Flat-Tax Fraud and Why America Needs a Truly Progressive Tax
Robert B. Reich
The so-called "flat tax" is all the rage among Republican presidential hopefuls.
The flat tax is a fraud. It raises taxes on the poor and lowers them on the rich.
The nonpartisan Tax Policy Center estimates that Cain's flat-tax plan (the only one that's been set out in any detail) would lower the after-tax incomes of poor households (incomes below
Meanwhile, 95 percent of households with more than
All flat-tax proposals benefit the rich more than the poor for one simple reason: Today's tax code is still at least moderately progressive. The rich usually pay a higher percent of their incomes in income taxes than do the poor. A flat tax would eliminate that slight progressivity.
Nowadays most low-income households pay no federal income tax at all -- a fact that sends many regressives into spasms of indignation. They conveniently ignore the fact that poor households pay a much larger share of their incomes in payroll taxes, sales taxes and property taxes (directly, if they own their homes; indirectly, if they rent) than do people with high incomes.
Flat-taxers pretend a flat tax is good public policy, for two reasons.
First, they say, it would simplify paying taxes. Baloney. Flat-tax proposals don't eliminate all deductions. People with families will still be able to deduct their dependents while single people will pay a higher rate, businesses will deduct their expenses, and, in most plans, people with homes will still be able to deduct interest on their mortgages.
That means most taxpayers would still have lots of paperwork.
Second, proponents of a flat tax say it's fairer than the current system because, in Cain's words, a flat tax "treats everyone the same."
The truth is, the current tax code treats everyone the same. It's organized around tax brackets. Everyone whose income reaches the same bracket is treated the same as everyone else whose income reaches that bracket (apart from various deductions, exemptions and credits, of course).
For example, no one pays any income taxes on the first
Republicans have tried to sow confusion about this. They want Americans to believe, for example, that if the Bush tax cut ended, small-business owners with incomes of
Get it? We already have a flat tax -- flat within each bracket.
The real problem is the top brackets are set too low relative to where the money is. The top-most bracket starts at
This means a doctor who's making, say,
Actually, it's worse than that because the plutocrats get most of their income in the form of capital gains, which are taxed at only 15 percent. That's why America's 400 richest people -- who earned an average of
The Republicans' push for a flat tax masks what's really going on.
Remember: The top 1 percent is now raking in over 20 percent of the nation's total income and owns over 35 percent of the nation's wealth. Under almost anyone's view of fairness, these are grotesque portions. They're especially large relative to what they were as recently as 30 years ago, when the top 1 percent raked in under 10 percent -- and paid a top marginal tax rate of more than 70 percent. And these huge portions at the top continue to increase.
Simple fairness requires three things: More tax brackets at the top, higher rates in each of those top brackets, and the treatment of all sources of income (capital gains included) exactly the same.
Not only fairness demands it, but also fiscal prudence. A truly progressive tax would bring in tens of billions of dollars a year from the people at the top who are in the best position to afford it.
Regressives are pushing the flat tax as a smokescreen. They'd rather not have anyone talk about the unfairness and fiscal absurdity of the current system.
Rather than merely oppose the flat tax, sensible people should push for a truly progressive tax -- starting with a top
rate of 70 percent on that portion of anyone's income exceeding
Read the latest political news.
- Rise of the Regressive Right and the Reawakening of America
- 'Buffett Rule' Is Bad Tax Policy
- Without 'Buffett Rule' Middle and Lower Class Will Suffer
- Defending Bloated Military Spending
- Smoking Herman Cain Campaign Ad: Brilliant or Bizarre?
- Rick Perry Relaunches 2012 Campaign
- GOP Tax Proposals: Nothing Is Simple As It Seems
- Rick Perry Ups Ante With Flat Tax Plan
- Tea Party Budget Cuts $9 Trillion
- If Super Committee Fails, Will Anyone Care
- Flat-Tax Fraud and Why America Needs a Truly Progressive Tax
- Endorsements Give Mitt Romney a Winning Edge
- Tea Party Disses Mitt Romney
- Mitt Romney Finally Gets the Front-Runner Treatment
- Obama and Perry Spend Big But Huntsman and Bachmann Spend Fast
- When Cain's Not Able, Will Gingrich Be Next In Line?
