Gingrich Brings Common Sense to Immigration Debate
Finally, there is a voice of reason on immigration among the front-runners for the Republican nomination, who until recently seemed to be competing with one another to see who could take the craziest stand against Hispanic immigrants.
Gingrich said that ultimately,
"If you've been here 25 years and you got three kids and two grandkids, you've been paying taxes and obeying the law, you belong to a local church, I don't think we're going to separate you from your family, uproot you forcefully and kick you out," Gingrich said.
For people who have been in this country for 25 years, Gingrich offered a "red card" program that would allow them to stay in this country, but not to get citizenship. Others who arrived more recently would be deported, he said.
In addition, Gingrich said, foreigners with graduate degrees in much-needed disciplines would get automatic residency. "I think that we ought to have an H-1 visa that goes with every graduate degree in math, science and engineering so that people stay here," he said.
Predictably, other Republican hopefuls, trying to position themselves to the right of Gingrich, demanded an all out deportation of all undocumented immigrants.
Asked by debate moderator
"Look, amnesty is a magnet," Romney said. "What when we have had in the past, programs that have said that if people who come here illegally are going to get to stay illegally for the rest of their life, that's going to only encourage more people to come here illegally."
Romney said that "we've got to stop illegal immigration. That means turning off the magnets of amnesty, in-state tuition for illegal aliens, employers that knowingly hire people that have come here illegally."
He added, "We welcome legal immigration. This is a party, this is a party that loves legal immigration. But we have to stop illegal immigration for all the reasons the questioner raised, which is, it is bringing in people who in some cases can be terrorists, in other cases they become burdens on our society."
Offered a chance for rebuttal, Gingrich said, "I don't see how the party that says it's the party of the family is going to adopt an immigration policy which destroys families that have been here a quarter century."
My opinion: Much of the immigration debate has been dominated by Hispanic-allergic anti-immigration zealots on
They rarely mention the fact that the number of undocumented migrants has been declining steadily since the 2008 U.S. economic crisis. Or that the Obama administration -- which supports a much more reasonable immigration reform that would include a path to citizenship to long-time lawful immigrants -- has deported a record of nearly 400,000 people this year.
Romney's argument that he is for "legal immigration" is misleading: There is currently virtually no path to "legal immigration."
A recent study by the
What's needed is updating immigration laws to make them economically advantageous and socially practical. Gingrich's proposal, while limited in scope, at least brings some rationality to the debate among Republican hopefuls.
Read the latest political news.
- Public Blames Congress, Not Obama, For Sour Economy
- Congress is Paralyzed Until More Americans Speak Up
- The Hijacking of the First Amendment
- George McGovern: Barack Obama, Democrats Need a Backbone
- Is Public Financing for Elections Finished?
- Backers Say Newt Gingrich Will Energize Base
- Newt Gingrich: The New Mr. Nice Guy
- Gingrich Might Want to Take a Bath Himself
- Mitt Romney: An Attack on the Truth
- Mitt Romney: The Castor-Oil Candidate
- Supporters Say Romney Should Focus on Obama and Ignore his Rivals
- Romney's Mormon Faith Likely a Minor Issue in General Election
- The Price of GOP Orthodoxy
- Newt Gingrich - Compassionate Conservatism: The Sequel?
- Newt's Bleeding Heart
- Gingrich Brings Common Sense to Immigration Debate
- Newt Gingrich Right to Bring Morals to Immigration Debate
- Newt Gingrich Plan Would Mean More Illegal Immigrants
- On Immigration, Newt Gingrich Has Right Questions, Wrong Answers
- Why Losing Presidential Candidates Stick it Out
- Michele Bachmann Comes Up Empty With Congressional Endorsements
- GOP Debate Mania
- Democrats: Courting Joe the Puppeteer
- 'The Spike' -- 80 years later
- Most Americans See Through Humbug About Taxes and Spending
- Blow Taps for the Tea Party
- The Decline and Fade of the Tea Party
- Tea Party Icon Allen West Discounts Pew Poll on Movement's Popularity
- Republicans Put Loyalty to Norquist Over Country
- Democrats Retiring May Portend Gloom in 2012 Congressional Elections
- A 'Followership' Crisis
- Pentagon Warns of Smallest Force Since WWII
- Catering to the Frozen Pizza Lobby
- What Happens If We End the Fed?
- Herman Cain Drops Out of the Race for Presidency
- Global Corruption: Party Systems and the Control of Politicians
- A Main Street Jobs Agenda
- Restore the Basic Bargain
- Online Shopping Deals Hurt State Budgets
- GOP 2012 Candidates Split on Payroll Tax Cut
- We Need to Focus on the 99 Percent
- A More Permanent Solution Is Needed
- Keynesian Policies Have Failed
- Many Time-limited Tax Breaks Never Die
- A Strong Recovery Remains Elusive
- An Economic Loser in the Long Run
- Extending Payroll Tax Cut Will Extend U.S. Debt
- White House Reiterates Urgency to Renew Payroll Tax Cut Bill
- So the 'Super Committee' Failed. How Will That Affect You?
