Four Roadblocks to Obama's Immigration Reform
Mallie Jane Kim
May 23, 2011
Can President Obama effect change to the broken immigration system?
After releasing his long-form birth certificate and taking care of that pesky terrorist leader Osama bin Laden once and for all, President Obama has now turned his public spotlight to the third issue most people had relegated to the never-going-to-happen category: comprehensive immigration reform. The president's speech in El Paso, Texas touted his administration's gains in border security and deportations while urging Congress to institute reforms that will provide a pathway to citizenship (though not without punishment) for the estimated 11 million immigrants already living in the United States illegally. The White House released a "Blueprint for Building a 21st Century Immigration System" that lays out the president's priorities in moving forward, but the question remains: With 2012 election season quickly approaching, can Obama actually effect change to the broken immigration system? Standing in his way are four major roadblocks:
1. The conventional wisdom that this is just a campaign ploy.
Obama's approval numbers among Hispanics dropped from 73 percent in January 2009 to 54 percent in March 2011, according to Gallup, and some say Obama's new push for reform is simply an attempt to recapture his popularity among this huge and growing portion of voters: If it worked in '08, maybe it'll work in 2012.
If the president is serious, he will have to take what the public perceives as concrete steps toward reform to get past this assumption and actually get anything done. But if it is all bark and no bite, says immigrant advocacy organization National Council of La Raza's Clarissa Martinez-De-Castro, the tactic may backfire. "If it turns out to be another round of politics, voters are going to see right through it."
2. Latino voters don't trust him because he already broke his promise on immigration.
In 2008, Candidate Obama promised to tackle immigration reform within his first year in office. That didn't happen. "Politician Obama let the Latino community down," says Luis Alvarado, managing director of right-leaning Latino Political Consulting. "The Latino community paid attention, and now those supporters he had in 2008 are now detractors and will be detractors in 2012."
But not all Latino voters have given up on the president. "They are disappointed that it hasn't passed," says Andre Pineda, a political consultant to Democrats. But "it's not that they blame him. They blame the Republicans," he says. "They just wish that he could have done more."
Pineda points out that Latinos are not necessarily single-issue voters, and immigration is not necessarily a top-of-mind issue for them. He held focus groups for immigrants and U.S.-born Latino voters in Colorado and Nevada and found that, out of 40 participants, only one mentioned immigration reform as a top issue. The other 39 focused primarily on jobs, housing, and education.
3. Bipartisan politics
Republicans have typically focused on securing the border as the only first step, saying they won't even consider broader reform until that is done. But in his speech, Obama suggested Republicans will never be satisfied, saying his administration had answered GOP demands, but he still suspects they will try to "move the goal posts on us one more time."
Supporters of a pathway to citizenship refer to the economic benefit and jobs that immigrants bring to the nation -- Obama pointed out that Google, Yahoo, Intel, and eBay were each founded by immigrants (though all were in the country legally). Detractors say just the opposite: Illegal immigrants take jobs from middle class Americans. With the nation's unemployment rate still hovering around 9 percent, any suspicion that a policy will cost jobs could derail public support.
Read the latest political news.
- Even Without Donald Trump, Plenty of Clowns in the 2012 GOP Field
- Who Benefits from Huckabee and Trump 2012 Announcements
- Bin Laden Killing Is Obama's Defining Moment
- Herb Kohl Retirement Adds to Democrats 2012 Senate Woes
- Government Hits Debt Ceiling as Parties Squabble
- Boehner's Debt Ceiling Speech Shows Problems of Obamanomics
- Four Roadblocks to Obama's Immigration Reform
- Alligators, Moats and Other Such Nonsense
- Obama Talks Nice About Immigration Reform But What Is He Willing to Do?
- Mitt Romney: Like Father, Like Son
- Why Newt Gingrich Will be the 2012 GOP Nominee for President
- The GOP Field for 2012: Who's on First?
- Republicans Vs. Invisibility
- A Sharper GOP Field for 2012
- GOP Warns Of Back Door Mileage Tax
- Big Oil Tax Break Vote Could Hurt Vulnerable Republicans
- Why Congress Cannot Fix Your Gas Prices Pain
- Why Washington Should Pay Attention to the Economy Here and Now
- On Gas Prices Obama Should Lead or Get Out of the Way
- Putting $4 Gas In Perspective
- 7 Ways the United States Population is Changing
- Dear Class of 2011: Good Luck You're Really Going to Need It
- Big Oil's Money Gusher
- Lawmakers Tell Obama to End Afghanistan War
- Osama bin Laden Is Dead: Does Obama or Bush Deserve the Credit?
- What did Killing Osama bin Laden Actually Accomplish?
- Toning Down the Celebrating
- Why the Hurry to Gloat About Bin Laden?
- Wall Street Lobbyists Trying to Sway Tea Party
- Killed by Tea Party GOP, Second F-35 Engine Revived
- Trotting Out the GOP Candidates
- Bad GOP Timing
- Recall Elections Enhance Democracy
- Recall Elections Waste Public Funds and Cause Chaos
- A Memorial Day to Remember
- Budget Rhetoric of Biblical Proportions
- Rules for Killing Rogues?
