|
Analysis
With just hours remaining before Election Day, both the Obama-Biden and McCain-Palin campaigns are making
their final pitch for your votes. Sen. Barack Obama hopes to hold off a late-inning McCain rally by repeating
several unlikely promises, which we examine in another article,
"Closing Arguments: Obama."
Meanwhile, hoping
to prove the pollsters wrong, John McCain and Sarah Palin flog some new attempts to cast doubt on Obama's
character; one concerns a seven-year-old interview and another, a five-year-old video.
McCain: The Case of the Palestinian Professor
The latest attempt to prove Obama guilty by distant association with an allegedly questionable character centers on a leading Palestinian scholar, Rashid Khalidi. McCain has accused the Los Angeles Times of withholding a videotape of a 2003 banquet honoring Khalidi at which both Obama and William Ayers were present. The Times wrote about the banquet in an April 2008 story, but says that it can't publish the tape because "it was provided to us by a confidential source who did so on the condition that we not release it," according to Times editor Russ Stanton.
That pledge to a source hasn't kept the McCain campaign from attacking the Times. McCain said last week on a Miami radio show that "we should know about their relationship including, apparently, information that is held by the Los Angeles Times. ... The Los Angeles Times refuses to make that videotape public." And Palin chimed in at an Ohio rally, "If there's a Pulitzer prize category for excellence in kowtowing, the L.A. Times wins."
The Times says that its story last April described the banquet in full. The occasion was Khalidi's impending departure from Chicago to accept a prestigious professorship at Columbia University. Obama spoke warmly of him and his wife, but, in contrast to some of the stridently anti-Israel remarks made by other speakers at the event, "Obama adopted a different tone in his comments and called for finding common ground," the story said. The piece also described Khalidi this way:
Los Angeles Times, April 10: [Khalidi] is seen as a moderate in Palestinian circles, having decried suicide bombings against civilians as a "war crime" and criticized the conduct of Hamas and other Palestinian leaders. Still, many of Khalidi's opinions are troubling to pro-Israel activists, such as his defense of Palestinians' right to resist Israeli occupation and his critique of U.S. policy as biased toward Israel.
Khalidi, according to the story, taught at a university in Beirut in the 1970s, sometimes speaking to reporters on behalf of the Palestinian Liberation Organization (though he says he was never part of the PLO) and in the 1990s helped advise the Palestinian delegation during peace talks.
The Obamas and Khalidis have socialized, and Khalidi hosted a fundraiser for Obama's failed 2000 run for Congress. Both men taught at the University of Chicago, and they lived near each other in the city's Hyde Park neighborhood.
The relationship between Obama and Khalidi is closer than Obama's more distant relationship with Ayers. But that doesn't mean that Obama accepts Khalidi's strident views about the Middle East. Obama has also forged strong ties with Jewish leaders and advocates for Israel over the years. He says he favors a two-state solution in which Palestinian and Jewish nations would peacefully coexist side-by-side, which is consistent with current U.S. policy, and he calls the militant Palestinian group Hamas a terrorist organization that must recognize Israel's right to exist and forsake violence before talks with it can begin. On his Web site, Obama states that he and Joe Biden "believe that our first and incontrovertible commitment in the Middle East must be to the security of Israel, America's strongest ally in the Middle East."
On the site, Obama also says:
Obama: [Khalidi] is not one of my advisors; he’s not one of my foreign policy people. His kids went to the Lab school where my kids go as well. He is a respected scholar, although he vehemently disagrees with a lot of Israel’s policy.
McCain hasn't always been so critical of Khalidi. Since 1993, the GOP candidate has chaired the board of the International Republican Institute, a group that conducts democracy-building activities abroad and is funded by the government and private (mostly corporate) donations. Under McCain's leadership, the IRI distributed at least one grant, for $448,873 in 1998, to a group Khalidi helped start, the Center for Palestine Research and Studies, according to the IRI's Form 990.
Taking a cue from Obama's brief exchange with Joe the Plumber, the McCain-Palin campaign has spent much of the last two weeks attacking Obama's "spread the wealth" comment. The attacks intensified last week after The Drudge Report unearthed a 2001 radio interview in which Obama discusses "The Court and Civil Rights." Both McCain and Palin have seriously distorted these comments. (You can read an excerpt of what Obama actually said in the sidebar on the left. A rough transcript is available at Fox News.)
