Everybody can agree that the privacy of children needs to be protected when they use the Internet.
Young children invite trouble by logging on, posting pictures of themselves, giving out their cellphone numbers, birthdays, home addresses and other personal information -- even on websites geared to their age-group -- if that data isn't protected.
The question is, whose responsibility is it? Regulators and Web-based companies don't agree how to do it, and their battle is being waged through the
Back in 1998 -- eons ago in cyber time --
The FTC, which has the authority to issue regulations and enforce COPPA, wants to update the law to address innovations in the online world, including social media platforms and new mobile devices and the apps that go with them. The updated regulations are expected by the end of the year.
But the commission is being met with fierce pushback from
Consider the use of plug-ins -- software that allows one website to offer a link to a page from another website. Simply by clicking their mouse, users can link to a video, an app, a photo or some other cyber experience. The popular ability to "like" another site via
The problem is where does responsibility lie for COPPA compliance with so much interconnectivity? Which entity is the legal operator of the content, and is therefore responsible for adhering to guidelines restricting information gathered from children?
The FTC is attempting to stretch the responsibility when websites are aimed at children or when companies have "reason to know" they are dealing with children. In reply, the tech firms argue that the FTC doesn't get that website publishers operate separately from plug-in providers and the two therefore can't be linked for accountability purposes.
A persistent problem facing Web companies is the difficulty of verifying how old a given user is.
The industry worries that the burden of potential liability would be chilling to the development of social media and other Web-based commerce.
Yet it's clear the rules need to keep up with new technology. The FTC recently announced a
Child advocates argue that this was not an isolated case. Preteens are not some marginal demographic -- they form a massive market for all manner of consumer products. And we should not assume that incursions into kids' privacy are merely accidental.
Protecting children's privacy -- to say nothing of that of adults -- from the mighty information-gathering powers of Internet marketers is no simple matter, especially for the marketer who wish to comply with regulations. However, that is no excuse for not doing it.
The back and forth of the FTC's extended comment period for the new regulations is all for the good. Ultimately, though, the industry needs to understand that the Web should not be an autonomous, self-regulating realm. Corporations are working hard to influence how people -- including children -- use cyberspace, and -- let's not kid ourselves -- their objective is to make massive profits.
Web enterprises are doing a good job figuring out new ways to make money. Now they need to focus some of their brainpower on how to do that while responsibly protecting children's privacy.
- Web Companies Need to Step Up on Protecting Kids Privacy
- We Humans Headed Toward Obsolescence
- Chinese Telecom Giants Deny Allegations Huawei, ZTE Pose Security Threats
- Google to be Top Ad Revenue Earner by End of this Year
- Microsoft to Use Google's Mistake to Boost Market Push for Bing
- Microsoft to Chinese companies: Stop Using Pirated Copies of Office
- Germany's IT Watchdog Warns Users Against Internet Explorer
- eBay Unveils New Design, Launches Same Day Delivery Service
- 6 Apps for a Good Night's Sleep
- Best iPhone Apps for Moms
- 4 Physical Therapy Apps That Speed Healing
- Rain or Shine: Developing a Weather App
- Why Is Parallel Programming So Hard
- App Marketing: Standing out from the Pack
- Open Source IDEs: An Update
- Mobile Technology Trends: Give Your Apps a Voice
- Mobile Apps and Accessibility
- Getting Organized: Developing an Organizational App
- Firefox Increases Browsing Speed with New Technology
Copyright © 2012 The Kansas City Star. Distributed by Tribune Media Services