Dog training may be going down the tubes

You may not know Dr. Ian Dunbar, but your puppy sure thanks him. He's the one person who arguably most impacted dog training until Cesar Millan hit the scene a few years ago. Dunbar focuses on lure reward (dogs are lured with treats). In fact, this gray-haired veterinarian from Royal Veterinary College of London University single-handedly popularized puppy classes.

"I was getting a Malamute puppy myself (in 1981) and no one offered training when puppies most needed it," Dunbar recalls. "I rang up over 50 (dog training) schools in the greater San Francisco area, and most wouldn't take the dog until he was a year old, some might accept him at six months. Susan Chernak McElroy (a pet writer and trainer) and her boss came to me and said they're looking for new ideas in dog training. I designed an off-leash class for puppies."

Dunbar understood research had long proven that puppies have a window of learning, known as the critical period of socialization. And while that window never completely closes, puppies can be best socialized when they're very young. By six months or a year, behavior problems - which might have been prevented with early socialization - already exist.

Some veterinarians protested, worried about disease transmission, at first concerned about distemper and later the threat became the parvovirus. However, today, the vast majority of vets concur with the importance of early socialization and puppy classes. Many vets, however, feel better if puppies are protected by at least two of the series of parvovirus vaccines before participating in a class. Dunbar doesn't necessarily disagree, but feels strongly that all puppies should be socialized to the hilt at home. "Every puppy should meet 100 people by its eighth week, all kinds of people of all ages," he says.

Following puppy classes, Dunbar supports further training, or "learning manners," as he puts it. Dogs are played with and encouraged with praise. That's light years different than Cesar Millan, the "Dog Whisperer," and his approach to be the dominant pack leader. Millan uses intimidation as a tool rather than motivation.

Dunbar's weary of being asked about Millan's theories and what seems like a mindless public following Millan's lead.

"It's just a different approach," he says. After all, Dunbar encourages clients to say "thank you" to their dogs. His methods are certainly far more genteel. Dunbar thinks dogs would do what we want, if only they understood. "That's the trick -- communication," he says.

Conversely, Millan told me an interview earlier this year, "Dogs need to know that you're in charge, that you are the pack leader."

Still, Dunbar and the Dog Whisperer are actually both on the same page on one topic: treating dogs as surrogate children. Millan says, "Americans do their dogs harm, spoiling them, not giving them enough exercise, and thinking they are little people."

"Well, they are dogs, aren't they?" Dunbar says and laughs. "They are not little humans in furry suits." But he is quick to add, "This doesn't mean we can't love them, or get doggy kisses. Or allow them on the couch or our beds. We just have to realize that they are dogs. But that's not so bad - dogs are our loyal friends."

Dunbar adds, "The biggest human foible we have, whether interacting with people or dogs, is we take the good for granted and grumble about the bad. And we don't say 'thank you,' or 'good job.' We wait until people or dogs make a mistake, and we sometimes assume it's on purpose, when it's not. We highlight the misbehavior. Kelly (his wife, Kelly Dunbar Gorman) and I began a new program at www.openpaw.org, designing (training) techniques specifically for adult dogs. You don't need any hocus pocus of a TV trainer (Millan). It's quite simple. Watch the dog. Wait until you get exactly the behavior you want and say, 'good boy!' Within a minute of doing this, your dog will respond. All we ask is that owners watch their dogs and every five seconds, respond. If the dog is being good, now praise with 'good dog.' All other behaviors are ignored. In five minutes, every dog is improved. It's amazing. It works."

Dunbar may not be a household name but he's hardly been a dog-training wallflower. He founded the Association of Pet Dog Trainers and has written several books (some available at no fee on his website, www.dogstardailycom). Still, he has nowhere near the platform to reach dog owners as Millan. And that's frustrating. "Sure we're the smarter species, but still I don't believe dogs are servants and we are masters," he says.

Dogs may be man's best friend, but Dunbar remains their best advocate.

 

 

Legendary Trainer Thinks Dog Training Might be in Trouble
By Steve Dale

Dr. Ian Dunbar fears dog training may be going down the tubes. Dunbar, arguably the most influential dog trainer of the past four decades, shifted the standard from punishment-based techniques to positive lure reward training, motivating through food and toys. Dunbar first appeared on the scene when most dogs weren't even trained at all.

Here Are Some Exotic Pets You Can Actually Live With
By Steve Dale

Here are five relative newcomers to the pet world. Perhaps their exotic appeal is bringing a little of the wild world into our concrete jungles

Tick Numbers Climbing, Even in Urban Areas
By Steve Dale

Ticks, and the diseases they transmit, are now in all 50 states. And experts concur that their numbers are rising. Dr. Dwight Bowman, a veterinary parisitologist at Cornell University, says that a general increase in wildlife numbers -- including deer, wild turkey, raccoon and other animals -- intersecting with suburbia likely has the most impact

 

Steve Dale welcomes questions/comments from readers. Although he can't answer all of them individually, he'll answer those of general interest in his column. Write to Steve at Tribune Media Services, 2225 Kenmore Ave., Suite 114, Buffalo, NY 14207. Send e-mail to PETWORLD(at)STEVE DALE.TV. Include your name, city and state. Steve's website is www.stevedalepetworld.com; he can be heard Sundays on WGN Radio, 8 to 10 p.m. CST (www.wgnradio.com to listen live), and hosts the nationally syndicated "Steve Dale's Pet World" and "The Pet Minute." He's also a contributing editor to USA Weekend

(c) 2009 DISTRIBUTED BY TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.