Resolution Against the Machine
Jean Athey and John Feffer
Communities all over the United States are reeling from budget cuts. Military contractors, meanwhile, have remained fat and well-fed on the one part of federal spending that so far hasn't been touched by budget-cutting fever: the Pentagon.
One community recently decided to call attention to this disparity. In Montgomery County, a relatively wealthy Maryland suburb of Washington, DC, Peace Action Montgomery got together with a group of County Council members to craft a simple, straightforward resolution. It urged Congress "to make major reductions in the Pentagon budget, in a manner that does not harm the safety or lives of our troops, with the savings invested in state and local needs so that Montgomery County and other counties in Maryland can repair their deteriorating infrastructure, reverse budget cuts to education, health care, and other needs, and otherwise improve the welfare of their residents."
On October 4, the Council president introduced this resolution with three cosponsors. One additional Council member announced that he would also support the resolution. With this majority, the resolution was guaranteed to pass when it came up for a vote on October 11.
But it didn’t pass. Cue the ominous movie soundtrack.
The Machine Fights Back
Lockheed Martin is one of the premier military contractors in the world. It also employs about 5,000 people in Montgomery County. Alerted to the resolution, Lockheed Martin switched into high gear. One of its top lobbyists began calling council members. The Washington Post reported that some Council members were also called by a "state delegate, and the offices of County Executive Isiah Leggett (D), Gov. Martin O’Malley (D) and Rep. Chris Van Hollen (D)."
Maryland officials were most upset at the prospect that Lockheed would up and leave Maryland — for Virginia. Last year, Northrop Grumman opted for Virginia over Maryland as the site of its new global headquarters. The prospect that Lockheed Martin might pull up stakes prompted Montgomery County Executive Isiah Leggett to refer to the resolution as "a dagger pointed directly at the heart of Montgomery County."
With that degree of opposition, at least one and perhaps two of the original supporters decided to rescind their support for the resolution. In order to avoid a defeat, the Council president pulled the resolution, and the Council never voted on it.
Now the controversy has achieved national attention with conservative columnist George Will weighing in. In a column that dismisses the Occupy Wall Street movement, Will also refers to Montgomery Peace Action's effort to get the resolution passed as part of all that he finds objectionable in the progressive tradition.
Setting the Record Straight
The controversy over this rather uncontroversial resolution — even right-wing Republicans like Sen. Tom Coburn of Oklahoma have agreed that Pentagon cuts must be on the table — began with an article in the conservative Washington Examiner newspaper. The piece emphasized the potential hazards of the resolution, citing "local economists and defense agencies [who] say such cuts likely would hurt local residents more than it would help them."
With the Cold War over and the United States spending more on the military than all its potential adversaries combined, military contractors have fallen back on the jobs argument. Since weapons systems are built in virtually every congressional district in the country, it has been very difficult even for Pentagon officials to cut funding for patently unnecessary fighter jets and the like. This argument has filtered down to the community level as well, particularly at a time of state and federal budget cutbacks. As shown in Maryland and Virginia, states vie with each other to see which can offer the best deal — read state and local tax cuts — to keep or entice a military contractor.
These deals may not be offered to other companies. For example, in 2010, Maryland passed a law created just for Lockheed Martin to exempt its guests, subcontractors, and employees from paying a hotel tax at Lockheed Martin's new hotel located on its Bethesda campus, costing the state $351,000 per year in foregone taxes.
In fact, however, dollars invested in military spending are not good job creators. Spend a billion dollars on the military, economists Robert Pollin and Heidi Garrett-Peltier estimate, and you get about 11,000 jobs (just a little more than what Lockheed Martin employs in all of Maryland). Spend that same billion dollars on clean energy projects and you generate about 17,000 jobs. The same money invested in education produces nearly 30,000 jobs.
In other words, if the federal government reorganized its priorities according to the proposed Montgomery County resolution, the number of jobs in the county could increase substantially. Moreover, Lockheed Martin already does a good portion of its business in non-military fields. Pentagon cuts could encourage the company to reduce the military share of its business. Neither the county nor Lockheed Martin should view military cuts as a dagger. Rather, it’s an incentive: to invest in human needs and shift over to non-military manufacturing and services.
