The Next Hoover
"Worst president since Hoover."
Democrats have said this at one point or another about every Republican president since, well,
Such wishful thinking is rarely repaid. History just doesn't work like that. Lucy will always yank the football away from the Charlie Browns who think history will repeat itself perfectly. Fate, providence -- whatever you want to call it -- has a better sense of humor than that.
Which is why I'm beginning to think
The creation myth of the modern
Over the last two years, Obama and his defenders have constantly invoked this story to buttress the case for Obama's "new foundation" -- his version of a new New Deal.
Whatever the problems with this story -- and there are many -- the simple fact is that history has happened. We live with the consequences of the New Deal. Its institutions --
On liberals' own terms, to argue that we need something like another New Deal or Great Society is to argue that these institutions either don't exist or don't work. But few, if any, liberals say anything like that. Instead, they change the subject. They talk about the Bush years as if they were a cross between a libertarian fantasy and an anarchist dystopia a la "Mad Max."
Here's Obama in his
"Cut taxes, especially for millionaires and billionaires. Cut regulations for special interests. Cut trade deals even if they didn't benefit our workers. Cut back on investments in our people and our future -- in education and clean energy, in research and technology. The idea was that if we had blind faith in the market, if we let corporations play by their own rules, if we left everyone else to fend for themselves, America would grow and prosper."
What movie was he watching? At best this is a rock 'em-sock 'em robot battle between delusion and dishonesty. Rhetorically, Bush never advocated anything like any of this. Indeed, Bush the compassionate conservative described his philosophy thus: "When somebody hurts, government has got to move." More concretely, under Bush we had massive spending increases on education, alternative energy, NIH and health care. We saw the passage of the Sarbanes-Oxley bill, and the trade deals Bush pushed are now part of the Obama agenda.
But Obama needs to spout such hogwash in order to sell some very old "new" ideas.
It hasn't worked. Americans understand this isn't 1932 or 1964. Some even understand that many of our problems -- Housing? Entitlements? -- stem from the liberal accomplishments of the 1930s and 1960s. Professional liberals, however, remain in denial, insisting they suffer from a "communications" problem or some such nonsense.
At best, the Democrats bet badly on the business cycle. They expected the economy to recover quickly, as it usually does, and when it did they would credit their policies. That didn't happen. The "new foundation" has either hurt the economy or did little to help it. Worse, from the liberal perspective, it further soured voters not just on Democrats but on faith in government generally, which Obama was supposed to restore.
And that's the funny part. For reasons fair and unfair, the Great Depression discredited laissez-faire economics for a generation or more. Hoover, who was hardly the "market fundamentalist" FDR made him out to be, suffered largely from the (bad) luck of the draw, giving Democrats a chance to argue for a new deal of the cards. For reasons fair and unfair, Obama, who inherited a bad recession and made it worse, every day looks more like a modern-day Hoover, whining about his problems, rather than an FDR cheerily getting things done. Inadequate to the task, Obama is discrediting the statism he was elected to restore.
The punch line? When the economy finally rebounds, it might be just in time for Obama's replacement to get all the credit.
Available at Amazon.com:
Read the latest political news.
- The Next Hoover
- Obama Targets Bush's Tax Cuts for the Rich
- Another Round of Class Warfare?
- Send in the Clowns
- Obama Could Use Some Clintonesque Salesmanship
- Glenn Beck, President Obama & the Hunger for Purpose in Times of Transition
- Glenn Beck-A-Palooza
- Glenn Beck and His War on Christians
- Glenn Beck to Obama: Heretic!
- With Apologies to Cole Porter
- Glenn Beck's Ecumenical Moment
- Glenn Beck: What Revival Looks Like
- Shock Prediction: GOP to Take House Maybe Senate in 2010 Election
- 2010 Elections: October Surprises
- Obama Going Back to Basics
- The 'Conservative' Reagan and Other Political Myths Dispelled
- The GOP and Tea Party Declare War on the Constitution
- Redistricting Heightens National Political Stakes for State Races
- What Does Generic Republican v. Democrat Ballot Say About Election 2010?
- Dick Armey Explains the Tea Party Movement
- The Senator from Agribusiness
- Daley and Bush Parallel Lives
- An Evening with Arne Duncan
- Out of the Media Muck an Idiot Emerges
- Dilemma of the Open Megaphone
- Republican Party Platform: Welfare for the Rich
- Lower Expectations
- 2010 Election Focusing on Scare Tactics From Both Parties
- 2010 Elections: Year of the Bad Candidates
- 2010 Elections: McCain and Murkowski Primary Results Send Mixed Messages
- 2010 Elections: GM IPO Could Help Democrats
- 2010 Elections: Rich Candidates Pay Millions to Run
- Pro-Arizona Immigration Rhetoric Will Haunt Republicans
- 2010 Elections: More Cloudy Tea Leaves
- Dorsal Fins Surround White House
- John Boehner's Economic Prescription
- Tax Cut Issue Will Impact 2010 Elections and Obama in 2012
- This is Who 'We' Really is, Glenn Beck
- Glenn Beck's Rally: The Big Bust on the Mall
- How to Spread Dumb-ocracy
- 2010 Elections: Let the Lovefest Begin
- Obama's Cronkite Moment?
