Cell phone risks remain fuzzy
Do cell phones cause brain tumors?
"An increased risk of brain cancer is not established, but it's important to note that we can't establish absence of risk, either," says study leader
In a retrospective study, between 2000 and 2006 her team enlisted 6,400 people with brain tumors and a similar number of healthy people. They were then quizzed on how much they had used a cell phone. The idea was that if the phones boost the risk of tumors, there would have been more phone use in the tumor group compared with the general population, and less phone use in the healthy group. But the opposite was found (
Good news for cell phone addicts? Not so fast. When the team got back in touch with healthy people who had declined to take part in the study, they discovered that these people were less likely to be regular phone users (defined as making more than one call a week for more than six months) than the healthy people who took part. This means that the benefit that cell phones seemed to offer could just be down to an over-representation of people who were both healthy and regular users. It also means that any detrimental effects might have been masked.
Despite this bias toward positive results, when the researchers compared the 10 percent of cell phone users who spent the most time on their phones with non-users and infrequent users (defined as less than one call per week), this level of use did appear to increase the risk of gliomas by 40 percent and meningiomas by 15 percent.
These increases became even more pronounced when only tumors on the same side of the head as sufferers said they held their cell phones were counted. Frustratingly, the extent to which even these findings can be trusted is unknown, due to another problem.
Because the study was retrospective, the researchers relied on participants' memories, going back up to 10 years, of how much they had used their handsets before being enrolled, and on which side of the head. Yet people who are ill are subject to "recall bias" -- a tendency to exaggerate memories of potential risk factors.
What should we make of all this? Cardis advises caution: "It may not be an unreasonable course of action to limit exposure through the use of text messages, hands-free devices and speaker phones." But Mike Repacholi, who helped set up the study while at the WHO, is more positive: "The study says use of cell phones isn't associated with tumors."
Further studies are underway, but don't hold the line: The prospective Cosmos study hasn't begun yet, and aims to follow users for 20 to 30 years.
Available at Amazon.com:
- Largest Ever Cell Phone Cancer Study is Inconclusive
- Treating Early-Stage Esophageal Cancer
- TNF Inhibitors Offer Relief to Those With Rheumatoid Arthritis
- TNF Inhibitors Offer Relief to Those With Rheumatoid Arthritis
- Advances in Breast Cancer Screening Helping to Fine-Tune Diagnosis
- Beware of Using Psychotropics During Pregnancy
- Prostate Exam Good First Stop When PSA Levels Increase
- 7 Nasty Germs That Could Land Your Kid in the Hospital And How to Avoid Them
- Omega-3 Foods Don't Always Add Up
- First Aid for Summer
- Get the Best Tan Without the Burn
- Is Agave Nectar Better for You than Ordinary Sugar?
- Loving Legumes for all the Right Reasons: Health, Flavor and Value
- Radishes, Spring's Favorite Vegetable
- The Microscopic World of Food Nanotechnology
- Ultraviolet Light Offers Benefits for Some Skin Conditions
- Secondhand Smoke A Serious Public and Personal Health Problem
- What to do About Excessive Belching and Feeling Full?
- Chest Pain: A Heart Attack or Something Else?
- Screening Plays Key Role in Detecting Polyps Before They Become Cancerous
- Streamline Your Daily Life
- Learn How to Read Supplement Labels
- What Parents Can Do to Keep Kids From Snacking Their Way to Obesity
- Though No Cure for POTS, Symptoms Can Often Be Effectively Managed
- Chicken Tortilla Wraps
- Compression-Only CPR Can Replace Conventional CPR in Many Circumstances
- Diabetes: Could You Have Diabetes and Not Know It
- Fighting Inflammation with Food
- Have a Healthy Vacation
- Cortisone Injections Unlikely to Have Negative Affect on Bones
- Bad Health Habits Rob Years From Life Span
- Beating Back Pandemics is a Cooperative Crusade
- The Importance of Decreasing Dietary Sodium
- Indoor Tanning Definitively Linked to Deadliest Skin Cancer
- Chronic Obstructive Pulmonary Disease (COPD): Takes Your Breath Away
- 7 Ways to Prevent Heart Disease
- Hypotension or Stiff Arteries May Cause Low Diastolic Blood Pressure
- Is It OK to Travel to a High Altitude With High Blood Pressure?