Montgomery County is home to many different kinds of employers, There’s the National Institutes of Health, the Health Resources and Services Administration, and other large Federal agencies. If military spending is not brought under control, the jobs of people working at these agencies will be under threat. Then there are the private businesses that depend on consistent spending on county infrastructure from roads to schools. With federal spending being dramatically cut to states and localities, including in Maryland, there is no money for infrastructure now.
If Montgomery County has to cut back on services because of the huge drain on national resources going to the Pentagon, private companies might move out of the county and new ones won’t replace them. Already one business has put its expansion into the county on hold. The innovative local restaurant chain Busboys & Poets has delayed any plans to expand into Silver Spring because of the council’s misguided decision on the resolution.
Montgomery County has a choice.
It can side with the old Cold War economy and the current federal budget priorities that are bankrupting the country. Or it can be part of the shift to a new, sustainable economy.
- Originally published by Foreign Policy in Focus
Read the latest political news.
- Resolution Against the Machine
- Obama and 2012 GOP-ers Need More Urgency on America's Future
- Mitt Romney a Sure Bet for GOP Nomination
- Super-Committee Lobbying Begins in Earnest
- Warren Buffett: A Hero For Our Times
- What I've Learned Occupying Wall Street and DC
- It's Not Just Anti-Wall Streeters That Have Grounds to Protest
- How 'Occupy Wall Street' Started and Spread
- Occupy Wall Street: Is Mad as Hell Enough?
- Occupy Wall Street: Don't Sleep Through the Revolution
- Occupy Wall Street: The Beginning of Something Big ... Maybe
- Occupy Wall Street: Sorting Out the 'Extremists'
- Occupy Wall Street Protestors Return to Nation's Roots
- Wall Street and Its Occupiers: Both State Welfare Junkies
- Tea Party: Stop Comparing 'Occupy Wall Street' To Us
- Obama's Trade Deal Delays Have Cost Jobs
- Why Rick Perry's Texas Success Isn't Translating
- Mormon Expert: Religion Won't Stall Mitt Romney
- Mitt Romney Takes Charge
- Herman Cain 9-9-9 Tax Plan Could Hurt Retirees
- Raising Cain
- On Race and Herman Cain: A Darker Shade of Wail
- Herman Cain: A Slogan in Every Pot!
- Ron Paul $1 Trillion Cut Plan Targets Five Cabinet Departments
- Republicans Looking For Love
- Politics and Religion 2012 Version
- Morality Not Theology
- The GOP -- and Mitt Romney -- Dilemma
- It's the Oligarchy, Stupid!
- Herman Cain's Anti-Race Card
- Mitt Romney and Ron Paul Aim to Soothe Skeptics
- Obama's Lonely Presidency
- Reconsider Dodd-Frank, Piece by Piece
- Dodd-Frank Brings Transparency to Financial Industry
- Dodd-Frank is More Right than Wrong
- Dodd-Frank Is a Counterproductive Mess
- Repealing Dodd-Frank Would Put the Economy in Danger
- 5 Years On: The Secret of Fox News's Success
- Is the Economy Better Off Without Washington?
- US Economic Woes Put China in the Political Crosshairs
- Vanishing Pensions Another Case of Corporate Greed
- Pension-Raiding Epidemic Worthy of Condemnation
- Predator in Chief
- Congress, Administration Discuss Next Steps on Iran
- Iran and The Diminishing Returns of Reasonableness
- Terror Plot's Mystery Link to Iran
- The Conservative Case Against a Border Fence
- GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012
- Learning From Mexico's Coalition Debate
- US Fears Misplaced When it Comes to China
- Sluggish America Can Still Be a World Leader
- Wall Street (Unlike)
- Newspaper Nostalgia
- Time Running Out for Obama To 'Re-Engage' and 'Re-Excite' Voters
- Rick Perry Proposal of American Troops in Mexico Stirs Criticism
- GOP Candidates Look at Narco-Terrorism Risks
- The Real Voter Fraud Scandal
- How to Achieve Transparency for the Supercommittee
- Military Spending Belongs on the Table
- Panetta Outlines Wide Range of Proposals to Cut Billions
- The Moral Question
- 'Flash Mob Politics' From Both Sides Now
- Occupy Wall Street Challenges America
- 'Occupy Wall Street' Tries to Harness Anger on the Left
- Occupy Chicago: Our Overripe Moment
- American Government's Indifference to Popular Protest
- Democracy's New Discontents
- Messiah Complex: The Sequel?
