Controversy Over Ethanol
A lot of words have been said and written about ethanol.
Some say it is the solution to our reliance on imported oil. Others suggest that, as a green solution to our fuel and carbon dioxide emission problems, ethanol is a sham. But relatively few have talked or written about how corrosive ethanol is.
Not only is it harder than petroleum to transport through pipelines and tankers, but it is also harder on internal combustion engines.
In fact, it is so potentially harmful to engines that a consortium of engine manufacturers from the automotive, marine, and outdoor power equipment industries have banded together in a new alliance called the Engine Products Group (EPG) to challenge the Environmental Protection Agency’s (EPA) recent decision to approve the sale of gasoline containing 15 percent ethanol (E15) for 2007-model-year and newer passenger cars and light trucks.
You might not realize it, but the gasoline you are using right now very likely contains 10 percent ethanol. When that gasoline mix, referred to as E10, was approved several years ago, it was followed by reports of a variety of maladies, including engine fires and leaking fuel tanks that were tied to the corrosive nature of ethanol. That controversy died down; engine manufacturers adapted their products to live with E10, and all was relatively quiet until an ethanol industry trade-group petitioned the EPA in March 2009 to raise the limit on ethanol in gasoline from 10 to 15 percent.
Having been almost literally burned previously, several engine-product and auto manufacturers urged the EPA to refuse the request, or to at least embark on thorough and adequate testing to assure that E15 would not harm existing products or pose safety risks. But after what many observers feel was an inordinately short period of time, the EPA made what seems like a compromise -- a compromise that is proving to be unpopular with those who favor E15, those who don't and those who just want to sell gasoline to the general public.
Instead of approving E15 gasoline for all uses or continuing to forbid its use, the EPA gave the E15 a partial waiver, allowing its use, as mentioned previously, in 2007-model-year and newer passenger cars and light trucks only. It was not approved for older passenger cars and trucks. But anyone who has ever filled his or her tank with gasoline can see the problem with that. What is going to prevent someone who has, say, a 2005 Honda Accord or Chevrolet Silverado pickup truck from filling it up at a pump with E15 gas when there will be nothing but a label on the pump to warn them? And what is to prevent someone with an outboard motor or a lawn trimmer from filling up those product's fuel tanks with E15, even though it might damage them? Even more to the point, how many gas stations are going to install tanks and pumps to handle E15 for newer cars, and E10 and/or straight gasoline for older models?
Almost certainly, as the EPG says, there is a risk that consumers will unknowingly or mistakenly put E15 in products for which it has not been approved. Since the misused gasoline has the potential to harm engines and other related components, you can understand why the organizations involved are working to get the decision overturned. And since there is less energy stored in ethanol than in gasoline, consumers who buy E15 at the same price as E10 will be getting less bang for their buck.
“While all members of the EPG have and continue to support the development and use of safe and sustainable alternative fuels, the action EPA has taken to permit E15 to be sold as a legal fuel, even if limited only to certain products, will have adverse consequences for the environment," said Kris Kiser, spokesman for the Engine Products Group. "A partial waiver, by its nature, necessarily will result in the misfueling of products not designed or tested for E15 use."
To prompt the EPA to rethink its decision, the Engine Products Group has filed a petition with the U.S. Court of Appeals for the District of Columbia Circuit, asking that the EPA’s ruling be remanded back to the agency. Among its assertions is that the Clean Air Act does not authorize EPA to issue any partial-waiver decisions in the first place. It also asserts that the EPA statute passed by Congress in 2007 states that fuels that could cause any failures can't be approved for the market, while there is no dispute that E15 has been shown to adversely affect engines in non-road products and older model-year vehicles -- not to mention causing emission failures. Finally, EPG suggests that there is no assurance that E15 won't damage more recent (post-2007) model-year vehicles, with the exception of vehicles expressly designed for use with flexible fuel.
So what does all this mean?
It means that the regulators at the EPA might well have to revisit their decision allowing E15. It means that gasoline retailers and oil companies will be on hold until it is determined whether E15 will go forward or not. And it means that, should the new regulations eventually be upheld, you will have to be careful which gas pump you pull up to.
Luigi Fraschini is a Driving Today contributing editor based in Cleveland. He writes frequently about automotive safety, pollution and air-quality issues
Recent Auto Reviews
- Ford C-Max: A Mini Minivan
- Can Toyota Rise Again?
- 11 Coolest Scooters to Help You Spring Into 2011
- In-car Gadget Market Grows
- Audi A6: Sibling Rivalry
- Consumers More Aware of Alt-fuel Vehicles
- Ford Vertrek: An Escape From the Escape
- Get Your Armor on
- Controversy Over Ethanol
- Aging Drivers Cause Concern
- Our 5 Favorite Must-haves for Car Geeks
- Smart Phone Apps Help Stop Distracted Driving
- Time to Buy a New Car?