- The Unholy Grail
- What a Week for the World
- The Bin Laden Bounce: How Will Obama Use This Moment of Unexpected Unity?
- United States Budget: Money Worries
- The Donald Makes (Almost) Humble Speech
- We've Had Enough of America's Favorite Huckster
- National Debt Debate Reflects How Far Left Democrats Have Moved
- Seniors Key Voters in 2012 Presidential Election
- Enough Drama Already: The Country's Getting Sick of It
- More Taxes on Big Oil?
- A Thorny Porny Issue for New York Public Library
- Orwell's Vision Becomes Reality
- Balanced Budget Amendment Needed to Fix National Debt Crisis
- A Balanced Budget Amendment Would Be a Dangerous Distraction
- By Accepting Conventional Wisdom on Deficit Obama Is Ignoring Lessons of 2008
- GOP Posturing on Debt Ceiling Could Lead to Economic Disaster
- He's Serious, All Right, But Not About the Deficit
- The Unhappy President
- Obama Still Strong Heading Into 2012 Election
- Donald Trump: Most Buzzed About GOP Candidate
- Pandering to the Obamaphobes
- Haley Barbour Says No
- GOP Reality Primary Could Be a Win-Win
- New GOP Agenda: Balance Budget and Expand Jobs
- Religion and Party Affiliation Go Hand in Hand
- Are Sky-High Gas Prices Good?
- Down the Tea Party Rabbit Hole in Florida
- Medicare Love Chills Tea Party Fever
- Cooling on Global Warming
- Year Later, Little in Gulf Has Changed
- Beware the Middle Ground of the Great Budget Debate
- Recalibrating Homeland Security
- Power and Politics in an Autonomous Latin America
- Make the Rich Pay!
- 2011 Budget Battle Only the First of Many to Come
- Barack Obama's 'Memento' Presidency
- Trump - Newsmax Conspiracy Is Real
- Michele Bachmann: Don't Misunderestimate This Firebrand From Minnesota
- Duck, It's The Donald!
- A Debate Worthy of a Great Nation in Trouble
- No Trump
- RNC's Reince Priebus Takes on Obama
- Ryan Budget Plan: Disaster for America
- Obama's Budget Deficit Speech Shows He's Willing to Say Anything
- Turning 50 Under GOP's Proposed Medicare Reform
- Medicare Isn't the Problem, It's the Solution
- Republicans Blindly Attack Social Justice
- Atlas Shrugged: The Movie
- Tax Check Off Program Just an Entitlement for Politicians
- Tax Payer Checkoff Protects Against Corruption
- More Taxpayer Money Spent on Mail During Election Years
- Obama's Approach to Libya Fodder for 2012 Presidential Campaign
- Budget Deal Leaves Both Sides Unhappy
- A Life Lesson
- Obama's Delusion
- Dreamland USA
- Who's In Charge?
- Supreme Court Decision Defies Madison
- It's Time NPR Grew Up and Supported Itself
- Uncertain Trumpet: Eric Holder Sees the Light
- Real Class Warfare
- NAACP and Right-Wing Foes Get Friendly
- Glenn Beck: Too Crazy For Fox -- And That's Crazy!
- Putting the Spotlight on the Sacrifices of Those Left Behind
- Why We Must Raise Taxes on the Rich
- Reaganomics? Meet 'Ryan-omics'
- If General Electric Does Not Pay Taxes, Why Can't We?
- How the GOP Has Already Won the Government Shutdown Fight
- Government Shutdown Deadline Nears After Obama's Budget Meeting
- GOP and Liberals Both Attack Obama on Libya
- The Conservative Case Against the Death Penalty
- Obama in 2012
- Obama's Sideline Strategy
- What Obama Doctrine?
- Enough With Obama's Birth Certificate
- China Sees the Evil of Plastic Bags
- Spreading Wealth the Right Way
- Technology Powers Revolutions and Saves Lives
- Chances for a New US Foreign Policy Not Taken
- GOP Finally Shifts Focus to Jobs
- High Gas Prices Could Hurt Obama in 2012
- Voters Think New Jersey's Chris Christie Can Beat Obama
- Beware Condemning Barack Obama For a Low Bully Pulpit Profile
- Another Obama Detour
- National Service Budget Cuts Could Devastate Nonprofits and Communities
- Where's The Tea Party Love?
- Birther Idiots Show Their True Color
- Why Liberals Love the Birthers
- Another Muslim Country, Another War
- Richard Shelby: This Senator Is Lost in Space
- 3 Reasons the U.S. Economy Remains in a Coma
- The Biggest Lies About Jobs
- Why Higher Unemployment Might Not Be a Bad Thing
- It's BACK! The Return of Stagflation
- President Obama's Most Amazing Libyan Achievements
- Prudent Multilateralism in Libya
- Insanity Dawn
- President Obama's 'New Model' of U.S.-Latin American Ties
- Obama Said He Doesn't Mind Criticism on Libya Mission in Latin America
Available at Amazon.com:
Four Roadblocks to Obama's Immigration Reform | Politics
(c) 2011 U.S. News & World Report