- Mitt Romney Believes in Corporate America
- Why Obama Is Down and Romney Is Up on Wall Street
- Early Primary Jumble Benefits Mitt Romney
- Christie's Right Decision
- Christie Out: Now Who for GOP Fiscal Conservatives?
- Herman Cain's Plan For First 90 Days as President
- All Aboard The Herman Cain Bandwagon
- Vote for Herman? Yes, They Cain!
- Herman Cain Lights Up Internet, Bachmann Goes Dark
- Herman Cain Booming But Many GOPers Still Leery of a Bust
- Why Obama's No Truman and Cain's No Eisenhower
- Sarah Palin Unlikely to Land VP or Cabinet Job Either
- Without Palin Followers Clout Will Dissipate
- Primary Madness Again
- Debate Reactions Are Part of the Republican 'Brand'
- Rick Perry's Rock and What It Says About Us
- Don't Write Rick Perry Off Just Yet
- Rick Perry Needs to Defend His Sensible Approach to Immigration Issue
- Discontented Republicans Search On for Mr. Right
- 'Centrists' Are Abandoning Ship
- Obama's Relevance: American Jobs Act
- Obama's Terrorist Dilemma
- Barack Obama's Divisive Class Warfare
- What Have They Done with Ron Paul?
- Ron Paul to Release $1 Trillion Spending-Cut Plan
- Supreme Court: Regrets? They've Had a Few
- Some Thoughts on a Half-Baked Idea
- White House Confident of Supreme Court Win on Healthcare
- Healthcare Law's Path Through the Supreme Court
- New Democratic Attack for a New Paul Ryan Plan
- Is Obama's National Infrastructure Bank the Answer on Jobs?
- We Are In a Modern-Day Depression
- Why 2012 Will Shake Up Asia and the World
- America's Government Contracting Bonanza Bilks Taxpayers
- The GOP's Lies and 'Monstrous' Lies
- The Only Thing Government Can Do Right: Kill
- Corporate Takeover of the 2012 Presidential Election
- Lamar Alexander's Choice
- Jon Huntsman: Moderate Republican in Immoderate Times
- Sarah Palin Dismisses Presidency As 'A Title'
- Mitt Romney Starting to Grow on Republicans
- Class War Is Bipartisan
- It's Class Warfare, All Right
- Trickle-Down Depression
- A Good Fight
- Postmodern Class Warfare
- Obama Needs to Acknowledge What Needs to Change in Himself
- A Bear of a Problem for Obama
- Newt Gingrich 2012 GOP Campaign Back on Upswing
- On This Let's Take the Tea Party At Its Word
- On Presidential Dreamers
- Will Rick Perry's Extreme Views Make Him Unelectable?