On the stump in Ohio, McCain falsely accused Obama of describing a lack of redistribution as tragic:
McCain (Oct. 27): He [Obama] said that quote one of the tragedies of the civil rights movement is that it didn't bring about a redistribution of wealth in our society.
Not exactly. It's true that Obama does speak positively of "redistributive change," but he doesn't describe its absence as a tragedy. In fact, what Obama actually said was that "one of the tragedies of the civil rights movement was that the civil rights movement became so court-focused." It is a focus on the courts that Obama says is tragic, not the lack of redistribution of wealth. Had the movement engaged in more traditional politicking and organizing, he said, it might have been able to achieve more on that front.
Palin stretched the truth even further. According to ABC News, Palin told audiences in Pennsylvania:
Palin (Oct. 28): Sen. Obama ... described the Court's refusal to take up the issues of redistribution of wealth as a tragedy. ... Let me remind Barack Obama of something else. When judges don’t confiscate your property and your hard-earned – all of your hard-earned money and then re-distribute that, he may call that a tragedy. But I call it fairness and adherence to our U.S. Constitution.
This is wrong on multiple fronts. First, Obama doesn't say anything at all about judges confiscating either property or money. In fact, Obama says that the Court is "poorly equipped" to carry out any sort of redistribution. Indeed, Palin has Obama's position exactly backward. Obama told one caller that he was "not optimistic about bringing about major redistributive change through the courts" because the court system "just wasn't structured that way." That's a far cry from finding it "a tragedy."
McCain/RNC: Defense Cuts
A pair of ads from the McCain-Palin campaign and the RNC draw spurious connections between Obama and a false claim that Democrats have a "plan" to cut the military by 25 percent. Both ads are running in Virginia. The most egregious is a radio ad jointly sponsored by the campaign and the RNC. It features retiring Republican Sen. John Warner, who says that Obama's "liberal colleagues in Congress" have "announced they will cut defense spending by 25 percent." A narrator then informs us that "newspapers" have documented this nefarious "plan" from "Congressional liberals," warning that such cuts "would mean huge job losses right here in Tidewater," and citing unnamed "independent studies" as proof.
The ad's claims are based on an Oct. 24 editorial in Massachusetts' South Coast Standard-Times, which reports that Democratic Rep. Barney Frank "called for a 25 percent cut in military spending, saying the Pentagon has to start choosing from its many weapons programs." That may be what Barney Frank is saying for home-state consumption, but it abuses the English language to puff up his comment into a "plan" that "Congressional liberals ... announced."
And those "independent studies" mentioned in the radio ad? They appear to consist of a single article in the magazine Virginia Business. The article does address the importance of the military for Virginia's economy. But it doesn't say anything at all about how Frank's proposal would affect jobs in the Tidewater region. In fact, the article appeared nearly two months before Frank made his comments.
Actually, the only cuts Rep. Frank mentioned were in weapons programs and the war in Iraq. Neither would necessarily translate into a "huge" reduction in jobs in the Old Dominion as this ad claims.
An RNC television ad echoes some of the same themes as McCain's radio ad – and makes an explicit and misleading connection to Obama. The TV spot points out that Virginia is home to 209,000 defense-related jobs and asks what will happen if Obama is elected given that one of his "top allies in Congress" plans to cut spending by 25 percent.
But Obama is not planning to cut the size of the military. Just the opposite: He is calling for an increase of 65,000 troops for the Army and another 27,000 for the Marines. Nor is this plan news to the RNC; its own Web site criticizes Obama's plan to add new troops, saying that it would cost "Approximately $11.04 Billion Per Year," according to the RNC's estimate.
Neither ad bothers to mention McCain's own repeated calls for cuts in defense spending. On his Web site McCain pledges to "[r]eform procurement programs and cut wasteful spending in defense and non-defense programs." And, as we have reported before, in July the McCain campaign released a budget plan that, among other things, promised "slower discretionary spending in non-defense and Pentagon procurements" and went on to elaborate that "there are lots of procurements – airborne laser, Globemaster, Future Combat System – that should be ended and the entire Pentagon budget should be scrubbed."
