What Happens If We End the Fed?
Libertarians, some Occupy supporters are among those calling for an end to the Federal Reserve
The "End the Fed" movement appears to have a lot going for it these days. Its adherents now include both conservatives and supporters of the Occupy movement. Perhaps its most prominent proponent, Rep.
Removing the institution at the helm of U.S. monetary policy since 1913 seems unrealistic, though, and opponents consider it a crazy idea, even dangerous. However, proponents keep up the call, using an array of arguments from economic theory to promoting liberty.
Whatever view one takes, ending the Fed is a goal much more easily stated than accomplished. But if Fed bashers got their wish, here are a few snapshots of how the country might change:
A New Monetary Standard
Many advocates of ending the Fed argue for a return to the gold standard, which
End to Constant Inflation (for better or worse)
Tying the dollar's value to a commodity could very well moderate inflation. If the country moved to a strict gold standard, for example, the money supply would be bound to the supply of gold, so printing more dollars would require acquiring more bullion to back them, a big disincentive. This notion, of course, pleases proponents of controlled government spending. Though there might be short-term bouts of inflation and deflation, in the long run, prices could easily remain stable. There are, of course, caveats. For example, massive borrowing could spark inflation. And the country would also be forced to periodically deal with the relatively unfamiliar territory of deflation. Returning to the gold standard in particular could make these problems worse. "The gold market can have very large movements within a day," says
Shock to the System
A change to the U.S. currency system could potentially be destabilizing to foreign economies. Kroszner says that, as many countries tie their currencies' values to the dollar, the potential deflationary effects of being linked to a gold standard would lead to more exchange-rate volatility. But advocates say the result would be more long-term stability for the global economic system. "I think it would be extremely positive, but the initial effect would be so bold as to be alarming," says
A Sad Day for Keynesians
Most Keynesian economists believe that expansionary monetary policy moves can boost economic growth. The U.S. has seen this at work most notably with the latest round of quantitative easing, known as QE2. The effectiveness of quantitative easing, especially balanced with associated inflation risks, have been hotly debated in recent years. But no more Fed would simply mean no more easing programs.
Saving May Be More Attractive
Shelton argues that the Fed, with its near-zero interest rates and contributions toward dollar devaluation, "makes a sucker out of a saver." "You save money, you've got zero interest for saving it, and by the time you get it back out, it's worth less," she says. Without the Fed pushing interest rates low in hopes of stimulating the economy, says Shelton, saving money could be much more rewarding.
Ending the Business Cycle
This is how
A New Regulatory System
The Fed does much more than determine the monetary base; its chief functions also include supervising and regulating banks -- arguably very important functions, especially post-financial-crisis. Without the Fed in place, a new entity would have to perform these functions. In Shelton's opinion, this could be done either privately or federally.
More Market-Based Interest Rates
The Fed has been around since 1913, so it seems difficult to envision exactly how a Fed-free monetary system would look. According to Kroszner, without a central bank, the U.S. might revert to the system in place before the creation of the Fed: one of private clearinghouses that would determine short-term liquidity, altering short-term interest rates. However, Kroszner points out, longer-term rates are already largely determined by supply and demand.
A Fairer Banking Industry?
"Fairness" is, of course, subjective, but Fed critics argue that two of the Federal Reserve's chief functions -- selling bonds and regulating banks -- are at cross purposes and make for an unfair market. "If [the Fed] goes into a community bank and says, 'We're very uncomfortable with your loans to entrepreneurs...but we won't penalize you at all if you buy U.S. Treasury bonds,' that's a huge conflict of interest. That makes me uncomfortable, that the Fed has the inside track on the financial resources of the country," says Shelton.
Read the latest political news.
- Public Blames Congress, Not Obama, For Sour Economy
- Congress is Paralyzed Until More Americans Speak Up
- The Hijacking of the First Amendment
- George McGovern: Barack Obama, Democrats Need a Backbone
- Is Public Financing for Elections Finished?
- Backers Say Newt Gingrich Will Energize Base
- Newt Gingrich: The New Mr. Nice Guy
- Gingrich Might Want to Take a Bath Himself
- Mitt Romney: An Attack on the Truth
- Mitt Romney: The Castor-Oil Candidate
- Supporters Say Romney Should Focus on Obama and Ignore his Rivals
- Romney's Mormon Faith Likely a Minor Issue in General Election
- The Price of GOP Orthodoxy
- Newt Gingrich - Compassionate Conservatism: The Sequel?
- Newt's Bleeding Heart
- Gingrich Brings Common Sense to Immigration Debate
- Newt Gingrich Right to Bring Morals to Immigration Debate
- Newt Gingrich Plan Would Mean More Illegal Immigrants
- On Immigration, Newt Gingrich Has Right Questions, Wrong Answers
- Why Losing Presidential Candidates Stick it Out
- Michele Bachmann Comes Up Empty With Congressional Endorsements
- GOP Debate Mania
- Democrats: Courting Joe the Puppeteer
- 'The Spike' -- 80 years later
- Most Americans See Through Humbug About Taxes and Spending
- Blow Taps for the Tea Party
- The Decline and Fade of the Tea Party
- Tea Party Icon Allen West Discounts Pew Poll on Movement's Popularity
- Republicans Put Loyalty to Norquist Over Country
- Democrats Retiring May Portend Gloom in 2012 Congressional Elections
- A 'Followership' Crisis
- Pentagon Warns of Smallest Force Since WWII
- Catering to the Frozen Pizza Lobby
- What Happens If We End the Fed?
