Our current high-skill immigration policy does more harm than good. To meet the needs of both the U.S. economy and American workers, the H-1B and L-1 guest worker programs require immediate and substantial overhaul. These programs are very large, accounting for about 1 million workers, and have a significant impact on U.S. labor markets. These impacts are especially significant in computer occupations, where they account for more than 10 percent of the workforce and are distorting the normal functioning of the labor, educational, and workforce development markets.
The goal of these guest worker programs is to bring in foreign workers who complement the American workforce. Indeed, many highly skilled and highly paid workers are brought in by employers to do so. However, loopholes have made it too easy to bring in cheaper foreign workers, with ordinary skills, who directly substitute for rather than complement American workers. The use of the programs for cheaper labor is substantial and growing, and they are clearly displacing and denying opportunities to American workers.
The problems in the programs stem from three serious design flaws that only legislation can fix. Administrative changes alone, such as stepped-up enforcement, while necessary, are not sufficient to correct the problems.
The first flaw allows employers to legally bring in foreign workers at below-market wages. How do we know that employers exploit this loophole? Employers have told the U.S.
Second, employers do not have to search for American workers before hiring an H-1B or L-1 and can even replace American workers with H-1Bs and L-1s. News reports indicate that American workers are being replaced by H-1Bs at companies such as
The third flaw is that the employer, rather than the worker, holds the visa, and as a result H-1B and L-1 workers are in a state of indentured servitude. Should they be terminated, H-1B or L-1 workers would have to leave the country immediately. As a result, H-1B or L-1 workers' bargaining power is severely limited, and they can easily be exploited by employers.
Unsurprisingly, many firms exploit these loopholes for competitive advantage and profit, at the expense of American workers and the American economy. Some of these practices require a keen eye to observe, such as enabling age-biased hiring or using guest workers as a substitute for investing in workforce development. But others are more obvious, such as the use of the programs to facilitate the offshoring of high-wage high-tech jobs.
For the past five years, the top H-1B and L-1 employers are using the program to offshore tens of thousands of high-wage, high-skilled American jobs. The list is a who's who in the offshore outsourcing business. Using the H-1B to offshore is so common it has been dubbed the "outsourcing visa" by
An even more disturbing outcome of these loopholes is that the programs have lost legitimacy among American high-tech workers who rightly believe their careers are purposely being undercut by government policy. This is especially worrisome since these workers are telling American students to avoid STEM professions, which threatens our future capacity to innovate and create jobs for the economy.
Another widespread misconception in the public discussion about employer-based immigration is that the H-1B is often mistakenly equated with permanent residence. But the employer has complete discretion over whether it chooses to sponsor its guest worker for permanent residency, and most of the largest H-1B employers sponsor very few of their H-1Bs for permanent residency. Just to provide one example: Between 2007 and 2009,
We can fix the flaws in the guest worker programs. Bipartisan legislation introduced in the last
- Lower Inflation Gives The Fed More Leeway in 2012
- What's in Store for Jobs in 2012?
- Our Challenge for 2012: Get Americans Working
- The Rebirth of Social Darwinism
- H-1B Workers in a State of Indentured Servitude
- Abuse of the H-1B Visa Program Is Widespread
- H-1B Visas a Symptom of Special-Interest Influence
- More Green Cards, Not H-1B Visas, Is the Real Fix
- We Are Creating a Dependency on H-1B Workers
- Unfilled Positions Reduce Productivity
- H-1Bs Are Simply Too Difficult to Get
- Most Immigrants Create Jobs
- White House Reiterates Urgency to Renew Payroll Tax Cut Bill
- Homegrown Obstacles to the Economic Recovery
- Does Extending Jobless Benefits Help the Economy?
- Men Continue To Fare Badly in This Economy
- Public Blames Congress, Not Obama, For Sour Economy
- Restore the Basic Bargain
- A Main Street Jobs Agenda
- Who Says Wall Street Isn't Hurting?
- Road Map to a Housing Rebound
- Housing Prices Drop Back to 2003 Levels
- GOP 2012 Candidates Split on Payroll Tax Cut
- We Need to Focus on the 99 Percent
- A More Permanent Solution Is Needed
- Keynesian Policies Have Failed
- Many Time-limited Tax Breaks Never Die
- A Strong Recovery Remains Elusive
- An Economic Loser in the Long Run
- Extending Payroll Tax Cut Will Extend U.S. Debt
- Jobs Report: A Glimmer of Hope for the Housing Market?
- Unemployment Rate Drops to 8.6 Percent
- Beige Book Shows Stronger Growth, but Europe a Major Threat
- What Happens If We End the Fed?
- Online Shopping Deals Hurt State Budgets
- 5 Reasons the Economy Will Be Better in 2012
H-1B Workers in a State of Indentured Servitude | Politics
Copyright 2012, U.S. News & World Report