The Contradictions of Thinking and Living Ethically
Her friend praised the food chain's organic, green products, but Hawthorne criticized the company for being against unions and for leading to the closures of small local stores.
"It really struck me that two people in basic agreement in their ethical views could be so opposed on a supposedly progressive store," the author and journalist says. Her latest book, The Overloaded Liberal: Shopping, Investing, Parenting and Other Daily Dilemmas in an Age of Political Activism, expands on that realization.
Hawthorne, who has written for the
What do you mean when you say liberals are "overloaded"?
I'm examining living by certain values, and not just earning a paycheck, keeping your house clean, and taking care of your kids, but also trying to make sure that, in the process, you are not adding to the garbage or carbon emissions that are hurting the Earth. Cutting back on your use of resources, trying not to harm animals, trying not to exploit the people who make the things that you buy. You're trying to help the local storekeeper, but you're also trying to help the subsistence farmer in
What types of contradictions do you mean?
For example, do I want to buy imported organic apples from
Is it just liberals that are facing these dilemmas? Why not, say, conservatives?
I'm looking at what are typically seen as left-wing values. But many of these are shared by people who are more centrist, even right-wing. People on the right, of course, might have vales of their own. I'm sure that everybody who tries to live by ethical values beyond their basic practical needs faces some degree of overload and contradiction. I wouldn't want to measure who has more. But it's the liberals who I know best.
Give me an example of a daily dilemma that an "overloaded liberal" might face.
Take the issue of who makes your clothing. It's really hard to find clothing that wasn't made in a sweatshop in
How do you reconcile all those competing interests? Does it boil down to one's own priorities?
It's a constant juggling act, and you're right -- each person has different priorities. In some cases you might make carbon emissions more important, or you might make supporting local goods more important. You might not be consistent all the time. Usually there is no easy answer.
Is there a point where you have to draw the line and stop thinking about ethics?
I would never want to say, "The heck with it. I'm just going to buy what makes me happy." I don't think that's a good answer. I do resent a lot of the books out there that make it sound too easy. Sure, there will be times when you'll have to put ethical values aside. But if two ethical values are contradictory, you don't have to throw them both out the window. I'm not saying I have all the answers, what I'm really trying to do is to point out the questions.
Why is this an issue now?
The economy is still rough, and price is a major factor. So many of the "ethical" purchases are expensive, whether it's organic or recycled, or buying from your local stationery store instead of
What surprised you in writing this?
In the process of writing the book, I joined the local food co-op. I thought that would make life easy. It would make all the decisions for me, vet the products and put them on the shelves. But if the co-op didn't exist, we'd have to go shopping somewhere. That means that a regular supermarket nearby would be hiring people to do these jobs. So by creating the co-op and donating our unpaid labor, we have kind of eliminated several hundred jobs that people are getting paid to do elsewhere. These aren't the best jobs in the world, but they do tend to be union jobs, which means a certain level of wages and benefits. I certainly didn't set out to cost 300 people their jobs. Even something that should be simple and clear-cut, such as joining a food co-op, is not.
How do you think this book will surprise readers?
I do think a lot of the complications that go along with these choices will surprise people. For instance, many readers have probably never had to weigh the comparative advantages of helping subsistence farmers overseas versus buying locally. Things like that.
I do think he is a person who tries to live by his values. It seems to me that he might well face these dilemmas. Even if you have staffers who are buying your food and clothing, clearly they make their decisions as far as what food and clothing to buy. Hopefully it will open his eyes and help him.
"Ignorance is bliss." Could that be the motto for this book?
I don't think so. Ignorance is easy. But I don't consider bliss not living ethically. I consider bliss being happy and knowing that you've done good.
Available at Amazon.com:
Read the latest political news.