- Supercommittee Failure Brings Little Hope for Congress' Popularity
- Deficit Is Greatest Security Threat
- Cutting Back on Defense Spending Will Make the World Safer
- It Is Time for Discipline, Defense
- Defense Spending Not to Blame for Deficit
- Military Already Underfunded Thanks to Obama
- Cutting Defense Spending Is Short-sighted
- Reasonable Ways to Cut Defense Budget
- Cutting Military Spending Does Not Mean Cutting Defense
- Cuts to Defense Budget Might Be Inevitable But Pentagon Knows Best
- Charlie Cook Sees GOP Winning Big in 2012
- Norquist's Influence: Anti-Tax Pledge Strengthened by Campaign Spending
- Will Occupy Wall Street Survive Eviction?
- Misrepresenting Occupy Wall Street
- Occupy Your Bank
- Big Banks are Doing Just Fine, Thank You
- The Class War is So Over
- Top Democratic Governor Accuses Republicans of Neglecting Economy
- GOP Presidential Race Poised for Mud-Slinging
- Why the GOP (and Democrats) Should Be Thankful for Mitt Romney
- To Win, Newt Gingrich Needs Cash and Discipline
- 'Likeability' Unlikely to Derail Gingrich in GOP Primary
- Ron Paul: Federal Reserve is Like Drug Addiction
- Tea Party: Buyer's Remorse
- A Call for an Enlightened Foreign Policy toward Latin America
- Is the National Security Complex Too Big to Fail?
- Alabama Law Against Illegal Immigration Suffers Setback
- A Fair Tax That Really Is One
- On Harnessing the Rage
- Without Park to Sleep In Occupiers Should Change Strategies
- End of Park Occupation Raises Questions About Future
- Blame It on Brokaw
- An Idea Dysfunctional Washington More Than Happy to Let Die
- Dear Average American: It's All Your Fault
- Obama Unbound
- Romney More Savvy at Profiting Off of Layoffs and Bankruptcies
- The Corporate Pledge of Allegiance
- Wanted: Adult for President
- Newt Gingrich: The GOP's Leadership Bankruptcy
- Newt Gingrich Enjoys His 15 Minutes at the Top
- Why Newt Gingrich is Back -- for Now
- In Debates, Newt Gingrich's Real Target Is Obama
- Mitt Romney's Latest Pitch
- Herman Cain: Clearing the Knowledge Bar
- Rick Perry: The Politics of Self-Destruction
- The Coming Collision
- Rookie GOP Candidates Lead to Campaign Blunders
- GOP Debates More Entertaining than GOP Policies
- Mitt Romney Goes After Federal Employees in Fiscal Plan
- On the 'Super Committee' Menu: Social Security Cuts and Tax Hikes
- 'Super Committee' Looking Stalled
- Grim Warnings for the Deficit 'Super Committee'
Foreign Influence Inappropriate for
Lawmakers Tasked with Shrinking Deficit
- One Nation, Gone Awry
- Tax Wall Street to Heal America
- United States in Decline -- If We Allow It
Statue of Liberty Turns 125
Old Immigration Attitudes Alive as Well
- GOP's Empty Rhetoric on Obama's Immigration Record
- The Jobs Crisis is Over!
- President Obama: We Can't Wait
- John Paulson's Plaintive Plea
- Why Occupy Wall Street Needs a Republican President
Turning Point for Occupy Wall Street:
Does It Have a Political Strategy?
- Who Are These Fat-Cat Few at the Top?
- The Great Local News Heist
- Scandal in Presidential Politics
- Herman Cain Bungles Scandal Management 101
- 'Our' Blacks vs. 'Their' Blacks
- Herman Cain: Sexual Harassment Has Nothing to Do with Race
- Herman Cain's Gauntlet
- Herman Cain: Herman Agonistes
- Herman Cain's Scandal Pain
- Raising Cain
- Herman Cain: Blaming the Opposition
- Tim Pawlenty's Lost Chance
- Cutting Taxes for the Rich Never Ends Well
- Equal Taxation for Wealth and Work
- Not All Taxes Have to Hurt
- Secret of the Flat Tax
- Current Tax Code Is Confusing
- Flat Tax Would Eliminate 'Crony Capitalism'
- Flat Tax Would Introduce New Problems
- Flat Tax Unites Americans
- Flat Tax Unleashes Economic Growth
- Flat Tax Shifts Burden to the Middle Class
- Flat Tax Will Benefit Only the Rich
- Wall Street Is Back to Its Old Tricks
- The World Is Finally Fighting Off the Infection of Neoliberalism
- America Now More Pro-Civil Service Than Russia
Gingrich Brings Common Sense to Immigration Debate | Politics
Copyright 2011, Tribune Media Services