Obama's Budget Falls Short of Deficit Panel Recommendations
Republicans charge that the White House proposals don't go far enough
The Obama administration's 2012 budget attempts to achieve fiscal responsibility while spending on priorities the president says are necessary to "win the future." At an appearance at a Baltimore middle school on Monday, the President characterized the two goals as inextricably linked: "the only way we can make these investments in our future is if our government starts living within its means, if we start taking responsibility for our deficits." Though the proposed 2012 budget makes some major cuts, they fall far short of the recommendations made in December by the National Commission on Fiscal Responsibility and Reform, which President Obama charged with identifying ways to improve the government's fiscal situation.
Obama's budget does take steps toward addressing federal red ink. It reduces spending to $3.7 trillion from 2011's total of $3.8 trillion, and it cuts the deficit even more steeply, from 2011's $1.6 trillion to $1.1 trillion for fiscal year 2012. Furthermore, it reduces the deficit as a share of GDP from 2011's 10.9 percent to 2.9 percent by 2018. But the deficit commission called for $3.9 trillion in overall deficit reduction through 2020. The White House budget would achieve just over one-fourth of that total, $1.1 trillion, through 2021.
Office of Management and Budget Director Jacob Lew said Monday that the budget proposal makes significant strides toward cutting deficits. "This budget does accomplish what was the task given to the commission, to bring the deficit down to 3 percent of the economy," Lew said, adding that the administration's proposal "draws heavily on the ideas of the commission."
While that may be true, the budget omits several major commission recommendations. One notable example is the commission's call for massive Social Security reform, including a gradual retirement age increase to 69 in the year 2075, up from the current range of 65 to 67 years. Likewise, the commission called for an overhaul of the income tax system, eliminating tax breaks like the mortgage interest deduction but also lowering tax rates across the board. The Obama budget makes only minor changes to Social Security and in part relies on tax increases, such as the 2012 expiration of the Bush tax cuts, in reaching its deficit-reduction goals.
In several other cases, the Obama plan echoes the commission but does not go as far. For example, the deficit commission's plan would get rid of all federal student loan in-school interest subsidies. Under Obama's plan, such subsidies would be eliminated for graduate students only. Additionally, the commission recommended a reform of corporate tax law by cutting tax rates but also eliminating many tax deductions and credits. The President's budget also eliminates "tax breaks and loopholes," particularly for oil, gas, and coal companies, and calls on legislators to start "the process of corporate tax reform." However, the budget does not contain a specific proposal for changing that tax code.
There are those who consider it a good thing that the budget proposal does not adhere closely to the commission's recommendations. Some high-profile economists, including Nobel Prize-winners like Joseph Stiglitz and Paul Krugman, were critical of the commission's recommendations, warning that drastic spending cuts are ill-advised at a time when they say economic stimulus ought to be a priority. And President Obama's budget includes initiatives that the administration has touted as potential engines for job creation. The proposal would allocate $148 billion for research and development in areas like energy and cybersecurity, and also includes significant infrastructure spending, including $53 billion to be spent over the next six years on passenger rail.
Robert Greenstein is executive director of the nonpartisan Center for Budget and Policy Priorities, a policy institute that advocates for the interests of low-income individuals in public policy, and he believes that the Obama budget does not contain enough long-term deficit-reduction fixes. However, he says, it is an "important step," and one of its major accomplishments is the stabilization of the debt as a share of GDP. The proposal estimates that the debt-to-GDP ratio, at 75.1 percent for 2012, would only increase to 77 percent by 2021. "Stabilizing the debt as a share of the economy is the most important fiscal goal for the decade ahead, as recent high-level fiscal commissions have noted," says Greenstein, alluding to the deficit commission.
However, top congressional Republicans remain unimpressed, and the White House's proposal will likely change drastically in the hands of a Republican-controlled House. Wisconsin Rep. Paul Ryan, Chair of the House Budget Committee, said that the proposed budget does not go far enough toward cutting spending. "It would be better doing nothing than if we were to actually pass this budget," said Ryan. He added, "I really thought, given that the President created a fiscal commission, that we would see an advancement." When the Republicans release their proposed budget this spring, it will almost certainly be smaller than the President's. The real battle then will be over which is better for the country.
Read the latest political news.
- The Two-Party System is Making America Ungovernable
- Obama's Budget Falls Short of Deficit Panel Recommendations
- Republican Budgetary Woes
- Smoke, Mirrors and Other Deceptions
- Chicken Little and the Debt Ceiling
- Healthcare Reform Law Requires New IRS Army Of 1,054
- GOP Falling Into the Same Healthcare Trap That Snared Democrats
- Obama and Big Business the Unlikeliest of Neighbors
- How Business Can Do Business With Obama
- Mitt Romney Takes Aim at Obama During CPAC Speech
- Palin Leads GOP Presidential Hopeful Fundraising Race
- George H.W. Bush Has Earned the Presidential Medal of Freedom
- Liberals Mobilize to Save PBS and NPR Funding
- Senate Looks at Holds and Confirmation Delays
- Seeking the Real Ronald Reagan
- Told You So
- Impending Debate Over Spending Cuts Has Nothing to Do With Reviving Economy
- The Great Jobs Recession Goes On
- Pruning Farm Subsidies
- What Today's Leaders Can Learn From Ronald Reagan
- Reagan and Obama: Differently Similar
- Ronald Reagan: The 40th President at 100
- The Myth of JFK as Supply Side Tax Cutter
- Is Obama's Pro-Business Rhetoric for Real?
