Positive Reinforcement Beats Force in Training Dogs & Cats
By Steve Dale
The veterinarian shakes the carrier and the cat drops to the floor with a thud. The dog groomer looks like she's wrestling with her client as she attempts to clip the pet's nails. Both are common practices but they're wrong, says veterinarian and applied animal behaviorist Dr. Sophia Yin, based in Davis, Calif., author of "Handling, Restraint and Behavior Modification of Dogs and Cats." She hopes this groundbreaking book will change how pets are dealt with at veterinary clinics, shelters, groomers and even in our homes.
Yin says that Cesar Millan, TV's 'dog whisperer,' seems to have success by forcing dogs into what he calls submission. Yin says too many veterinary professionals and groomers use the same techniques every day. She even concedes that she once did, too.
"It's what I was taught, and I didn't know any better than using force. For us, at that time, what mattered was that we were able to get the procedure completed."
Yin continues, "What (Millan) says he does is to make himself a pack leader. That's not the case. What he's really doing (called forced helplessness) is like if you're afraid of spiders and freaking out because they're all around you -- but you're being forcibly restrained. You finally realize you are helpless; you can't do a thing about it. You finally give up. But that doesn't mean you're any less anxious. In fact, you're likely to be more afraid. Forcible techniques don't help, except to intensify fear. The goal is to implement techniques that help to make the pet more secure."
The outcome of force may cause a previously content and amicable dog or cat to develop other problems.
For example, Yin recalled a cat named Skippy who was so terrified of vet visits that his owners simply stopped going. The owners did hire someone to trim the cat's nails at their home but the pet was terrified of him. As a result, Skippy became aggressive toward any stranger entering the house.
For cats or dogs who detest having their nails trimmed, the solution is called desensitization and counter-conditioning: Take the clipper out and simply feed your dog (or cat) as you hold the clipper. Yin adds, "Now, touch the dog's feet and offer a treat. Stop giving the treat as you stop the handling. Soon, the pet will figure out, 'wow, this is fun, she touches me and I get fed.'" Yin adds that veterinary professionals or groomers should take the time - and we're only talking 10 minutes or so - to desensitize a dog rather than to allow the anxiety to heighten with each visit.
You can even teach a cat to actually enjoy, or at least accept, taking a pill. Yin says all cat owners should buy a pill gun device (available at some pet stores and online), and place some moist food or baby food on it. Once every few days, offer the treat. A few months or a few years later, when the cat really needs to take a pill, he'll likely be happy about taking the treat or baby food as he always has.
According to the American Veterinary Medical Association, on average, cats visit the veterinarian about half as often as dogs. As a result, many cats die from diseases that might have been treated if only discovered earlier. Many more cats simply don't get treatment because visiting the veterinarian is such an ordeal.
From a cat's point of view, the trauma begins when the carrier is pulled out; the pet knows exactly what this means. Some cats desperately attempt to run off, while others hide. Owners feel awful because they have to stuff a very distressed cat into the carrier, and the cat may even be thinking 'I'm going to die.' There is an alternative, says Yin.
"Cats are actually sometimes easier to train than dogs, and you can teach them to go right into the carrier on command. Begin by keeping the carrier out all the time. Drop treats and kibble around it. The cat's curiosity and hunger will take over. Once the cat is willing to eat near the carrier, place the entire meal inside. Soon the cat may even choose to sleep inside the carrier because it's a secure place."
Once the cat feels comfortable inside the carrier, walk to another room in your house with the carrier, open the door and let the cat hop out. Repeat this action many times. Finally, just before dinnertime, take your tabby for a car ride. Head around the block and return home to feed your cat dinner. Now, instead of the destination being a vet office, it's a yummy meal.
Of course, puppies and kittens can easily be desensitized to veterinary clinics. "Take them there for treats," says Yin. "My dog loved the veterinary clinic because it's a fun place; good things happen there."
Steve Dale welcomes questions/comments from readers. Although he can't answer all of them individually, he'll answer those of general interest in his column. Write to Steve at Tribune Media Services, 2225 Kenmore Ave., Suite 114, Buffalo, NY 14207. Send e-mail to PETWORLD(at)STEVE DALE.TV. Include your name, city and state. Steve's website is www.stevedalepetworld.com; he can be heard Sundays on WGN Radio, 8 to 10 p.m. CST (www.wgnradio.com to listen live), and hosts the nationally syndicated "Steve Dale's Pet World" and "The Pet Minute." He's also a contributing editor to USA Weekend
(c) 2009 DISTRIBUTED BY TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.
Use Treats to Break Dog's Barking Habit
By Steve Dale
My 11-pound American Eskimo dog Foxy barks constantly when she sees another dog outside. Foxy may have simply trained you to let her out to see her friends. Foxy's "issue" may be more complex.
Treating Cats with a Heartworm Preventative
By Steve Dale
My vet suggests I treat my cat, Sasha, with a heartworm preventative. Sasha is an indoor-only cat. I've never heard of this before
Tampa Tops List of Cat-Friendly Cities
By Steve Dale
Dogs may have the claim as our best friends, but Americans' favorite companions are cats. There are more pet cats than dogs in the U.S. (81.7 million cats vs. 71.2 million dogs). Tampa, FL, topped the list, followed by Phoenix; San Francisco, CA; Portland, OR; Denver, CO; Boston, MA; Seattle, WA; San Diego, CA; Atlanta, GA, and Minneapolis, MN.
Questions Answered at the American Animal Hospital Association Conference
By Steve Dale
These pet-related questions were answered at the American Animal Hospital Association Conference May 26-29 at the Phoenix Convention Center. The AAHA supports excellence in veterinary care.
Heartworm Disease on the Rise
By Steve Dale
Experts stop short of calling it an epidemic, but the newly-released results of a nationwide survey indicate that the number of heartworm cases is rising. As a result, it's also likely that more pets are dying of the disease. The tragedy is, heartworm disease in dogs, cats and ferrets is totally preventable.
Dog Owners Share Some Smelly Stories
By Steve Dale
A few weeks back, reader K.S. in Atlanta offered her personal view that dogs' paws smell like Fritos, which sparked an onslaught of email and other comments directed to my Facebook page. I received around 100 comments, and still the controversy rages!
Bone Up Before You Buy: Read About Pet Care Before Bringing Home That Cute Dog or Cat
By Steve Dale
'Tis the season for adding a furry member to you family. But wait! Before you bring home that dog or cat, do your homework and learn how to integrate the pet into your family. Once you do adopt a pet, learning about care and training are imperative. Here are some great new books to help along the way.
Humans May Owe Very Existence to Dogs
By Steve Dale
Whether or not you like dogs, you can thank a canine for your very existence, according to Stanley Coren, a psychology professor at the University of British Columbia, Vancouver, Canada. Without the domestication of canines, early man might never have survived at all, Coren theorizes.
Cat's Quirky Eating, Drinking Habits Not Unusual or Harmful
By Steve Dale
This entire column is devoted to cats. The first two questions were answered at a meeting of the CATalyst Council at the headquarters of the American Veterinary Medical Association. CATalyst is a non-profit organization devoted to elevating the status of cats.
Cat Overpopulation Remains a Problem, Especially in Summer
By Steve Dale
In 1975, American Humane, a non-profit organization dedicated to protecting children and animals, designated June as Adopt-a-Cat month. "Cat overpopulation was a real issue, a big problem back then," says Dena Fitzgerald, publications and communications manager at American Humane. "Unfortunately [today], most shelters are still over-filled with cats."