- Existing Drugs to Treat Herpes Are Very Effective
- Dry Mouth Can Be a Serious Problem
- 6 Simple Ways to Improve Symptoms of Fibromyalgia
- All About Gout: Old Disease Becoming More Common
- Frequent Monitoring Critical to Effectively Manage Scleroderma
- Sick Day TLC
- When to Call the Doctor
- Chocolate Reduces Inflammation Associated with Heart Disease
- Healthy Eating Tips for a Busy Lifestyle
- Olive Oil and Health
- Push for Healthier Diets Means Big Changes for the Food Industry
- How to Identify Suicide Risk Before It's Too Late
- Tips for Natural Allergy Relief
- Inflammation May Play Role in Irritable Bowel Syndrome
- Bouncing Back After Being Sick
- Longevity Revolution Will Restructure Life Around the World
- Maximum Fitness: CrossFit Training
- Tests to Optimize Treatment of Breast Cancer
- Insulin: Hormone That Regulates Blood Sugar Now May Save Your Brain
- Enjoy the Health Benefits of Tea
- Can Your Toothbrush Make You Sick?
- Sunscreen Facts You Need to Know
- Fight Inflammation With the Right Diet
- When does Knee Replacement Surgery Make Sense
- Asthma and Allergies Can Run in Families
- Is Hefty the New Healthy?
- Nicotine Patch May Offer Some Benefit to Ulcerative Colitis
- Best Way to Take Heartburn Medication
- Salivary Gland Stones Rare But Not Unheard of in Children
- Fight Dry Skin and Win
- Aerobics Without Heartburn
- How Much Vitamin D is Enough
- Are Carbonated Drinks Bad for Bones?
- Common Myths and Misconceptions About Diabetes
- Vitamin E Supplements Not Recommended for Those With Diabetes
- Tick-Borne Disease Risk Peaks in Spring and Summer
- Are Carbonated Drinks Bad for Bones?
- Meibomitis Creates Receptive Environment for Bacteria
- Top 4 Seasonal Allergy Mistakes
- Stress Less: Ten Strategies That Work
- Paralyzed Limbs Revived by Hacking Into Nerves
- The Threat of Childhood Obesity
- Nature's Gym: Exercising Outdoors
- Eat Smart for Healthy Hair
- Paying the High Price of Food Waste
- Can Acid Reflux Damage my Esophagus
- Secrets to Breathing Better With Allergies
- Take the Work Out of Workout
- Bounce Back From Spring Break
- Cultivate a Nutrient-Rich Approach to Eating for Life
- What's the Right Amount of Vitamin C
- Treadmill Test Can Reveal Hidden Problems in Heart
- Suffering From Allergies? Tailor Treatment to Your Symptoms
- Researchers Break Through to Unconscious Patients
- Key Factors Related to Heart Attack Risk
- Type 2 Diabetes Increases Risk for Cardiovascular Problems
- Middle-Age Spread and How to Avoid It
- Fiber and Weight Loss: Learn the Secrets
- Treadmill Test Can Reveal Hidden Problems in Heart
- Could Hot Flashes Only Occur at Night?
- Hypochondria: The Impossible Illness
- Get the Lead Out: The Less Exposure to This Toxic Metal the Better
- Everything You Ever Wanted to Know About Sugar
- Omega-3 Rich Diet
- Omega-3 Enriched Eggs an 'Eggs-traordinary' Choice for Heart Health
- Quinoa: Nutritious Mother Grain of the Incas
- 14 Things You Might Not Know About Aspirin
- Cultivate a Healthy Brain Lifestyle As You Age
- Regular Exercise Helps Protect Aging Brains
- Surgeries Can be Combined But May Not be Necessary
- Get the Lead Out: The Less Exposure to This Toxic Metal the Better
- Hypochondria: The Impossible Illness
- Guide to Cold and Allergy Symptoms
- Is Heartburn Surgery the Answer?
- Best Cooking Methods for Heartburn Sufferers
- 14 Things You Might Not Know About Aspirin
Copyright © 2010 New Scientist Magazine. All rights reserved.