- Vote For Obama Because He's Black
- Obama's Border Blues
- Republican Hardball
- Dispatch from Occupy Wall Street
- Occupy Wall Street Looks Forward, Tea Party Backward
- Occupy Wall Street: Railing Against Reality
- Occupy Wall Street and Tea Party Movements More Alike Than Not
- Occupy Wall Street Less Likely to Be Co-Opted
- 'Occupy'-ers Seek Social Awareness, Not Policy Change
- Occupy Wall Street: The Real Tea Party
- Unlike Occupy Wall Street, Tea Party Knows What It's Protesting
- 'Occupy'-ers Seek Dissolution of Democracy, End of Capitalism
- The Abandoned Class
- Occupy Wall Street Becomes Occupy America
- For Occupy Wall Street Protests Simplicity Matters
- Occupy Wall Street: The Student Debt Threat
- Next Move Crucial For Occupy Movement
- 'Occupy'-ers Know Who Truly Threatens America
- Occupy Wall Street Movement Lacks Clear Objectives
- Occupy Wall Street Movement Purposely Has No Single Set Demand
- States Rights at Heart of New 'No Child Left Behind' Debate
- The Broken Contract: Inequality and American Decline
- The Wisdom of Retrenchment: America Must Cut Back to Move Forward
- Mixed Emotions as the United States Leaves Iraq
- Little League Rules for Big League Debates
- Riots and Revolutions in the Digital Age
- Senator Landrieu: Don't Cut Aid to Israel
- Resolution Against the Machine
- Obama and 2012 GOP-ers Need More Urgency on America's Future
- Mitt Romney a Sure Bet for GOP Nomination
- Super-Committee Lobbying Begins in Earnest
- Warren Buffett: A Hero For Our Times
- What I've Learned Occupying Wall Street and DC
- It's Not Just Anti-Wall Streeters That Have Grounds to Protest
- How 'Occupy Wall Street' Started and Spread
- Occupy Wall Street: Is Mad as Hell Enough?
- Occupy Wall Street: Don't Sleep Through the Revolution
- Occupy Wall Street: The Beginning of Something Big ... Maybe
- Occupy Wall Street: Sorting Out the 'Extremists'
- Occupy Wall Street Protestors Return to Nation's Roots
- Wall Street and Its Occupiers: Both State Welfare Junkies
- Tea Party: Stop Comparing 'Occupy Wall Street' To Us
- Obama's Trade Deal Delays Have Cost Jobs
- Why Rick Perry's Texas Success Isn't Translating
- Mormon Expert: Religion Won't Stall Mitt Romney
- Mitt Romney Takes Charge
- Herman Cain 9-9-9 Tax Plan Could Hurt Retirees
- Raising Cain
- On Race and Herman Cain: A Darker Shade of Wail
- Herman Cain: A Slogan in Every Pot!
- Ron Paul $1 Trillion Cut Plan Targets Five Cabinet Departments
- Republicans Looking For Love
- Politics and Religion 2012 Version
- Morality Not Theology
- The GOP -- and Mitt Romney -- Dilemma
- It's the Oligarchy, Stupid!
- Herman Cain's Anti-Race Card
- Mitt Romney and Ron Paul Aim to Soothe Skeptics
- Obama's Lonely Presidency
- Reconsider Dodd-Frank, Piece by Piece
- Dodd-Frank Brings Transparency to Financial Industry
- Dodd-Frank is More Right than Wrong
- Dodd-Frank Is a Counterproductive Mess
- Repealing Dodd-Frank Would Put the Economy in Danger
- 5 Years On: The Secret of Fox News's Success
- Is the Economy Better Off Without Washington?
