Obama and Romney Struggling With Working Class Voters
Experts say general election will swing on blue-collar voters
In order to win the presidential election in November, both Republican front-runner Mitt Romney and President Obama must answer the same question: How do they connect with working class voters? Much has been made of the importance of wooing independent women voters this fall, manifesting itself in campaign sniping about which side better represents their interests. But such a demographic is not separate from the working class, which likely will sway results in key states such as Pennsylvania and Ohio.
To be successful, each candidate will need to buck their perception among blue-collar voters -- Romney seemingly aloof, Obama coming off as a liberal elite -- by crafting a winning argument aimed at the "everyman" audience.
"For Romney to win, he's got to get Midwestern, blue-collar voters because they form a swing bloc," says David Woodard, political science professor at Clemson University and a former GOP consultant. "I don't think that they are really in Obama's camp - it's like they're able to be courted, but you have to court them. You can't just ignore them and hope that they come in."
Woodard says the Republican primary was riddled with Romney remarks that put a distance between him and the working man.
"I have some great friends that are NASCAR team owners," Romney has previously said after commenting he doesn't closely follow the sport. Soundbites like that, paired with an economic philosophy that promotes letting the home foreclose process "run its course" and "hit the bottom" along with allowing Detroit automakers to "go bankrupt" have left the former Massachusetts governor, whose self-worth tops $200 million, a bit vulnerable.
Romney also trailed Obama in a recent Washington Post/ABC News poll that asked voters who better understands the economic problems people are having -- 49 percent picked Obama compared to 37 percent who selected Romney.
"It's clear that, one-on-one, [Romney's] not going to be able to relate to them," Woodard says. "Even when he takes off his coat and he's in his shirt, he looks too pristine compared to what the working class guys wear."
However, Woodard says all is not lost for Romney.
"Sure Romney's a rich guy, but we like rich guys - they make jobs," he says.
Romney's burden is not to convince CEOs or "the head of the company" to vote for him, but to convince the guys who are the "guts of the company" that what he does as president will really help them, Woodard says.
Gerald Shuster, communications professor at the University of Pittsburgh, believes Obama holds the edge right now with the working class, but has some advice for Romney.
"He doesn't have to be sympathetic, but learn how to be empathetic," he says. "Like, I may be wealthy but that doesn't mean I don't understand why you feel the way you feel. And that's the difference."
It's a tactic that's worked for successful presidents like John F. Kennedy, Ronald Reagan and even George W. Bush.
But Obama is not without his own challenges winning over the working class, a demographic he's had trouble with since his lengthy 2008 Democratic primary against Hillary Clinton, who clobbered him among those voters.
"Anybody gone into Whole Foods lately and see what they charge for arugula?" he had asked primary voters in Iowa, a state that did not even have a Whole Foods market at the time.
Shuster says since becoming president, Obama's difficulty no longer lies with his ability to relate with working class voter, but making them believe his policies aren't to blame for high gas prices and a sluggish economy.
"The average working person -- the bottom of the middle class -- are saying, I am voting this time, and this time they better mean what they say," says Shuster.
Economic arguments aside, for independent voters who haven't made up their mind, it might just come down to likeability. So far, that's a battle Obama is winning.
According to the Washington Post/ABC News survey, 64 percent of respondents said Obama was more friendly or likeable compared to 37 percent of voters who chose Romney.
Read the latest political news.
- How Everyone Else Pays for Big Business's Tax Breaks
- No Easy Solutions for Big Money in Politics
- GOP: That Great Enemy of Reason
- GOP's Presidential Plans in Peril if Economy Keeps Improving
- Mitt Romney's Woman Woes
- Can Republicans Regain Women Voters?
- Independent Ladies Pick Obama
- Republicans Can Close the 'Gender Gap' With the Economy
- Free The Markets, Mitt Romney
- Obama and Romney Struggling With Working Class Voters
- Mitt Romney Turns Attention to Contrasts With President Obama
- The Mitt Romney Veepstakes Begin
- Tool Or Hero: What Role Will Marco Rubio Play?
- Paul Ryan: Chairman of the Con Man Committee
- Paul Ryan's Medicare Hot Air
- Grand Old Pedagogy
- For Government: No Limits
- Parties Begin Staking Out Ground For a Budget Deal
- Rich Freeloaders
- Obama Will Not Stand Up for His Party's Politics
- How the Rich Welch on Retirement Taxes
- Invoking Fake Job Creators to Cut Taxes on the Rich
- Down and Out on Wall Street
- Enemies of the People
- The 99 Percent Spring
- The Most Lopsided Economic Recovery On Record
- Massachusetts Health Care Reform from the Front Lines
- Health Care Jujitsu
- Freedom or Fairness in 2012?
- Obama Energy Policy: Very Few of the Above
- Faith-Based Energy Policy
- Obama Unleashed
- Five Economic Mistakes Obama is Making
- Better Public Schools Require a Stronger Safety Net
- Catching up to the Local Food Revolution
- Taxation without Representation
- Partisanship Bickering Hangs Over Immigration Hearing
- Women Agree With the GOP on Birth Control
- Has Obama Gone Too Far in His Rhetoric About the Supreme Court?
- The Second Oil Revolution
- An America in Decline
- Romney's Russia Remarks and the Dangers of Dumbed Down
- Volatile Times, Uncertain Futures
- The Crisis in Public Morality
- Where's The Hope?
- Rising Economic Tide Lifts Obama's Fortunes
- Politics: A Never-Ending Game of 'Hot Potato'
- Why Older Citizens are More Likely to Vote
- Ryan's Budget Plan Could Cause Problems Within Both Parties
- Re-election Could Put Obama in Top 4 All-Time
Obama and Romney Struggling With Working Class Voters | Politics
Copyright © 2012 Tribune Media Services