"The Last of the Unjust" Movie Review: 3 1/2 Stars
by Kenneth Turan
With the groundbreaking 91/2-hour "Shoah" and similar documentaries to his credit, it would be understandable if filmmaker Claude Lanzmann felt he'd spent enough time dealing with the Holocaust. But the opposite is true, with a vengeance.
At age 87, Lanzmann has come out with one of his most provocative films because he felt he had no choice. The subject of "The Last of the Unjust," based on interviews the director did in 1975, "continued to dwell in my mind and haunt me," Lanzmann has written. "I was the custodian of something unique."
What's unique are the thoughts and reminiscences of Benjamin Murmelstein, who died in 1989.
Murmelstein had been a rabbi in
More than that, Murmelstein had been the head of the Judenrat at the notorious Theresienstadt camp, a show ghetto in the Bohemian countryside just outside
At three hours and 38 minutes, "The Last of the Unjust," like Lanzmann himself at his advanced age, is ungainly but powerful. An essay/meditation on the nature of good and evil, heroism and expediency, this films tackles head-on the question of whether people such as Murmelstein were collaborators who should be condemned, if not executed, or realists who made the best of a completely nightmarish situation. Those who think this is a black-and-white issue will be surprised, as Lanzmann himself appears to have been, by what is said here.
Lanzmann filmed about a dozen hours of conversation with Murmelstein, and "The Last of the Unjust" -- a play on the title of
Before we get to the heart of Murmelstein's testimony, we see Lanzmann at stations where the transport trains to Theresienstadt stopped, hear a cantor chanting Kol Nidre at a restored synagogue, even glimpse people walking on the Holocaust-themed Path of Remembrance in
A bull of a man trying to finish his life's work, the aging but indomitable Lanzmann is a powerful presence, and his moments in today's crumbling ruins of the Theresienstadt camp have an impact. But "The Last of the Unjust" is at its best in the 1975 footage and the glimpse it gives us into an aspect of the Holocaust even Lanzmann hasn't shown us before.
Articulate and unabashed, a man of formidable will and intelligence and a most persuasive talker, Murmelstein is well aware that his actions ("They said I was a big mouth and mean") have enraged people. He calls his position as head of the Judenrat "a mockery, a character created to be made fun of," but insisted that despite the essential powerlessness of his situation, he "had to be a marionette who pulled his own strings."
Because he believes that "one cannot understand things without context," Murmelstein begins his story in 1938, six years before his ascension at Theresienstadt. As a representative of the Vienna Jewish community, he worked closely with the notorious
It's when Murmelstein begins to talk about his time at Theresienstadt that "Last of the Unjust" goes up a notch. He says of the camp that "it was all a lie from top to bottom" and uses as an example his reaction when the Germans insisted that a typhus epidemic had to be instantly eradicated.
"We had the doctors write 'diarrhea' instead of 'typhus' on all cases," Murmelstein said. "You have to defeat the enemy with its own methods; lies had more value in Theresienstadt than elsewhere."
Though he admits to a taste for adventure and ambition ("We're all human, who doesn't like power?"), Murmelstein does not have a heroic vision for himself. In fact, the literary character he most identifies with is
"He is pragmatic and calculating while others are tilting at windmills," Murmelstein explains. "I was a calculating realist with both feet on the ground."
Lanzmann wouldn't be Lanzmann if he didn't push back at some of Murmelstein's claims, especially the man's defense of his decision to help beautify Theresienstadt's facilities to mislead visitors from the
Accused by Lanzmann of being unemotional about the plight of Jews who died in Theresienstadt or were shipped east, Murmelstein replies, "If you are a doctor crying over a patient during an operation, you kill him. What good would crying have done?"
Somewhere near the end of his multi-hour interview with Lanzmann, Murmelstein takes a breath and says to his interrogator, "I never pulled away from danger. You're the last danger to come my way and I'm not afraid of you either." How many people he will convince is an open question, but Murmelstein's efforts make you think about the unthinkable, and that is a major accomplishment in and of itself.
No MPAA rating. Running time: 3:38
"The Last of the Unjust" Movie Trailer
'Shoah' director Claude Lanzmann's provocative Holocaust film 'The Last of the Unjust' tackles head-on whether Theresienstadt administrator Benjamin Murmelstein was a collaborator or a realist