- The Debating Epidemic
- Debate Reactions Are Part of the Republican 'Brand'
- Wanted: A GOP Dating Service
- Media Making GOP Race Romney-Perry Too Early
- President Obama Leaves Too Much to Congress
- How Southern Republicans Aim to Make White Democrats Extinct
- Tyranny of the Typical
- Obama: A Dose of Reality
- How Obama's Deficit-Reduction Plan Could Backfire
- Obama Deficit Plan Could Derail Hopes for Super Committee Success
- Raising Retirement Age: Reflection of Our Evolving Economy
- Public Perception of Media Bias Hits Historic High
- Congress Needs a Three-Martini Lunch
- The Drug War Spreads the Bloodbath South
- U.S. Congress: Standard Bearer for Israeli Expansion
- Michele Bachmann 'Blames' Obama for Arab Spring
- Obama Vows to Do Away with Millionaire Tax Cuts and Reduce Deficit
- Vote on Disputed Trade Bill Could Be Hitched to Jobs Retraining
- New Post-Standoff Era Begins on Capitol Hill
- 5 Political Lessons of the Economic Downturn
- Republicans Keep Helping Wall Street and Banks Over Main Street
- With Poverty on the Rise, This is No Time to Slash the Safety Net
- Special Election Results: Troubling, But Not Apocalyptic for Democrats
- The Poor You Shall Always Have With You
- Major Theme of GOP Presidential Race: The Will to Punish
- 5 Ways to Reform Social Security
- It's Time to Study Social Security's Origins
- 10 Commentators the Right and Left Love to Hate
- Does the GOP Hate Women?
- First Medicare, Now Paul Ryan Tackles Tax Code
- GOP Economic Plan Unlikely to Find Much Common Ground With Dems
- Ron Paul Was Right
- Ron Paul's False Bargain
- A Perry Tale about the Prince of Privilege
- Rick Perry's Cowboy Certainty
- Rick Perry Faces Heat from GOP Rivals
- Debate Jars Rick Perry Out of Sweet Spot
- The Republican Assault on Voting Rights
- Obama Plans to Run Against Bush Again in 2012
- Boehner's Answer to Obama
- A Question of Competence
- Obama Becomes the Fall Guy
- Heroes of the Republic
- Two Cheers and One Jeer for the American Jobs Act
- Obama's Dilemma: Foreign Policy and Electoral Realities
- Obama's Middle East Dilemma
- How to Save Israel and the United States from Themselves
- Should Alzheimer's Be a Reason to Ditch Marriage Vows?
- Honoring the Memory of 9/11 By Honoring the Memory of 9/12
- Why the Republicans Want to Raise Your Taxes
- Wake Up and Smell the Politics
- Right-Wing Politicians Expose Themselves on Radio
- A Recovery Plan That Works
- Time for Boldness
- A President in Labor
- Seeking Jobs and Re-election
- Government Needs to Help Job Creators and Middle Class Consumers
- What the Debt Ceiling Deal Means for Consumers
- Debate Shows GOP 2012 Contest Is a Two-Man Race
- The GOP Field Expands -- and Narrows
- Rick Perry: A Lousy Amigo
- Rick Perry's Official Coming-Out Party
- Will Rick Perry's Democratic Past Hurt Him at the Polls?
- Rick Perry Gallops In
- Rick Perry Grabs 'Third Rail'
- Rick Perry's Plan to Help Blue States and Big Corporations
- For 2012, Sarah Palin's Time May Have Run Out
- Obama, Abroad, Is Adrift
- Disaster Relief or Corporate Greed -- Choice Should Be Easy
- Some Questions for Dick Cheney
- Back to School and Deeper in Debt
- 9/11 REMEMBERED VIDEO REPORTS
- 9/11 Prayer and Remembrance
- Al-Qaeda Lost the Battle Long Ago
- 10 Years of 9/11 Wars is Enough
- Why Al Qaeda is Unlikely to Execute Another 9/11
- 9/11 in Retrospect: Bush's Grand Strategy, Reconsidered
- 9/11 Anniversary: Rethink Needed
- 9/11 Anniversary: From Empire to Decline
- 9/11 Anniversary: Scanning Bodies, Stripping Rights?
- War Costs Greater Than Acknowledged
- 9/11 and the Successful War
- Reasons to Remember 9-11
- 9/11 Unity Is Just a Memory
- Did 9/11 Weaken or Strengthen the United States?
- Extremists: Power-Mad Brothers Under the Skin
- Myth and Reality After 9/11
- Captives to the Logic of Violence
- Bin Laden's Unintended Legacy: Revealing True American Colors
- Durban III Promises Wave of Islamophobia
Resolution Against the Machine | Politics
Copyright 2011, iHaveNet.com