This is just the first-half of our final series on the candidates' closing arguments. Be sure to check out our companion piece on Barack Obama's final pitch.
– by Joe Miller, Viveca Novak and Brooks Jackson
Source
Theimer, Sharon. "McCain-Led Group Active Abroad," The Associated Press, 19 Oct. 2007.
Wallsten, Peter. "Allies of Palestinians see a friend in Barack Obama," Los Angeles Times, 10 April 2008.
"McCain Campaign Accuses LA Times of 'Suppressing' Obama Video," Los Angeles Times, 29 Oct. 2008.
Diakides, Tasha. "McCain Pushes Obama Connection to Khalidi," CNN politicalticker, CNN.com, 29 Oct. 2008
Obama Radio Interview Excerpts (Jan. 18, 2001)
Obama: But the Supreme Court never ventured into the issues of redistribution of wealth and sort of more basic issues of political and economic justice in this society, and to that extent, as radical as people try to characterize the Warren court, it wasn't that radical. It didn't break free from the essential constraints that were placed by the founding fathers in the Constitution, at least as it has been interpreted. And the Warren court interpreted it in the same way – that generally the Constitution is a charter of negative liberties [that] says what the states can't do to you, says what the federal government can't do to you, but it doesn't say what the federal government or the state government must do on your behalf, and that hasn't shifted. And one of the, I think, the tragedies of the civil rights movement was because the civil rights movement became so court focused, I think there was a tendency to lose track of the political and community organizing activities on the ground that are able to put together the actual coalitions of power through which you bring about redistributive change, and in some ways we still suffer from that.
...
You know maybe I am showing my bias here as a legislator as well as a law professor, but you know I am not optimistic about bringing about major redistributive change through the courts. You know the institution just isn't structured that way. Just look at very rare examples where during he desegregation era the Court was willing to for example order, you know, changes that cost money to local school districts and the Court was very uncomfortable with it. It was hard to manage. It was hard to figure out. You start getting into all sorts of separation of powers issues.
McCain-Palin 2008/RNC Radio Ad: "Cuts"
Warner: Hello, this is Senator John Warner. Hampton Roads is home to the world's largest military facilities.
Barack Obama's liberal colleagues in Congress announced they will cut defense spending by 25%. Fellow Virginians: cuts in the defense budget will weaken Virginia's economy and weaken national defense.
John McCain is a true fighter. He'll champion Tidewater's leading role in our nation's defense.
Narrator: Newspapers document Congressional liberals have announced a plan to cut defense spending by 25% after the election. It would mean huge job losses right here in Tidewater. Independent studies prove it will mean fewer jobs. Fewer benefits for more communities in the middle of a recession. That's the Congressional liberals' plan if you give them your vote.
Paid for by McCain-Palin 2008 and the Republican National Committee.
McCain: I'm John McCain and I approve this message.
Republican National Committee Ad: "Military"
Narrator: American safety depends on Virginia. And Virginia's economy depends on our military. Two hundred and nine-thousand defense-related jobs – more per capita than any other state.
But what would happen if Barack Obama wins? One of Obama's top allies in Congress has already announced plans to cut our military by 25 percent. 25 percent.
What would that mean for your job?
The Republican National Committee is responsible for the content of this advertising.
Source: FactCheck.org
Recent Political Commentary
Bye-Bye 2008: Things I Want to Forget
Arianna Huffington
2008 was a very memorable year, featuring one of the most unforgettable presidential campaigns in history. I'd like
to take a moment to focus on the things that happened over the last 12 months that I'd love to forget.
Laissez-Faire Capitalism Should Be as Dead as Soviet Communism
Arianna Huffington
The collapse of Communism as a political system sounded the death knell for Marxism as an ideology. But while laissez-faire capitalism has been a monumental failure in practice, and soundly defeated at the polls, the ideology is still alive and kicking.
The Madoff Debacle
Arianna Huffington
Ambitious and risky undertakings featuring the weeding out of anyone who raises alarms, little-to-no transparency,
an oversight system in which no central authority is accountable, and the deliberate manufacturing of ambiguity and
complexity.
Does this sound Familiar? Is it Iraq? Fannie Mae? Citigroup? Bernie Madoff?