- Cadillac Eyes Smaller Cars
- 2011 Chevrolet Camaro Convertible Debuts
- Greatest Cars - Triumph TR-2
- Greatest Cars - Porsche 911
- Greatest Cars - Lamborghini Countach
- Are Green Vehicles Overhyped?
- Is Propane Fuel Getting a Fair Shake?
- Negotiating Car Price Still Saves Big Bucks
- Auto Leasers Remorse on the Rise
- Tailgating Goes Upscale
- Chevrolet Volt Becomes a Political Issue
- 4 Steps to Fix Your Car for Fall
- Kicking Off a 'Hydrogen Highway'
- Get Ready to Plug in Your Car
- Making Cars Safer
- Putting the Brakes on Ethanol
- Toyota Lost Its Way
- The Most Anticipated 2011 Cars
- Battle of the Greenest: Electrics vs. Hybrid Cars
- Don't Write Off Gasoline Engines Yet
- American Car Buyers Think Small
- Prepay Your Traffic Tickets?
- Buy or Lease: Is There a Simple Answer
- Will Hybrids See a Resurgence?
- Detroit Tops Auto Industry Customer Satisfaction
- Steps to Finding the Right Mechanic
- Men Seeking Cars Increase
- 2011 Model Year Holds Great Suspense
- Danger From GPS?
- Carbon Dioxide Emissions: Epoch-Changing Decision from the EPA
- Tracking Device Saves You Money on Car Insurance
- Electric Cars May Not Make the World Greener
- 10 Ways to Exercise Your Driving Muscles
- When Should You Buy Gas?
- American Carmakers Cry Foul
- Breathe Easier With 5 Cost-saving Clean Air Tips
- Chrysler Tries to Kick up Incentives in July
- Austin 7
- Benz Patent Motor Wagen
- Continental Mark II
- Cadillac V-16
- Chevrolet 409
- Chevrolet Chevelle SS 454
- Stutz Bearcat
- 1959 Chevrolet El Camino
- Porsche 356
- Compromise Between New and Used Cars
- American Cars vs. Import Cars: The Short Course on Vehicle Quality
- Honda Element Outlives Its Birthright
- Defaulting on an Auto Lease Contract
- Smart Car Goes Electric
- The Top 5 American Cars of All Time
- 1964 - 1967 Sunbeam Tiger Roadster
- 1967 Chevrolet Camaro
- Nash Metropolitan
- Ferrari GTB/4 Berlinetta Boxer
- Austin-Healey Sprite
- Dodge Charger
- Chevrolet Chevelle SS 396
- Lamborghini Miura
- Stanley Steamer
- Mercedes-Benz 500K/540K
- Ferrari 550 Maranello
- Fuel Economy Limits for Big Trucks
- Gittin Gets 2011 Mustang Drift
- Hot Rods Invade Pebble Beach
- Have a Safe Trip
- Electrifying Transportation
- The Price of Global Climate Change Regulations
- Sweet Deal for the Auto Dealers
- Prevent Overheating
- Crucial Safety Tips for Motorcycle Season
- Auto Financing Outlook Improves
- Voice Control for Driving Safety
- Keep Your Family Safe This Summer
- Spring Cleaning Tips for Your Car
- Hybrid Electric Cars Turn to Natural Gas
- To Lease a Car or Buy a Car
- Teens Don't See Drinking and Driving Dangers
- Tesla Takes Big Step
- Green Cars and Toyota
- Station Wagon Might Be Getting New Life
- Hydrogen for Your Car at Home
- 4 Ugly Cars Only Their Mothers Could Love
- Hybrid-like Fuel Economy From Non-hybrid
- Eco-friendly Driving Tricks Anyone Can Do
- What's Driving Us to Road Rage
- Toyota's Future in America
- Toyota: Profit Over Principles
- Toyota's Reputation Remains Strong
- Is the Inside of Your Car Making You Sick?
- American Luxury Hybrid Style
- Your Traffic Forecast Here
- Stop Curbstoning
- Seat Belt With Air Bag Brings More Safety
- Stuttering Start for Electric Cars
- Going the Extra Mile
- Learn to Share the Road
- Lease a Tesla Electric
- Honda Design Philosophy Stresses Function
- Financing Your New Car in a Difficult Economy
- 2011 Mustang Shelby GT350 Returns to Action
- Ford Gives Its 2011 Edge New Edge
- Kelper Motors Unveils 800-horsepower 'Motion' Supercar
- Will 2010 be a Better Year to Buy a Car
- Post-Cash for Clunkers Buyers Think Differently
Copyright © 2010 Studio One Networks. All rights reserved.