United States Shouldn't Create Underclass of Immigrants
House Republicans don't seem to get it. After getting pummeled by Hispanic voters in the 2012 election, they now want to create an underclass of 11 million people - mostly Latinos - by denying undocumented immigrants a path to citizenship.
Goodlatte and other House Republicans suggested instead that undocumented people be given a legal status without a pathway to citizenship, something they presented as a midway solution to the U.S. immigration crisis.
While details of the various immigration bills being drafted in
1. House Republicans, such as Goodlatte, are proposing to give undocumented people a temporary legal status that presumably could be renewed indefinitely, but that would not include a path to permanent residency, or citizenship.
2. Senate Republicans, including Sen.
3. Obama and most House and Senate Democrats would give undocumented immigrants a direct path to permanent residency and citizenship if they pass background checks, pay a penalty, pay taxes, learn English and wait in line behind those who are trying to immigrate legally.
Pro-immigration advocates say that under Obama's plan, most of the 11 million undocumented immigrants could achieve citizenship in about 12 years, while under the Rubio plan it would take them up to 25 years.
"We have an example in American history in which we denied people citizenship, called slavery," Sharry told me. "It's bad for America, for our social cohesion, for our belief in equality and for the functioning of democracy."
Critics of the House Republican no-citizenship plan say that, far from being a midway solution, creating an underclass of temporary residents without a path to citizenship would institutionalize rampant labor abuses.
Since temporary residents would have to renew their status periodically, they would be subject to exploitation by unscrupulous bosses, critics say. In addition, an underclass of immigrants without a path to citizenship would alienate millions of people, and increase social tensions.
"When you don't allow people to blend into society, like in
Opponents of a path to citizenship for the 11 million undocumented immigrants, in turn, argue that their proposal for a temporary and renewable legal status is far better than the current situation, in which we have millions living in the shadows, under constant threat to be deported.
My opinion: Granted, the House Republicans' new immigration stand is a clear improvement from the anti-immigration, anti-Hispanic, bigoted positions that many of them passionately defended during the 2012 campaign.
But creating an underclass of noncitizens is not the solution to the U.S. immigration mess.
House Republicans' real motive for denying a path to citizenship to undocumented immigrants, most of them Latinos, is that following the November election - in which 73 percent of Hispanics voted for the Democrats - most of the future citizens would vote Democratic.
But, beyond politics, denying millions of undocumented immigrants a path to citizenship is a bad idea because it would only help kick the problem forward: 10 or 15 years from now, we would have 11 million people and their relatives demanding their right to vote, and to have full rights.
That would be of little help for Republicans to mend fences with Hispanics, would be morally questionable, and would be a recipe for increasing social tensions in the country.
Read the latest political news.
- Gilded Class Warriors
- 'Assassination Memo' a First Step in Setting New Warfare Parameters
- The Double Threats
- Rush to the Defense? Not So Fast
- Why Annihilate the GOP?
- A New GOP, or Just A Cosmetic Touchup?
- Government Spending That Isn't Smart
- Obama's Second Coming
- Operation Hubris
- Can the GOP Escape Its Bubble
- Leave Liberal Hollywood to the Liberals
- Can GOP's Local Success Translate to Federal Level?
- United States Shouldn't Create Underclass of Immigrants
- Rubio vs an Invisible Obama
- Marco Rubio's Problem Wasn't the Water
- Rubio and the GOP's Thirst for Leadership
- The GOP's Civil War Stumbles On
- Two Cheers for Republican Rebranding
- Obama's Blunt Challenge to Congress
- Conservative Business Leaders Should Widen Their Scope
- Calling Out Bugnut Idiocy
- No Easy Answers for Gun Woes
- A Time to Resist
- Recycling Old and Failed Ideas
- Obama: An Energized Lame Duck
- Obama's Place in History Already Assured
- Obama's License to Kill by Drone
- Drone Double Standard
- Torture Helped Get bin Laden?
- Let Us Prey
- A Message to Obama, Served Cold
- Government Should Not Define 'Church'
- Where The Buck Still Stops
- Republicans Make Nice, But Are Their Hearts True?
- Incoherent Immigration Reform
- The Eye Doctor and the 'I' Pol
- 60 Minutes' Missed Opportunity
- Obama and Rubio: A Study in Contrasts
- State of the Union, At Home and Abroad
- The Minimum Wage and The Meaning of a Decent Society
- The Hoax of Austerity Economics
- Diplomacy: Lying Politely
- United States and Israel Push The Boundaries of International Law
- Pentagon Keyboard Jockeys Can Now Out-Decorate Combat Heroes
- One Day The World Will Thank Bush For Shaking Up The Arab Region
- Has Obama Kept His Open-Government Pledge?
- State of the Union Allows Presidents to Outline Agenda
- State of the Union Address Likely to Focus on Domestic Issues
- Obama Again Offers to Negotiate Big Deficit Deal
- Immigration Reform Plan is a Farce
- The GOP Crack-up and Obama's Unraveling of the Republican Coalition
- GOP: Rest in Peace?
- A Time to Build
- Obama's Challenge
- Obama's Debt-Ceiling Strategy Could Put The Squeeze on GOP
- Obama's Battle Hymn of the Republic
- Why I'm Singing the Inauguration Blues
- Obama's Inaugural Address Not Progressive Enough
- Taking Joe Biden Seriously
United States Shouldn't Create Underclass of Immigrants | Politics
(c) 2013 Tribune Media Services, Inc