What's Next For Airlines Paying by the Pound?
Now that Spirit Airlines has done the unthinkable, announcing plans to begin charging for carry-on bags this summer -- that's right, carry-on bags -- the question everyone seems to be asking is: What's next?
Pay toilets? Too late.
Airlines have always had a strained relationship with passengers of size, at least the ones in economy class. Fitting into a 17-inch wide seat is a squeeze for the average American, and it's becoming even more of one as the population expands. A Gallup poll found that the average American weighed 13 more pounds in 2007 than in 1990.
Solutions have ranged from Southwest's policy of asking XL passengers to buy a second seat, to the Canadian government's "one person, one fare" rule, which gives disabled and obese passengers a free extra seat on domestic flights. But in the current climate of relatively high fuel prices and an anything-goes attitude toward fees, would anyone be surprised if airlines began charging overweight passengers in the same way that the post office makes you pay more for a heavier parcel?
Making heavy passengers pay more, presumably for a second seat, could help air travelers such as Cricket Moore, who recently had the misfortune of sitting next to an oversize passenger on a flight from
"I was pushed against the armrest with my back twisted to avoid contact with my huge seatmate," remembered Moore, a retired civil servant who lives in
Then again, her flight was on
I'm hardly the first person to suggest that airlines might someday charge us by the pound. Two years ago, when fuel prices peaked and air carriers instituted new luggage fees, even the airlines admitted that nothing was beyond their imagination when it came to getting more money out of passengers and saving fuel. One of the earliest mentions of an airline weighing passengers dates back to 1985, when the German carrier
Exactly how an airline might charge passengers by the pound is something of a mystery. Would every passenger get weighed, with anyone over, say, 200 pounds being assessed a surcharge, like the one on overweight luggage?
Would your fare be based on your self-reported weight? Would lighter passengers receive a discount?
There's another solution to the problem of heavy planes, which is to make the planes themselves lighter. The newest aircraft, such as
Knowing the airline industry as I do, I bet they'll go for the upgraded planes and the pay-by-the-pound scheme.
As someone who came of age before airline deregulation, I'm troubled that we're even having this discussion. I wonder what legendary airline industry figures like
We know that when it comes to carry-on fees, it'll be a bumpy ride.
Last week, five U.S. senators weighed in on the issue by introducing the
Airline passengers often joke that they're treated like cargo, but this is one of those times when the rhetoric could someday match reality.
If it does, the joke will be on us.
Recent Vacation Ideas & Travel Destinations
- Krakow: Poland's Historic and Cultural Gem
- Europe this Summer: Mixed Bag of News
- 'Qualify' for a Fleecing?
- Forget Your Travel Agent: 4 Trips You Should Book Yourself
- I Had to Pay Twice For My Flights to Mexico
- What's Next For Airlines Paying by the Pound?
- What Parents Say About Family Vacations
- Low Cost Travel Accommodations: Home Exchanges
- Low Cost Travel Accommodations: Hospitality Exchanges
- Parents Who Shouldn't Be Allowed on a Plane
- Traveling with Pets
- The Best Airlines in the United States
- Spirit Airlines Hits Two New Lows
- Online Airfare Booking Conspiracy
- By Unbundling Airlines Make a Bundle
- Touring Rome When All Doesn't Go as Planned
- Traveling Greener as We Celebrate Earth Day
- Eating Tapas in Spain
- Exploring Greece's Ancient Past: Delphi, Epidavros & Mycenae
- Entertaining Edinburgh
- Honest Guest's Guide to Free Hotel Amenities
- Value Destination: Go Back to College
- Budget Hotels in Europe
- Healthy Eating at Disney World is Possible
- Where Are Cheap Round-the-World Airfares
- New-Style Vacation Trips Trip with the Grandparents
- Princess for a Day at Disney World
- Easter in Europe
- Premium Economy for Overseas Trips
- Healthy Hiking With Your Dog
- Four Secrets for Upgrading Your Next Vacation
- What's New in Eastern Europe in 2010
- Low Fare Airline to Europe? Sort Of
- Europe 2010: Pricey, But with Some Good Deals
- Too Sick to Fly? When to Put Yourself on the 'No Fly' List
- Lowest Airfare? You May Have to Connect
- How to Ensure Your Luggage Survives a Trip
- What Hotels Will Resort to For a Good Review
- Accidental Tourist? Tips for Maximizing Happy Coincidences and Avoiding Bad Ones
- Low Airfares That Vanish in a Click
- Air Travel Buying Extra Legroom
- Priceline Opens Up; Quikbook Goes Opaque
- Another Argument For Travel Insurance
- Travel Apps for Your Smart Phone
- 6 Ways to Save: Family Vacations
- My Hotel Lost a Star -- What Now?
- When Travelers Experience Discrimination
- Good Airline Fees? Some Are Worth the Money
- Clear Airfares Act Left Sitting on the Tarmac
- Rental Car 'Gotchas' That Can Cost You Real Money
(c) 2010 Christopher Elliott
World-renowned chefs with an extraordinary passion for food, share that passion. They make great cooking easier than you ever imagined. Each feature includes both an expert tip and an easy recipe - exactly what you need to transform your home cooking from acceptable to delectable.
Recipes Click Here
Movie Reviews, commentary and more. Plus Trailers from movies currently in theaters and available on DVD.
Movie Reviews Click Here