Turning a Blind Eye to Government Benefits
Why do Americans so often vote against their own economic interests? Because money isn't everything. Values matter, too, especially when your values tell you that cuts in government spending won't bring new pain to hard workers like you.
That's my simplest answer to that often-perplexing question. Here's a longer one:
The question has taken on new urgency as two big issues drive the politics of this election year: income inequality and growing government debt. White working-class voters form the
The latest surprises to confirm this stereotype-defying trend come in a
Hypocrisy? No, let's be charitable. Many recipients of government benefits have, shall we say, an elastic idea of what constitutes a "government benefit."
I was informed of this in a gigabyte of emails that I received last summer after writing about a study by
Irritated readers responded with personal arguments that basically went like this:
"How dare you refer to (
Believe me, I get it. The dispute here is between what I mean when I say "benefit" and what some people hear. In the years since
But, sorry, folks, if you think of your
In that values vein, I had a recent email exchange with
Contrary to common beliefs, the new yuppie-era upper class that Murray labels "Belmont" is adhering to old-school traditional values as measured by such statistical standards as marriage, parenting, work habits and church attendance rates -- while those measures show the new, lesser-educated worker class that he calls "Fishtown" is sliding into a new underclass of long-term unemployment, fatherless children and dependency.
My criticism: Murray's analysis, while important, puts too much of the blame on culture and too little on the seismic structural changes in our economy since the 1960s. The low-skill, high wage jobs that supported American family life in earlier decades largely have been lost to cheaper labor markets overseas.
But, given Murray's view that blue-collar whites are drifting away from the values of upper-class elites, I asked whether he had any thoughts as to why blue-collars whites continue to vote conservative, according to exit polls.
"You've still got a big proportion of Fishtown that's getting married, working hard, etc.," he wrote back. "They're the ones who are most likely to vote (overall voting among the working class is quite low), and also the ones who rationally can vote for conservative candidates. So it's not surprising that the polling results from Fishtown still tend to go Republican."
In other words, the most important values in an election, regardless of income or education, are the ones that motivate you to get off the couch and vote.
Read the latest political news.
- Stock Market Picks 90 Percent of Presidential Elections
- Twitter Mentality a Threat to America
- God and Caesar in America
- The God Gap
- When the Senate Worked
- The Congressional Thaw
- Failed Highway Bill Shows Just How Fanatical GOP Has Become
- Starving Public Universities Shrinks the Middle Class
- The GOP's Worst Week
- Why Marco Rubio Can't Save the GOP
- Third-Party Group Wants Internet to Pick Presidential Candidate
- Buddy Roemer to Seek Third-Party Presidential Nomination
- Debt, Baby, Debt: America's Newest Voting Bloc
- GOP Candidates Could All Add to Federal Deficit
- Who is the True GOP Conservative?
- Rick Santorum: The GOP's Unelectable Soul Mate
- Getting to Know Them
- No Republican Middle
- Note to GOP Field: Braggadocio Is Not Leadership
- Rick Santorum Repulses Independent and Moderate Voters
- What Rick Santorum Has Been Saying, And 'Not Saying'
- Only Santorum Addresses Values Issues that Concern Voters
- Rick Santorum Appeals to Only a Minority of Voters
- Mitt Romney Is More Electable, But Needs to Clean Up Campaign
- Both Mitt Romney and Rick Santorum Disappoint Conservatives
- Mitt Romney Can't Be Trusted So Rick Santorum Is More Electable
- Romney's Arizona Law 'Model' Would Hurt All Immigrants
- The Manufacturing Myth
- GOP Candidates Revive Bush Pre-emption Doctrine
- The Tricky Politics of the Auto Bailout
- Protesting Today's Threat to Voting Rights
- Turning a Blind Eye to Government Benefits
- Obama Fights Back on GOP Gas-Price Attacks
- How Sex Hijacked Election Talk
- Rick Santorum's Reverse Snobbery
- Mr. Right Eludes the GOP
- Latino Voters to Candidates: What Are We, Chopped Chorizo?
- Lack of Enthusiasm Isn't Just a GOP Problem
- A Brokered GOP Convention?
- Obama's Cynicism for Me, Not for Thee
- Brash Limbaugh
- The Supreme Court: Politicizing Justice
- Muddying the Playing Field
- National Deficit Result of Wars and Bush Tax Cuts
- Five Ways to Spin Obama Tax Plan
- Social Issues Bring in Popular Vote for Republicans
- Republicans Can Win on Economic Issues, Not a Culture War
- Social Issues Are at the Core of Our Problems
- Republicans Should Focus on the Economy
- GOP Needs to Rethink Positions on Economy, Foreign Policy
- Republican Mean Streak Could Leave GOP Out in the Cold
- Extra Dollars You're Paying At Pump Going To Wall Street Speculators
- A Farewell to Fossil Fuels
- United States Can't Control the World Oil Market
- The Future of U.S. - Chinese Relations
- If American Manufacturers Keep Jobs, So Does Obama
- GOP Will Lose in 2012 if Social Issues Take Center Stage
- Why Looks Are Everything in a Presidential Election
- Swing Voters Need a Champion
- Good Businessmen Rarely Make Good Presidents
- Un-Presidential Primaries
- Inside Rick Santorum's Head
- Improving Economy Driving Independents Back to Obama
Turning a Blind Eye to Government Benefits | Politics
Copyright © 2012 Tribune Media Services