Arianna Huffington argues that the correct answer is "All of the Above."
Hillary Plus Obama Equals High Drama
Arianna Huffington on the Obama Administration
It's too early to tell what changes Hillary Clinton will bring to Barack Obama's foreign policy, but she's already had an enormous effect on his brand.
Hillary's appointment isn't even official, but the Obama/Clinton narrative has already left the realm of politics. Its twists, turns, shadings and complex emotions are the stuff of literature.
Arianna Huffington on Politics & President-Elect Barack Obama
Obama's high-tech outreach has been instrumental in getting people across the country to donate millions of dollars and contribute millions of hours working on the campaign. Will it now become a hub for civic action
Obama has always said that a call to service would be a central cause of his presidency. We will ask Americans to serve," he said in a signature speech in July. "We will create new opportunities for Americans to serve. And we will direct that service to our most pressing challenges.
Summit on Financial Markets and the World Economy
G20 Leaders gather in Washington DC to address the Global Economic & Financial Crisis
President Bush and world leaders gathered for the first in a series of meetings to discuss efforts to strengthen
economic growth, deal with the financial crisis, and to lay the foundation for reform to help to ensure that a similar
economic crisis does not happen again.
President-Elect Barack Obama: Can Obama Pull Off A Historic Presidential Double Play
Arianna Huffington on Politics & President-Elect Barack Obama
Change was driven by two things: our remarkable capacity for regeneration, and Barack Obama's remarkable
ability to tap into the better angels of our nature. You know something extraordinary is happening when
even Michele Bachmann, Sarah Palin and Joe Lieberman trip over themselves -- and their hastily discarded
invective -- to say nice things about Obama and the tremendous signal sent by his election.
Barack Obama Wins: Why All Americans Have a Reason to Celebrate President-Elect Obama
Arianna Huffington on Politics & President-Elect Barack Obama
Even if your candidate didn't win Tuesday night, you have reason to celebrate. We all do. Ten months ago, when Barack Obama won in Iowa, we had a glimpse of what was possible and what became real Tuesday night.
What I wrote then about one state is now true for the whole country: Barack Obama's impressive victory says a lot about America, and also about the current mindset of the American voter.
Barack Obama Closing Arguments Election 2008 Eve
FactCheck.org & the 2008 Election
With the finish line in sight, Obama serves up familiar, pie-in-the-sky promises.
In the last few days, Obama has wrapped up his pitch to the electorate with some misleading claims we've
heard before: He continued to ask voters to believe he can pay for every dime of an ambitious health care
plan and other spending proposals while cutting taxes for all but the most affluent. Budget experts say
that's unlikely. He also kept up the drumbeat on a promise to end "tax breaks for sending jobs overseas,"
as though that could do much to keep jobs at home. Experts say it can't.
John McCain Closing Arguments Election 2008 Eve
FactCheck.org & the 2008 Election
John McCain and Sarah Palin close their campaign with a new set of dubious attacks. In the final week, the
McCain-Palin campaign unleashed some all-new misleading attacks on Obama: McCain strained to tie Obama to a
Palestinian professor whose views on Israel are quite different from Obama's. McCain and Palin both distorted
a seven-and-a-half-year-old radio interview with Obama concerning the court system and civil rights. McCain and
the GOP ran ads claiming Obama's military budget would mean huge job cuts in Virginia, despite Obama's proposal
to increase the size of the Army and Marine Corps – and McCain's own calls for ending wasteful weapons programs.
Barack Obama It’s Official Obama Born in the USA and The Truth About Obama's Birth Certificate
FactCheck.org & the 2008 Election
Of all the nutty rumors, baseless conspiracy theories and sheer disinformation that we’ve dealt with at
FactCheck.org during campaign 2008, perhaps the goofiest is the claim that Barack Obama is not a
"natural-born citizen" and therefore not eligible to be president under the constitution.
There has never been anything but rumor and speculation to support such a claim, and zero hard evidence.
Barack Obama Should Spill a Little Red Ink to Turn a Few More Red States Blue
Arianna Huffington on Politics & the 2008 Election
Republicans, while still holding out hope for a "McCain Miracle," are increasingly worried that McCain is losing in a way that, as David Frum put it, "threatens to take the entire Republican Party down with him."