- Obama Edge on Financial Reform
- Resisting Wall Street Reform
- Time to Break up the Big Banks
- Obama Criticism of Arizona Immigration Law Ignores Federal Incompetence
- Arizona's Illegal Immigration Catch
- Open Season on Latinos in Arizona
- Arizona Takes Off Its 'Rainbow Shades'
- Arizona's Ugly but Necessary Immigration Law
- What Obama Can Learn From Bush
- Obama's Promise to Work With Foreign Governments
- Hoyer Sees Election Trouble for House Democrats
- Voter Anger Could Doom Democrats in Fall Elections
- Midterm Congressional Elections: Replicating Obama 2008
- Fran Hawthorne Discusses 'The Overloaded Liberal'
- Obama Should Not Appoint Another Appeals Judge to Supreme Court
- Presidents and Wars: Of Laureates and Cowboys
- Come November, 'The Fire Next Time'?
- Slick Willie Is Back and He's After the Tea Party
- Timing of Tea Party's Rise is Telling
- Tea Parties a Delayed Bush Backlash
- The Starving Armenians
- Capitalism vs. Capitalists
- Independent Charlie Crist Will Be Fun to Watch
- Prayer and State
- Obama Aims to Escape Washington Bubble
- Obama America's World Leader
- West Virginia Mining Disaster and Financial Crisis Have Same Root Cause
- Congressional Pig Book: Pigs at the Trough
- Five Reasons Harry Reid Can Win Reelection
- Clarence Thomas for President or Budget Boss
- Replacing Justice Stevens
- Empathy and the Supreme Court
- America Needs a Proud Liberal on the Supreme Court
- Fear Factor: Swine Flu, Nuclear Weapons, Reacting to Doom
- Women Leading and Stirring Tea Party Movement
- Watch What Obama Says Not What He Does on Cap and Trade Off-Shore Drilling
- Media Cheers Obama Ignores Tea Party Movement
- Tea Party and the Press: The Inconvenience of Truth
- Tea Parties Bust and Believe Stereotypes
- Tea Party Protesting the Protestors
- Republicans Doing Banks' Bidding
- To John McCain's Integrity: Rest in Peace
- How Much Taxation Is Enough
- Obama & Democrats Face Brighter Political Future
- Internet Was Buzzing About Healthcare But Obama Buzz Dropped
- United States - 5 Ways to Keep America Great
- Rise of Political Extremism and the Decline of Decency
- Why Democrats Should Try Bipartisanship
- Justice Gives up Bungled Abramoff-Related Lobbying Case
- Obama's Climate Czar Working Toward National Energy Policy
- Obama: Gold Standard of Manners
- Obama's Offshore Oil Decision Has Political Dimension
- Ongoing Melodrama of Victims and Oppressors
- Nuclear Roulette: The Obama Doctrine
- Pivot to Foreign Policy: American-Russian Cooperation
- Republicans Need a Plan B for Health Care
- Obamacare: The Eye of the Storm
- Health Care Bill - Aroused Vox Populi
- Michael Steele: GOP Leadership Dilemma
- Michael Steele fights GOP Culture Gap
- If We Europeanize Europe Is in Trouble
- The Next Injustice - Supreme Court Nominations
- Obama & Democrats Go On Attack
- Clash of the Titans: President Vs. Supreme Court
- Carville to Democrats: Pray Now to Avoid Disaster in November
- Simple measure could be top weapon against global warming
- Jim DeMint, Blanche Lincoln and Perils of Progressive Purity Politics
- Sean Hannity Names Obama's 15 Most Radical Aides
- Case for Mississippi Governor Haley Barbour in 2012 Presidential Race
- The Road to Bipartisan Financial Reform
- Tea Party Will Test GOP's Cat-Herding Skills
- Angry but Engaged Electorate
- Obama on the Rebound
- Obama's Self-Vindication
- GOP Tactical Contradiction
- Obama: The Same Old Drill
- The Hostility Follies
- Definition of Political 'Freakout'
- We Must Respect Families and Small Business
- In GOP a Black Comeback
- Right's Anger Could Backfire
- What Would Newt Gingrich Do
- Newt Gingrich Interview
- Drill, Baby, Drill! Obama Embraces Offshore Drilling
- Standing Up for Life or Something Else
- Al-Qaeda has Lost the Battle. But has it Won the War?
Fran Hawthorne Discusses 'The Overloaded Liberal' | Paul Bedard
(c) 2010 U.S. News & World Report