- US Economic Woes Put China in the Political Crosshairs
- Vanishing Pensions Another Case of Corporate Greed
- Pension-Raiding Epidemic Worthy of Condemnation
- Predator in Chief
- Congress, Administration Discuss Next Steps on Iran
- Iran and The Diminishing Returns of Reasonableness
- Terror Plot's Mystery Link to Iran
- The Conservative Case Against a Border Fence
- GOP Uses Border Fence as Immigration Distraction for 2012
- Learning From Mexico's Coalition Debate
- US Fears Misplaced When it Comes to China
- Sluggish America Can Still Be a World Leader
- Wall Street (Unlike)
- Newspaper Nostalgia
- Time Running Out for Obama To 'Re-Engage' and 'Re-Excite' Voters
- Rick Perry Proposal of American Troops in Mexico Stirs Criticism
- GOP Candidates Look at Narco-Terrorism Risks
- The Real Voter Fraud Scandal
- How to Achieve Transparency for the Supercommittee
- Military Spending Belongs on the Table
- Panetta Outlines Wide Range of Proposals to Cut Billions
- The Moral Question
- 'Flash Mob Politics' From Both Sides Now
- Occupy Wall Street Challenges America
- 'Occupy Wall Street' Tries to Harness Anger on the Left
- Occupy Chicago: Our Overripe Moment
- American Government's Indifference to Popular Protest
- Democracy's New Discontents
- Messiah Complex: The Sequel?
- Mitt Romney Believes in Corporate America
- Why Obama Is Down and Romney Is Up on Wall Street
- Early Primary Jumble Benefits Mitt Romney
- Christie's Right Decision
- Christie Out: Now Who for GOP Fiscal Conservatives?
- Herman Cain's Plan For First 90 Days as President
- All Aboard The Herman Cain Bandwagon
- Vote for Herman? Yes, They Cain!
- Herman Cain Lights Up Internet, Bachmann Goes Dark
- Herman Cain Booming But Many GOPers Still Leery of a Bust
- Why Obama's No Truman and Cain's No Eisenhower
- Sarah Palin Unlikely to Land VP or Cabinet Job Either
- Without Palin Followers Clout Will Dissipate
- Primary Madness Again
- Debate Reactions Are Part of the Republican 'Brand'
- Rick Perry's Rock and What It Says About Us
- Don't Write Rick Perry Off Just Yet
- Rick Perry Needs to Defend His Sensible Approach to Immigration Issue
- Discontented Republicans Search On for Mr. Right
- 'Centrists' Are Abandoning Ship
- Obama's Relevance: American Jobs Act
- Obama's Terrorist Dilemma
- Barack Obama's Divisive Class Warfare
- What Have They Done with Ron Paul?
- Ron Paul to Release $1 Trillion Spending-Cut Plan
- Supreme Court: Regrets? They've Had a Few
- Some Thoughts on a Half-Baked Idea
- White House Confident of Supreme Court Win on Healthcare
- Healthcare Law's Path Through the Supreme Court
- New Democratic Attack for a New Paul Ryan Plan
- Is Obama's National Infrastructure Bank the Answer on Jobs?
- We Are In a Modern-Day Depression
- Why 2012 Will Shake Up Asia and the World
- America's Government Contracting Bonanza Bilks Taxpayers
- The GOP's Lies and 'Monstrous' Lies
- The Only Thing Government Can Do Right: Kill
- Corporate Takeover of the 2012 Presidential Election
- Lamar Alexander's Choice
- Jon Huntsman: Moderate Republican in Immoderate Times
- Sarah Palin Dismisses Presidency As 'A Title'
- Mitt Romney Starting to Grow on Republicans
- Class War Is Bipartisan
- It's Class Warfare, All Right
- Trickle-Down Depression
- A Good Fight
- Postmodern Class Warfare
- Obama Needs to Acknowledge What Needs to Change in Himself
- A Bear of a Problem for Obama
- Newt Gingrich 2012 GOP Campaign Back on Upswing
- On This Let's Take the Tea Party At Its Word
- On Presidential Dreamers
- Will Rick Perry's Extreme Views Make Him Unelectable?
- The Debating Epidemic
- Debate Reactions Are Part of the Republican 'Brand'
- Wanted: A GOP Dating Service
- Media Making GOP Race Romney-Perry Too Early
- President Obama Leaves Too Much to Congress
- How Southern Republicans Aim to Make White Democrats Extinct
- Tyranny of the Typical
- Obama: A Dose of Reality
- How Obama's Deficit-Reduction Plan Could Backfire
- Obama Deficit Plan Could Derail Hopes for Super Committee Success
- Raising Retirement Age: Reflection of Our Evolving Economy
- Public Perception of Media Bias Hits Historic High
Flat-Tax Fraud and Why America Needs a Truly Progressive Tax | Politics
Copyright 2011, Tribune Media Services, Inc.