Cheapskate
- Do You Live in a Frugal State
- How to Keep Your Nest Egg Intact After a Layoff
- Student Loan Crunch May Be Easing
- Don't Neglect Long-Term Care in Retirement Planning
- These Financial Blogs Are Worth Your Time
- Disney Interactive Exhibit Teaches Basic Financial Concepts
- Avoid Tax Trap When Converting Traditional IRA to Roth IRA
- Why Consumers Are Shunning Credit Cards
- How the Health Care Bill Impacts Retirees
- Keeping Adult Children on Your Insurance Policy
- iPad Launch: Perils of the iPad
- Many Americans Still Clueless About Retirement Saving
- How to Avoid the Marriage Tax
- The Challenge of Deducting Medical Expenses
- Health Care Reform Overhaul: What Happens When
- Older Americans Comment on Health Care Reform
- Big Changes Coming to Student Loans
- Affording a Stay-at-home Mom?
- 21 Ways to Cut Expenses in Retirement
- New Frugality Emerging for Retirement
- Gen Y to Banks: Do Better
- Deducting Hobby Expenses: Think Business
- Sadly Bad Advise Abounds on Roth IRA Conversions
- Medigap Plans Cooking Up New Alphabet Soup
- Identity Theft May Be Prelude to More Serious Crime
- Automatic Saving Plans for Emergency & Retirement Funds
- New Tax Provisions Make Filing More Complicated This Year
- Not All 401(k) Plans Are Created Equal
- Time to Prepare Your Will
- Bigger Tax Break for Writing Off Costs of College
- The Secret to Being Poor
- Bad Day? 5 Tips to Keep Your Motivation
- 8 Factors that Determine Your Final 401(k) Balance
- How to Tell if You Are Saving Enough for Retirement
- Financial Help For Women: 5 Effective Strategies
- New Credit Card Rules Triggering More Higher Fees
- Roth Conversion Can Be Good Move, But Consider These Caveats
Personal Finance - The Trouble With Online Retirement Calculators
(c) 2010 Mark Miller