Project Nim

3 Stars

If a chimp was raised by humans as a human, would he inevitably go ape?

That's the central question posed by the absorbing Project Nim. And the answer is that a chimp would at some point exhibit wild behavior dictated by his hard wiring, but, then, so would the humans handling him. That is, if he was literally going ape, then, metaphorically speaking, so were his human handlers.

In 1973, a wife brought a chimpanzee home to her husband and seven kids and proceeded to raise it in their Upper West Side brownstone in New York City along with, and as, one of her children -- even breastfeeding him.

That's the springboard for Project Nim, a compelling documentary about a controversial scientific research experiment in the nature-versus-nurture vein that traded in the rigors of the laboratory for what would come to resemble a seventies hippie commune.

When he was just two weeks old, the chimp was taken from his mother at an Oklahoma primate preserve and sent to New York City for a Columbia University linguistics experiment.

Could a chimp raised among humans and taught to communicate with sign language (chimps don't possess the physical capacity to talk) learn not just a vocabulary of over 100 words but grammatical structure as well? Or was this just gussied-up anthropomorphiic nonsense?

And more dramatically, would the humans be safe with this strong, wild animal and his powerful fangs in the house? Would the excesses of the 1970s -- like the sexual entanglements of Nim's human nurturers -- enter into the murky ethics of this seriously flawed simian experiment? And would Nim simply accept the parade of dysfunctional caretakers in his life, never seeing another chimp, or would he be traumatized -- and get to use those words he had learned to articulate just that -- by what seemed like serial abandonment?

The chimp's name was Nim Chimpsky (a pun on Noah Chompsky, the linguist who professed that language was for humans only and whose theories this experiment was designed to challenge or disprove), and he would experience a roller coaster of a life dictated by the humans in his unique circumstance. And despite all the animal behavior on display, it's the human behavior that is perhaps most eye-opening, upsetting, and perversely fascinating: here's a group of people who would appear to care very much for Nim, but who are also more than willing to exploit him.

Documentarian James Marsh, director of the fascinating, Oscar-winning Man on Wire, engrosses us once again by mixing talking-head interviews, archival footage, and dramatic re-creations. He gives his interviewees their say as they explain what they remember from their own viewpoint, and he covers the 27 years of Nim's life, which ended in 2000.

But he pretty much lets us draw our own conclusions. Which are? Well, we're initially intrigued, eventually saddened, and ultimately disappointed by the shortsightedness and self-absorption of our own deeply flawed species, as represented here by the self-serving participants in this misguided experiment.

Because we can't give the title character the last word in the unsettling chimp-experiment-gone-awry doc, Project Nim, let's turn to one of the humans involved:

"We did a huge disservice to him and his soul, and shame on us."

 

93 minutes

In theaters July 22, 2011

Rating: PG-13, Documentary

 

     RSS

 

"Project Nim" Movie Trailer

 

more MOVIE REVIEWS ...

Recent Movie Reviews - Films in Theaters

 

Captain America

Captain America: The First Avenger
Michael Phillips

Everything good about 'Captain America: The First Avenger,' which certainly is the most stylish comics-derived entertainment of the year. Director Joe Johnston's film is paced and designed for people who won't shrivel up and die if two or three characters take 45 seconds between combat sequences to have a conversation about world domination   [Continue ...]

 

Friends with Benefits

Friends With Benefits
Michael Phillips

'No relationship. No emotions. Just sex!' So says the hotshot website art director played by Justin Timberlake, recruited from his California gig for a New York City job as GQ magazine's design head. The woman he's pitching, an executive headhunter played by Mila Kunis, says she's up for it. The newbie and his savvy Manhattan sponsor fall into a fast friendship   [Continue ...]

Friends with Benefits
Bill Wine

To wit: a contemporary couple attempts to keep their relationship strictly physical, with no romantic involvement. Friends with Benefits features Justin Timberlake and Mila Kunis. Friends with Benefits benefits from some friendly genre tweaking   [Continue ...]

Project Nim

Project Nim
Bill Wine

In 1973, a wife brought a chimpanzee home to her husband and seven kids and proceeded to raise it in their Upper West Side brownstone in New York City along with, and as, one of her children. That's the springboard for this compelling documentary about a controversial scientific research experiment in the nature-versus-nurture vein

 

Copyright © 2011 Tribune Media Services, Inc.