Democrats, while being careful not to count their electoral chickens before they're hatched, are privately worried about winning without enough of a majority in the Senate to really change things.
John McCain The Internet and the Death of Rovian Politics
Arianna Huffington on Politics & the Internet's Impact
Age has finally become an issue for John McCain. But the problem isn't the candidate's 72 years; it's the antediluvian approach of his campaign.
McCain is running a textbook Rovian race: fear-based, smear-based, anything goes. But it isn't working. The glitch in the well-oiled machine? The Internet.
What McCain May Be Planning & What Obama Can Do to Ruin It
Arianna Huffington on Politics & the 2008 Debates
Political horse-race fans are focusing on Obama's 11-point lead in the new Newsweek poll. But I'm focusing on the 10-point lead McCain has on national security and terrorism -- the only remaining issue voters believe the Republican candidate would be more adept at handling.
As the one arrow left in McCain's quiver-- other than appealing to racists -- national security becomes the likeliest playing field for that GOP fall tradition, the October Surprise.
The Winner of Presidential Debate II? 'That One'
Arianna Huffington on Politics & the 2008 Debates
In Debate II, John McCain twice laid out the criteria for how the American people should judge the candidates: In tough times, we need someone with a steady hand on the tiller. By that measure, Obama was the clear winner.
Does John McCain Still Agree with Ronald Reagan that Government is the Problem
Arianna Huffington on Politics & the 2008 Economic Crisis
Ronald Reagan, in his first inaugural address, famously declared that "government is not the solution to our
problem; government is the problem." Twenty-seven years later, in the midst of the worst economic crisis since the Great Depression, and
seven-plus years into the reign of Bush and Cheney, Reagan's anti-government battle cry should be on trial.
But, stunningly, it is not. This needs to change. The presidential candidates' view of the role of
government should be one of the central questions of the last 36 days of the campaign.
The Bailout Plan: Welcome to Economic Shock & Awe
Arianna Huffington on Politics & the 2008 Economic Crisis
Welcome to Economic Shock and Awe (or as some have dubbed it, according to Paul Krugman, "the Authorization for Use of Financial Force").
Even the amount of taxpayer money being bandied about -- $1 trillion -- is similar. Think you got your money's worth for the Iraq war? Congratulations -- you're about to buy another pricey debacle.
We've seen how negligent the Bush administration is with our money -- flushing billions on wasteful, mismanaged Iraq reconstruction and Katrina recovery projects.
The Palin Doctrine: Why the Neocons are So Excited
Arianna Huffington Politics & the 2008 Presidential Elections & Sarah Palin
Sarah Palin may not have known what the Bush Doctrine was, but we're getting a pretty good idea of what the
Palin Doctrine is. Or will be -- because it's still currently under construction. And what is it going to look like? Let's just say, it's going to seem familiar.
According to London's Daily Telegraph, the architects of the Palin Doctrine are a group of people who have been singularly wrong about virtually everything in the last decade -- the neocons, who have been briefing Palin for weeks.
As predicted, the fact that she didn't know anything wasn't a bug, it was a feature.
She's perfect for the neocons: likeable on the outside, a blank slate on the inside.
To borrow from an old cliche, if Sarah Palin didn't exist, the neocons would have had to invent her.
Sarah Palin: A Trojan Moose Concealing Four More Years of George Bush
Arianna Huffington Politics & the 2008 Presidential Elections
Did Sarah Palin wrongfully push to have her ex-brother-in law fired? Was she really against the "Bridge to Nowhere?" Did she really sell Alaska's plane on eBay, or just list it on eBay? Did she actually have any substantial duties commanding the Alaska National Guard?
The correct answer to all these questions is: Who cares?
Saving the GOP & The Unbearable Lightness of Being Sarah Palin
Arianna Huffington Politics & the 2008 Presidential Elections
You can see why Sarah Palin is such an appealing pick for John McCain. Along with all the things she brings to
the table -- fresh face, mother of five, hockey mom -- Sarah Palin is notable for what she doesn't bring: a track record.
