Mitt Romney Missed Big Chance with Latino Voters
Republican presidential candidate
Granted, Romney came across as much more confident and seemingly gentler to Hispanics than during the primaries, when - in his effort to outflank his conservative anti-immigration rivals from the right - he often sounded as a Latino basher. If you had not been following the immigration debate closely, you may have thought that Romney was offering Latinos a big carrot Wednesday when he called for a "permanent solution" on immigration.
But if you listen carefully to what he said - and more important, what he omitted - at the forum, it's hard not to conclude that Romney wasted his biggest chance so far to separate himself from the hard-line Republican extremists whose anti-immigration policies many Latinos fear would create a hostile climate against all Hispanics in this country.
Let's look at the facts: during the primaries, Romney said that
On Wednesday - despite his glamorous smile, his repeated vows to find a "permanent solution" to the immigration problem, and cheers from an adoring crowd of mostly Cuban-American Republicans - Romney did not walk away from any of those positions.
In addition, instead of talking about "undocumented immigrants" or "illegal immigrants," he used the term "illegal aliens," a dehumanizing label that obscures the fact that many undocumented workers entered the country through the back door because of an outdated visa system that doesn't allow them to get in through the front door.
Asked about his support for the
On the DREAM Act, Romney softened his previous all-out opposition by praising
Time and again, Romney responded with a promise to find a "permanent solution" to the immigration problem.
Problem is, he didn't offer specifics, which amounts to offering a non-solution. And his "permanent solution" non-proposal omitted the word "comprehensive," as in "comprehensive immigration reform," which is the way Democrats and moderate Republicans refer to an immigration bill that would simultaneously address border security, visa quotas and a path to legalization for undocumented immigrants who meet certain standards.
On his proposal for "self-deportation" of undocumented immigrants, Romney downplayed the deportation side of the equation, but in effect did not change his previous stand that undocumented immigrants - even those who have been here for decades - should go home before they are allowed to apply for visas.
"A lot of people expected him to walk away from those far-right policies after the primaries, but he did not," says
My opinion: Romney, who according to a new Fox News Latino poll trails Obama by 60 percent to 30 percent among Latino voters, could have done himself a great favor if he had explicitly disassociated himself from anti-immigration extremists in his own party.
He could have said that, after extensive talks with Rubio, former
He didn't do that, probably for fears of being seen as a chronic flip-flopper. Perhaps he will still do it in the presidential debates, but he had the best opportunity he will probably get to do it in front of a nationwide Latino audience, and he didn't use it.
Read the latest political news.
- A Memo to Mitt and Ann Romney
- Mitt Romney's Biggest Problem is His Own Party
- Mitt Romney Can Win By Doing One Thing
- Mitt Romney on the Spot
- Presidential Debates Present Opportunity and Peril for Mitt Romney
- The Presidential Debate: Look for the Plans, Not the Puns
- His Campaign Sliding, Mitt Romney Must Deliver in Debate
- The 'Self-Made' Hallucination of America's Rich
- Why Mitt Romney and Paul Ryan are Going Down
- Four Reasons Why Mitt Romney Might Still Win
- America Needs Good Refs -- On the Gridiron and in Politics
- How the GOP Protects Its Falsehoods
- 2012 Election Could Mirror 1980 Race
- A GOP Civil War Simmers
- Mitt Romney Missed Big Chance with Latino Voters
- Mitt Romney's Losing Bid to Win the Latino Vote
- Does Political Discourse Need Geneva Conventions?
- Another Episode in Mitt Romney's Foreign Policy Follies
- Team Romney Doubles Down
- In Defense of the 47 Percent
- The High Cost of Mitt Romney's Candor
- It was a privilege, Mitt Romney
- The Obama Hare and Romney the Tortoise
- An American Shame that Both Candidates Ignore
- Revisiting Wilson's 'Truly Disadvantaged'
- The Poor: America's Forgotten Swing Voters
- Pragmatic Racism
- Mitt Romney's Taxes: Who Cares?
- Waffling on Obamacare will Not Help Mitt Romney
- Why They Call Bill Clinton 'Big Dog'
- Bill Clinton's Secret: Make Little Words Matter
- Bill Clinton Delivers
- Forward to What, Democrats?
- The New Obama Shows Muscle
- Words of Wisdom from a Nun
- Likable Mitt Romney
- Mitt Romney Misjudges Voters
- Mitt Romney's Troubling Pattern
- Mitt Romney's Party -- Checks OK, iPhones Not
- Distractions and Diversions
- The Self-Immolation of Mitt Romney
- The Latest Battle in the War on Voting
- Better Off Today? Don't Ask
- What has Obama Learned?
- Obama Sells Old Ideas as New
- Let George W Bush Be
- Do We Want This Foolish Man?
- Poor Visibility
- Paul Ryan Runs Into the Truth
- Team Romney's War Against Facts
- Both Parties Go to Extremes
- Candidates Have De-Emphasized Foreign Affairs
- Campaign 2012 in a Nutshell: Wrong Ideas vs No Ideas
- Memo to GOP: Demography is Destiny
- Tribe of Liberty
- The Price of Freedom
- Paul Ryan Calling the Kettle Black with Medicare Scare Tactics
- House of Representatives Armed with Irony
- Obama Leads Romney in Post-Conventions Poll
- Character, Policy and the Selection of Leaders
- The Politicization of Violence
- The Selling of American Democracy: The Perfect Storm
- Losing Latino Votes
- The Party is Over: Longtime GOPer Dissects Modern Political Landscape
- Paul Ryan's Faux Populism
- Rise Up, Middle Class, Rise Up!
- A Modest Proposal: Three Weeks of Paid Vacation
- The Paul Ryan Choice
Mitt Romney Missed Big Chance with Latino Voters | Politics
(c) 2012 Tribune Media Services, Inc