The Gitmo Distraction
Robert C. Koehler
America's charade of change comes complete with national "debate" and a slight readjustment of the center to accommodate the Bush Lite policies of the Obama presidency.
What matters is that any change President Obama proposes be symbolic rather than substantive. A furious battle then ensues over the symbolic change so that, if it does finally come to pass -- with the president weathering the endless flow of invective and fear-mongering from the Republican right -- it will appear as though something was actually accomplished.
Meanwhile, business as usual holds course. The great swell of hope for a renewal of American society that swept Obama into office -- for a real accounting of the crimes of the Bush administration, not to mention a reversal of its most heinous policies and a return to value-based governance -- dissipates into the vague, scattered disappointment of millions of supporters, who once again have no focus for their disaffection.
And nowhere does this scenario hold sway more than in regard to the treatment of detainees in the war on terror and the continued existence of the
With Obama's ascendancy, common sense -- and the great yearning of so many Americans for governance based on fairness, for policies that pursued justice rather than war and did not dehumanize people -- seemed to regain the center of American society. But this was not, in fact, the case. Common sense is still marginalized as "the left," counterweighted in the media by the intensifying stridency of the highly organized and well-financed Republican right.
Thus, the Obama administration's attempt to close Gitmo -- just that, minus any accompanying change in policy that would make this action meaningful -- is consuming pretty much all the political capital the administration has to spare, as the Republicans, led by House Minority Leader
"And they can do the tribunals right there at Guantanamo," Boehner, speaking for the dug-in right, said this week on
This, then, is the "debate" as it is being played out in the media. It begins with most Bush-era assumptions still intact. The prisoners, shut in their cages like dangerous beasts all these years, are obviously bad people -- terrorists -- whose shackled, heavily guarded presence anywhere on America's sacred soil is an outrage and a danger. This is the blather of security clowns, unconnected to reality, but no matter. It skews the issue.
The issue is no longer the enormous betrayal of American values that resulted in the establishment of indefinite-detention facilities for Muslim men rounded up in
If the whole issue is shutting down Gitmo because the rest of the world hates it, then the deal in the works between the Obama administration and Republican Sen.
But maybe this high-cost deal will come to pass and, while the concept of real rather than show trials for detainees will have been abandoned, Gitmo will wind up shutting down. Phew, America's blot of shame removed. We can all move on.
But will it be hollow symbolism, with no real change? Will the prisoners just be shunted elsewhere, still without access to justice? Certainly there will be no deeper push for an accounting from Bush administration officials about torture and other war crimes.
And what about
Read the latest health care reform news.
- 'Dotcom' Turns 25: Predictions for What Comes Next
- Obama's Healthcare Focus Is Misguided
- Obama Gets High Scores on Leadership Report Card
- Obama: Another Partisan Push for Another 'Comprehensive Reform'?
- Why Earmark Reform Has Not Changed Much in Congress
- Who Would Be Best Governor of California
- Democrats Release GOP 'Hypocrite' List After Rangel & Massa Ethics Charges
- Democrats Losing Support of Blue-Collar Voters
- Grover Norquist says Republican Party has no Leader
- Obama's Reset Reset Foreign Policy
- A Democratic Reality Check
- The Real Patriots
- The Gitmo Distraction
- Things I Don't Believe
- Don't Know Much About History and Don't Wanna
- Dennis Kucinich: A Relevant Outsider
- On Our Co-Equal Branches
- An Engaged Vice President
- Reading Tea Party Leaves
- 'Undercover Boss' Most Subversive Show on TV
The Gitmo Distraction | Robert C. Koehler
(c) 2010 Robert C. Koehler