If John McCain had picked any of the far more experienced candidates on his short list, they would have come fully equipped with a long paper trail
McCain Vs. Biden: Not All 'Foreign Policy Experience' Is Created Equal
Arianna Huffington Politics & the 2008 Presidential Elections
What's great about the Biden pick isn't just that he has "foreign policy expertise," it's the kind of expertise
he has, how he uses it, and how useful his expertise is for the unique challenges we currently face around the
world. His approach favors diplomacy and engagement. Contrast that with the approach of John McCain, who also
has "foreign policy experience."
Making The Case That McCain Isn't 'Ready To Lead' on National Security
What I'm really hoping is that Obama will use this downtime to regroup, recharge, and come back ready to relentlessly make the case to the American people that McCain isn't "ready to lead" on national security. Voters trust McCain on the war on terror; Obama needs to show them every day why they shouldn't.
"Swing Vote": What It Tells Us About the Race, and Why Obama Needs to Put Kevin Costner on His Ipod
The makers of Swing Vote, the new film starring Kevin Costner, have pulled off a rare double play, producing a smart political satire that is also heartfelt and moving. It's also a film that turns out to be remarkably relevant to the 2008 race.
Obama's Trip Bounce - Media Obsession With Polls Leads to a Bad Case of Premature Pontification
Isn't it strange that Barack Obama didn't get a bounce from his wildly well-received overseas trip? Of course, almost all of this analysis is based on polls taken before the end of Obama's trip -- a serious case of premature pontification.
Tell Me Again, Why is Obama's Popularity With Our Allies A Bad Thing?
I understand why John McCain's campaign is desperately looking for negatives in Obama's overseas trip. But why have so many in the media internalized the McCain campaign's claptrap?
The Latest Media Blind Spot: Viewing All Criticism of Obama Through a Right-Left Prism
In the last two weeks, there has been a flurry of stories that has tried to portray criticism of Barack Obama's recent stands as the sole province of disenchanted members of "the left" -- also referred to as "the far left", "left-winger bloggers", ...
Surge Amnesia : The Media's Newest Affliction
John McCain, aided and abetted by his loving protectors in the media, is running a victory lap on Iraq. Buoyed by a reduction in violence in Iraq, war supporters are crawling out from the shadows and beating their chests
Memo to Obama : Moving to the Middle Is For Losers
I looked at the Obama campaign not through the prism of my own progressive views and beliefs but through the prism of a cold-eyed campaign strategist who has no principles except winning. From that point of view, and taking nothing else into consideration, I can unequivocally say: The Obama campaign is making a very serious mistake. Tacking to the center is a losing strategy.
McCain's Campaign Funding Hypocrisy: Why are the Media Looking the Other Way?
Isn't it interesting how, after largely ignoring the issue for the last 30 years, during which the GOP consistently outfundraised and outspent Democrats in election after election, the media are suddenly all atwitter about whether the campaign finance system is "basically fair"? How dare Obama inspire 1.5 million donors, giving an average of $197 apiece, to help him raise more money than McCain?
John McCain: The Second Coming of Bob Dole
"Prominent Republicans . . . have been for the first time openly critical" of John McCain's "floundering campaign."
An NBC/Wall Street Journal poll released last week asked the question, "Who do you think will win?" The answer: Barack Obama 54; John McCain 30. Obama is unlikely to win in such a landslide, which means that millions planning to vote for McCain expect him to lose -- as was the case with Dole.
Scotty Come Lately - Seven Takes on Scott McClellan's New Book
In his book "What Happened: Inside the Bush White House and Washington's Culture of Deception," Scott McClellan offers withering portraits of George Bush, Karl Rove, Condi Rice and Scooter Libby, confirms that we went to war in Iraq under false pretenses, and that we were serially lied to about the outing of Valerie Plame.
Unmasking McCain: His Reactionary Record on Reproductive Rights
We've seen the exit polls. I get the anger and the disappointment. Really? In Clinton vs. McCain. And nowhere is the difference more profound than with reproductive rights.
Hillary Clinton's Defeat: A Historic Triumph
A front page story in Monday's New York Times wonders whether Hillary Clinton's flagging run for the presidency is "a historic if incomplete triumph or a depressing reminder of why few (women) pursue high office in the first place."
Political News Commentary and Opinion by Arianna Huffington
RSS
SHARE
| 