- Barack Obama's Progressive Problem
- Obama's Sputnik Analogy Doesn't Fly
- Obama Challenges America to Win the Future
- Why Congress Should Repeal and Replace the Healthcare Reform Law
- Healthcare Reform Law Repeal Would Be Inhumane
- 10 Ways the GOP Can Take Down Healthcare Reform
- Preexisting Conditions Common in United States
- Obama's Plan Would Cost Another $20 Billion
- Sensible Budget Must Include Investment in Our Future
- Freedom From Our Incessantly Growing Union
- Balance of Power
- The National Empathy Divide
- Obama and the Polls
- Obama Bounces Back
- The Loud Passing of the Old Order
- The Speech: Obama's State of the Union
- Obama Looks Good Halfway Through His Presidency
- Bipartisan Support for Making the Tax Code Simpler
- Obama's 'Freeze' Rehashes Failed 2010 Try
- The Spending Cuts Challenge
- Obama Should Challenge Country to Make a Clean Energy Automobile
- Obama's State of the Unions Less 'Intelligent' Than Bush's
- The Sorry State of Our Economic Union
- Looking Ahead and Back
- Obama Remembers JFK
- Reagan and Kennedy Are Role Models for Obama
- We Were Young For One, Brief Shining Moment
- Reagan Son Claims Dad Had Alzheimer's as President
- The Modern Military-Industrial Complex
- Why Sarah Palin Is Wrong About Michelle Obama's Weight Gain Fight
- After Repeal Vote, Healthcare Reform Fight Goes On
- GOP Attack on Health Care Shows Why Democrats Should Have Pushed Medicare for All
- Republicans Play Games with Health Care
- Giffords Shooting in Arizona Spurs Gun Law Debate
- Violent Rhetoric Can Lead to Tragedies Like Arizona Shooting
- Political Tone Had No Role in Arizona Shootings
- 10 States With the Largest Budget Shortfalls
- Contrasts in Black and Red
- The Bloomberg Syndrome
- The Enemies of Our Enemies are Our Friends
- Spiritual Death
- For (and Against) the Filibuster
- Who Needs Democracy?
- On Sargent Shriver
- Why are Republicans Doing This?
- Muslim 'Cosby' Show? Couldn't Hurt
- New Congress to Push Obama on Latin America
- Eisenhower's 'Military-Industrial Complex' and JFK's Inaugural
- Republicans Break Their Promises On Day One
- Speaker Boehner: Will He (Republican) Party Like It's 1995?
- Dysfunctional Duo's undoing
- The Tab Comes Due in 2011
- Incoming Republican Leadership Reeks of Corporate Control
- For the 112th Time: New Congress, Same Challenges
- Obama and Human Rights: Continuity and Change
- Despite Critics, Palin's Buzz Is Positive
- Moment of Silence Needs to Be Followed by More Than Just Lowered Voices
- Tests of a New Political Tone
- At Time of Healing, Sarah Palin Throws Gas on Flames
- The Liberal Empire Strikes Back
- The New Sophists
- Fishing for Democratic Corruption
- The Shameful Attack on Public Employees
- The Stealth Attack on American Education
- Obama Faces the Same Problems in 2011
- GOP's John Boehner Gets House Speaker's Gavel
- Good Teen Pals = Good Politics?
- Boehner, Pelosi, Haley, Ryan and Others to Watch in 2011
- New Era of Bipartisanship in 2011? No Chance
- Congress to Tackle Healthcare and Filibuster Rules
- Democrats Push for Filibuster Rule Change
- Republicans Charge Harry Reid Power Grab on Filibuster
- Lame Duck Session Was Successful For The President's Party
- Constitutionalists vs. 'Interpretationists'
- 2010 Midterm Elections Set Campaign Spending Records
- Biden Hints at Obama Reelection Themes
- Obama's Toughest Year Ahead?
- How Obama Is Failing at the Dramatic Side of the Presidency
- The Founding Fathers: Religion and God
- Ham-and-Egg Justice
- Obama's Hawaii Vacation Is Revealing
- Like Sarah Palin Early Feminists Were Pro-Life
- They're Back! The Return of the Death Panels
- Don't Reignite 'Death Panel' Insanity
- Sarah Palin: She Told Us So
- Why the Rich Are Getting Richer
- A Far From Happy New Year
- The American 21st Century
- Defense Is On The Table
- A Leaner and Meaner Defense
- The Political Power of Social Media
- The Good News About Gas
Available at Amazon.com:
Obama's Budget Falls Short of Deficit Panel Recommendations | Politics
(c) 2011 U.S. News & World Report