2012 GOP Candidates: Fumbling Foreign Policy
From Mitt Romney's juvenile $10,000 bet with Rick Perry to Ron Paul's declaration that death by untreated illnesses is "what freedom is all about," the Republican presidential candidates haven't missed an opportunity to sound off-base and out-of-touch with ordinary Americans.
But during a December debate in Des Moines, an exchange between Mitt Romney and Newt Gingrich brought the campaign to an entirely more surreal level. When Romney criticized Gingrich for his intemperate characterization of Palestinians as an "invented people," the two men didn't bother to debate the remark's substance. Instead, they argued over which of them was better friends with Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu. Then, they debated which of them would be of more use to their buddy "Bibi."
Gingrich's remark was ludicrous. Palestinians are no more or less invented than Israelis -- or, for that matter, Americans. But Romney didn't say that. He only objected to Gingrich's willingness to hurl a foreign-policy firebomb without first consulting Netanyahu. "Before I made a statement of that nature," Romney said, "I'd get on the phone to my friend Bibi Netanyahu and say, 'Would it help if I say this? What would you like me to do?'"
Tactfulness and consultation are, of course, admirable habits. But it's bizarre that Romney, an unabashed "American exceptionalist," would plan on letting a foreign official put words in his mouth about such a crucial part of the world. Romney -- who has so often accused President Barack Obama of "apologizing" for America -- has also scolded Obama for "chastening" Israel, promising to visit the country before any other should he be elected. Don't call it apologizing, though.
Sure, Israel is a U.S. ally. But what if Obama called another ally -- say, French President Nicolas Sarkozy or King Abdullah of Saudi Arabia -- and asked, "What would you like me to do?" You can be sure Romney would treat that like treason.
Gingrich comes off equally obsequious and un-presidential. In addition to his incendiary comments about Palestinians, he has strongly suggested that he would support an Israeli request for a U.S. invasion of Iran, evoking in the process the questionable claim that Iran intends to attack Israel with a nuclear weapon (which it still does not possess). However one feels about Iran, Gingrich's willingness to outsource U.S. military policy to Tel Aviv is even more mind-boggling than Romney's deference on diplomacy.
The underlying GOP argument, tailored to the whims of right-wing evangelical voters, is that Obama has been insufficiently supportive of Israel. But this is absurd. Not only has his administration maintained U.S. military aid to Israel to the tune of $3 billion per year, it has also spent considerable diplomatic capital to quash popular UN resolutions recognizing a Palestinian state and condemning Israel's illegal settlement policy in the West Bank -- favors to Israel that fly in the face of longstanding U.S. policy.
Israeli Defense Minister Ehud Barak has even said that he "can hardly remember a better period" of U.S. support for Israel.
The GOP's criticisms are mistaken at best. At worst they send a coded message to certain voters that Obama -- whether because of his race, his name, or his father's religion -- is somehow incapable of supporting Israel.
A better critique of Obama's Israel policy is that it has enabled Israel's right-wing government to prolong the statelessness of Palestinians at the expense not only of international law, but perhaps even of Israel's democracy. It bolsters the view that the United States cares little for Arab or Muslim lives, and it furthers the spread of anti-Semitism. No true friend of either Israel or Palestine should support it.
But maybe Gingrich and Romney are only interested in being friends with Bibi.
Read the latest political news.
- Iowa Caucuses: Romney and Santorum in Virtual Tie
- 2012 GOP Candidates: Fumbling Foreign Policy
- Top 10 Quotes of 2011
- The Top 9 Political Events of 2011
- Defining Issue Isn't Government's Size, But Who It's For
- The Rebirth of Social Darwinism
- Our Challenge for 2012: Get Americans Working
- 2011: An Ode to a Very Bad Year
- 2011: The Year The Power Went Off in Washington
- Newt's Up in South Carolina, But Can He Hold On?
- Obama, Teddy Roosevelt and the Not-So-Fierce Urgency of Maybe Next Term
- The Republican Crack-Up
- John Boehner Destroys Republican Record on Taxes
- Disenfranchising Voters is Un-American
- 'Swing' Voters, Still Partisan
- $1 Trillion in Defense Cuts? Big Deal
- Mexico's Drug Cartels are no 'Terrorist Insurgency'
- Public Blames Congress, Not Obama, For Sour Economy
- Congress is Paralyzed Until More Americans Speak Up
- The Hijacking of the First Amendment
- George McGovern: Barack Obama, Democrats Need a Backbone
- Is Public Financing for Elections Finished?
- Backers Say Newt Gingrich Will Energize Base
- Newt Gingrich: The New Mr. Nice Guy
- Gingrich Might Want to Take a Bath Himself
- Mitt Romney: An Attack on the Truth
- Mitt Romney: The Castor-Oil Candidate
- Supporters Say Romney Should Focus on Obama and Ignore his Rivals
- Romney's Mormon Faith Likely a Minor Issue in General Election
- The Price of GOP Orthodoxy
- Newt Gingrich - Compassionate Conservatism: The Sequel?
- Newt's Bleeding Heart
- Gingrich Brings Common Sense to Immigration Debate
- Newt Gingrich Right to Bring Morals to Immigration Debate
- Newt Gingrich Plan Would Mean More Illegal Immigrants
- On Immigration, Newt Gingrich Has Right Questions, Wrong Answers
- Why Losing Presidential Candidates Stick it Out
- Michele Bachmann Comes Up Empty With Congressional Endorsements
- GOP Debate Mania
- Democrats: Courting Joe the Puppeteer
- 'The Spike' -- 80 years later
- Most Americans See Through Humbug About Taxes and Spending
- Blow Taps for the Tea Party
- The Decline and Fade of the Tea Party
- Tea Party Icon Allen West Discounts Pew Poll on Movement's Popularity
- Republicans Put Loyalty to Norquist Over Country
- Democrats Retiring May Portend Gloom in 2012 Congressional Elections
- A 'Followership' Crisis
- Pentagon Warns of Smallest Force Since WWII
- Catering to the Frozen Pizza Lobby
- What Happens If We End the Fed?
- Herman Cain Drops Out of the Race for Presidency
- Global Corruption: Party Systems and the Control of Politicians
- A Main Street Jobs Agenda
- Restore the Basic Bargain
- Online Shopping Deals Hurt State Budgets
- GOP 2012 Candidates Split on Payroll Tax Cut
- We Need to Focus on the 99 Percent
- A More Permanent Solution Is Needed
- Keynesian Policies Have Failed
- Many Time-limited Tax Breaks Never Die
- A Strong Recovery Remains Elusive
- An Economic Loser in the Long Run
- Extending Payroll Tax Cut Will Extend U.S. Debt
- White House Reiterates Urgency to Renew Payroll Tax Cut Bill
2012 GOP Candidates: Fumbling Foreign Policy | Politics - 2012 GOP Candidates
- Provided by Foreign Policy In Focus