- Iraq: A Promise Kept?
- Election Day Shocker: 10 Percent Unemployment
- Gingrich and Palin: Twin Towers of Intolerance
- Ground Zero Mosque Madness
- Ground Zero Mosque: Islamophobia? Not Really
- Is the Great Mosque Debate Making Us Stupid?
- Strengthening the Political - Military Relationship
- Beyond Moderates and Militants: Charting a New Course in the Middle East
- Don't Tread on the 14th Amendment
- Focus on Bush Tax Cuts Masks the Real Issue
- Tea Party Terror
- Republicans Hit Obama for Ground Zero Mosque Comments
- Obama's Ground Zero Mosque Mess
- 'Ground Zero Mosque' Controversy Shows America's New Nativism
- Ground Zero Mosque Presidential Paradox
- Lack of Foresight Let 'Ground Zero Mosque' Controversy Balloon
- Please Mr. President, No More Teachable Moments
- Hope, Hate and Frustration
- Republicans Who Could Replace Michael Steele
- Florida's Marco Rubio Tops List of Tea Party Fundraisers
- Card-Carrying Member of the 'Professional Left'
- Memo to America's Middle Class: Obama Is Just Not That Into You
- National Deficit: The Ticking Debt Bomb
- Obama's Wins on Jobs and Healthcare Don't Mean Much to Voters
- Obama Follows Reagan's Campaign Strategy
- Democrats Push Elizabeth Warren as Consumer Watchdog
- Downsizing Defense
- Iraq - Mission Accomplished II
- Constitutional Amendments and Citizenship Rights
- 2010 Elections: Obama's Key Aides Could Help Democrats in 2010 Election
- 2010 Elections: Boehner Preps to Replace Pelosi as Speaker of the House
- 2010 Elections: Low Hispanic Turnout May Hurt Democrats
- Arizona Immigration Ruling Has Little Impact on 2010 Elections
- Obama: Not Your Grandfather's FDR
- What Year Is This?
- Honing the Obama Pitch
- Nostalgia for Buckley et al Is Misplaced
- Sarah Palin, 'Mama Grizzlies,' Carl Jung, and the Power of Archetypes
- Why We Shouldn't Keep the Bush Tax Cut for the Wealthy
- Magical Thinking in Washington
- Wake Up Washington
- The Final Lesson of BP
- Illogical Immigration
- Iran - The Next War
- Obama's Juggling Act in the Middle East
- Let's Preserve Freedom at Ground Zero
- End Poverty: Export Capitalism
- Why Can't Obama Get Anything Done?
- Washington's Crisis Checklist
- Place the Blame Where It Belongs
- What's Keeping President From Picking Best Person to Protect Consumers?
- Immigration Ruling Correct But 'Civil War' Remains
- Administration Lying About Arizona Immigration Law
- Immigration Problem Requires a Federal Solution
- Arizona Ruling May Backfire for Immigrants
- Immigration Reform Requires More Than Getting Tough or Feeling Good
- Republicans Running on Empty
- 2010 Elections: Republican Summer Action Plan: Hit Democrats, Blog, Retweet
- 2010 Elections: It's Obama Vs. Bush for Democrats on the Campaign Trail
- 2010 Elections: Republicans' Agenda Dilemma
- Democrats Focus on GOP Objections to Unemployment Bill
- Tea Party Candidates Raise Big Money for House Races
- 2010 Elections: Incumbents Work Overtime to Raise Campaign Cash
- 2010 Elections: House Candidates Ramp up Spending Ahead of 2010 Election
- Democrats Pushing Campaign Finance Bill Ahead of 2010 Elections
- None Dare Call It ... What?
- Why Are We Beginning to Hate Congress?
- Corrupt or Just Clueless? You Decide
- Lobbying Royalty Celebrate 20 Years
- Congress Must Act Now to Alleviate Child Hunger
- The GOP's Opportunity ... and Challenge
- Bipartisanship on Hold
- Gingrich Blasts Plan for Mosque at Ground Zero
- Build Mosque Near Ground Zero; It's the American Way
- 'Journolist' Affair: School of Journolism
- 'Journolist' Affair Worse Than Clinton Conspiracy
- 'Journolist' Affair: Open Conspiracy No Longer Merely Ajar
- Outsourcing Government
- The Secrecy State
- Unemployment Extension Win for Obama & Democrats
- The Boundless Beneficence of Big Brother
- Financial Reform Another Talking Point for Obama & Democrats
- New Finance Bill: Mountain of Legislative Paper; Molehill of Reform
- Obama and Big Business Trade Blame on the Economy
- The New Racial Mess
- Funny Thing Happened on the Way to Post-Racial America
- Chewing Up the Innocent While Spewing Racism
- Shirley Sherrod - Perils of the 24/7 News Cycle
- Breitbart's Bum Story
- Bad Boy of Pseudo-Journalism Exposes Himself
- 2010 Elections: Tea Party Dilemma
- A Tea House Divided
- Republicans Are Turning Against the Afghanistan War
- Chuck Schumer Is Most Active Member of Congress
- Financial Reform: Obama's Sales Challenge
The Next Hoover | Politics
(c) 2010 Jonah Goldberg