- Herman Cain Drops Out of the Race for Presidency
- Global Corruption: Party Systems and the Control of Politicians
- A Main Street Jobs Agenda
- Restore the Basic Bargain
- Online Shopping Deals Hurt State Budgets
- GOP 2012 Candidates Split on Payroll Tax Cut
- We Need to Focus on the 99 Percent
- A More Permanent Solution Is Needed
- Keynesian Policies Have Failed
- Many Time-limited Tax Breaks Never Die
- A Strong Recovery Remains Elusive
- An Economic Loser in the Long Run
- Extending Payroll Tax Cut Will Extend U.S. Debt
- White House Reiterates Urgency to Renew Payroll Tax Cut Bill
- So the 'Super Committee' Failed. How Will That Affect You?
- Supercommittee Failure Brings Little Hope for Congress' Popularity
- Deficit Is Greatest Security Threat
- Cutting Back on Defense Spending Will Make the World Safer
- It Is Time for Discipline, Defense
- Defense Spending Not to Blame for Deficit
- Military Already Underfunded Thanks to Obama
- Cutting Defense Spending Is Short-sighted
- Reasonable Ways to Cut Defense Budget
- Cutting Military Spending Does Not Mean Cutting Defense
- Cuts to Defense Budget Might Be Inevitable But Pentagon Knows Best
- Charlie Cook Sees GOP Winning Big in 2012
- Norquist's Influence: Anti-Tax Pledge Strengthened by Campaign Spending
- Will Occupy Wall Street Survive Eviction?
- Misrepresenting Occupy Wall Street
- Occupy Your Bank
- Big Banks are Doing Just Fine, Thank You
- The Class War is So Over
- Top Democratic Governor Accuses Republicans of Neglecting Economy
- GOP Presidential Race Poised for Mud-Slinging
- Why the GOP (and Democrats) Should Be Thankful for Mitt Romney
- To Win, Newt Gingrich Needs Cash and Discipline
- 'Likeability' Unlikely to Derail Gingrich in GOP Primary
- Ron Paul: Federal Reserve is Like Drug Addiction
- Tea Party: Buyer's Remorse
- A Call for an Enlightened Foreign Policy toward Latin America
- Is the National Security Complex Too Big to Fail?
- Alabama Law Against Illegal Immigration Suffers Setback
- A Fair Tax That Really Is One
- On Harnessing the Rage
- Without Park to Sleep In Occupiers Should Change Strategies
- End of Park Occupation Raises Questions About Future
- Blame It on Brokaw
- An Idea Dysfunctional Washington More Than Happy to Let Die
- Dear Average American: It's All Your Fault
- Obama Unbound
- Romney More Savvy at Profiting Off of Layoffs and Bankruptcies
- The Corporate Pledge of Allegiance
- Wanted: Adult for President
- Newt Gingrich: The GOP's Leadership Bankruptcy
- Newt Gingrich Enjoys His 15 Minutes at the Top
- Why Newt Gingrich is Back -- for Now
- In Debates, Newt Gingrich's Real Target Is Obama
- Mitt Romney's Latest Pitch
- Herman Cain: Clearing the Knowledge Bar
- Rick Perry: The Politics of Self-Destruction
- The Coming Collision
- Rookie GOP Candidates Lead to Campaign Blunders
- GOP Debates More Entertaining than GOP Policies
- Mitt Romney Goes After Federal Employees in Fiscal Plan
- On the 'Super Committee' Menu: Social Security Cuts and Tax Hikes
- 'Super Committee' Looking Stalled
- Grim Warnings for the Deficit 'Super Committee'
Foreign Influence Inappropriate for
Lawmakers Tasked with Shrinking Deficit
- One Nation, Gone Awry
- Tax Wall Street to Heal America
- United States in Decline -- If We Allow It
Statue of Liberty Turns 125
Old Immigration Attitudes Alive as Well
- GOP's Empty Rhetoric on Obama's Immigration Record
- The Jobs Crisis is Over!
- President Obama: We Can't Wait
- John Paulson's Plaintive Plea
- Why Occupy Wall Street Needs a Republican President
Turning Point for Occupy Wall Street:
Does It Have a Political Strategy?
- Who Are These Fat-Cat Few at the Top?
- The Great Local News Heist
- Scandal in Presidential Politics
- Herman Cain Bungles Scandal Management 101
- 'Our' Blacks vs. 'Their' Blacks
- Herman Cain: Sexual Harassment Has Nothing to Do with Race
- Herman Cain's Gauntlet
- Herman Cain: Herman Agonistes
- Herman Cain's Scandal Pain
- Raising Cain
- Herman Cain: Blaming the Opposition
- Tim Pawlenty's Lost Chance
- Cutting Taxes for the Rich Never Ends Well
- Equal Taxation for Wealth and Work
- Not All Taxes Have to Hurt
- Secret of the Flat Tax
- Current Tax Code Is Confusing
- Flat Tax Would Eliminate 'Crony Capitalism'
- Flat Tax Would Introduce New Problems
- Flat Tax Unites Americans
- Flat Tax Unleashes Economic Growth
- Flat Tax Shifts Burden to the Middle Class
- Flat Tax Will Benefit Only the Rich
- Wall Street Is Back to Its Old Tricks
- The World Is Finally Fighting Off the Infection of Neoliberalism
- America Now More Pro-Civil Service Than Russia
What Happens If We End the Fed? | Politics
Copyright 2011, Tribune Media Services