No historically grounded film is obliged to stick to the facts, and having made "Glory," "The Last Samurai" and "Blood
Diamond," in order of decreasing effectiveness, director Edward Zwick knows firsthand the difficulty of forging potentially
uncommercial subject matter into satisfying popular entertainment.
Yet some stories resist Hollywood manhandling more than others.
Zwick's latest, "Defiance," holds you, and its story is remarkable. The telling of that story, however, feels honest
one minute and false the next, and the film's determination to mythologize the heroism of the real-life characters comes
across as unseemly.
In 1941, in the area known then as Belorussia (now Belarus), a farmer's son with a checkered past named Tuvia Bielski
led the rescue of more than 1,000 fellow Jews by establishing what became known as "Jerusalem in the woods" -- a
settlement deep in the Naliboki Forest.
"We know these woods," says Tuvia's brother Asael, played by Jamie Bell. "They'll never find us here."
Daniel Craig portrays Tuvia, the charismatic, circumspect leader of this collective. Liev Schreiber, perpetually
gunning down Nazis, is the hotheaded brother of action, Zus. Alongside Bell's Asael, there is a fourth brother, Aron,
played by young George MacKay and first seen hiding in a farmhouse cellar, having survived a massacre. Later, many
Jews who have the chance to join the Bielskis in the forest choose not to. The options are clear, says Schreiber's
exasperated Zus, simplifying in the extreme: "Fight, or wait to be killed."
The script boils everything down to simple, reductive maxims.
The characters sound less like real people in a grimly dramatic circumstance than supporting turns in an old-fashioned
play. "If my friends at the New Socialist Club could see me now!" says the self-professed intellectual played by Mark
Feuerstein, assisting with the construction of a shelter. Lines such as this, akin to Zwick's habit of grouping his
extras just so (like extras), keep "Defiance" firmly in movieland, as opposed to life.
Zwick's technique has its strengths. He's a front-and-center story man, though in both "Blood Diamond" and "Defiance,"
the strain of addressing deadly serious matters while setting up the next violent set piece becomes troubling.
Here he cross-cuts "Godfather"-style between the wedding celebration of brother Asael and his bride, and Zus'
dazzling commando attack on the latest group of Nazi soldiers. It's a misplaced attempt at virtuosity; because
we're witnessing wholly justified slaughter juxtaposed against loving ritual, the dramatic impact is muffled.
The script hokes up the tensions between the brothers played by Craig and Schreiber, and while they're both
fascinating, simmering-kettle performers, they consistently outshine their material.
Much of the film cannot help but get you in the gut. It's an action-packed melodrama at heart. And that's why
"Defiance" is a limited achievement: The film should've aimed higher, given all that these people endured to have
their story told.
Defiance Movie Trailer
Defiance Movie - The "Defiance" panel talks about making the movie with Charlie Rose
"Defiance" Movie MPAA rating: R (for violence and language).
Running time: 2:17.
Starring: Daniel Craig (Tuvia Bielski); Liev Schreiber (Zus Bielski); Jamie Bell (Asael Bielski); Alexa Davalos (Lilka); Allan Corduner (Shimon); Mark Feuerstein (Isaac).
Directed by Edward Zwick; written by Clayton Frohman and Zwick, based on the book by Nechama Tec; photographed by Eduardo Serra; edited by Steven Rosenblum; music by James Newton Howard; production designed by Dan Weil; produced by Zwick and Pieter Jan Brugge. A Paramount Vantage release.
Kevin James plays a mall security guard trying to stop a Black Friday robbery scheme. Underneath all the cartoonish mall
mayhem and silly slapstick lies a comedy that aspires to be the sort of gentle crowd-pleaser John Hughes used to make.
Jamal Woolard stars in this biopic about The Notorious B.I.G., the rapper who was gunned down on Wilshire Boulevard in
1997 when he was just 24. Woolard turns in a performance that goes a long way toward saving a movie that has fallen
obsessively in love with its subject.
Dustin Hoffman and Emma Thompson smooth over most of the problems just by showing up and doing what they do for a
living. Hoffman plays a composer who meets the lonely-hearts frump played by the luminous Thompson and invites
her to his daughter's wedding.
A teen girl and her younger brother are placed in the dubious foster care of two headbangers, all the while keeping
their Jack Russell terrier a secret from their alleged caregivers. One day they discover a condemned hotel where a
few strays have set up shop, and the kids and their newfound human pals get to work rehabbing the joint. This mildly
entertaining film is loosely based on a Lois Duncan book.
Steven Soderbergh's two-part Che is a methodical if coolly romantic portrait of the most familiar 1960s T-shirt icon
outside the peace symbol. Though not without its faults, this is Soderberghs most interesting film in years, defiantly
eccentric and absorbing at its best.
This charmless film concerns two lifelong friends, played by Kate Hudson and Anne Hathaway, whose competing weddings, mistakenly scheduled for the same day at Manhattan's Plaza Hotel, turn bride-to-be against bride-to-be. Half the comedies made in Hollywood are based on the premise of boy-men acting like idiots. Switching the gender and toning down the vulgarity to a PG level offers only change, not improvement. Hathaway in particular deserves better material.
Based on a book by Bishop T.D. Jakes, this film is a faith-based love story, secondarily about God's role in the care and feeding of an L.A. couple's turbulent marriage. Thanks to Morris Chestnut, whose warm, easy screen presence was an asset way back in "Boyz N the Hood," and to Taraji P. Henson, a by-the-book scenario (described by screenwriter Brian Bird as "sort of a male version of the film 'Waiting to Exhale'") ends up being pretty entertaining.
The misadventures of a lovable Labrador retriever frame this sweet, surprisingly moving chronicle of a young couples
struggle to simultaneously build a family, advance their careers and maintain their sanity. Owen Wilson plays journalist
John Grogan, whose popular 2005 memoir spawned this film, and Jennifer Aniston plays Jenny, his wife. Dog lovers will
laugh delightedly for the first hour and spend the second hour weeping openly.
This is a tall tale of a man aging in reverse while bobbing serenely on lifes unpredictable seas. The colorful supporting
characters spill their guts to the wonder of nature played by Brad Pitt, as he begins his life a very old man, ages into
late-middle age, ripens into well, Brad Pitt, then embarks on the big fade into childhood, infancy and Check-out time.
This film spends 105 minutes grappling at the edge of camp, Cheap laughs and cliches. Yet the way it is handled by
director Darren Aronofsky and especially by Mickey Rourke, who really should get an Oscar for his portrayal of Randy The Ram
Robinson, a steroid-addled sweetie in tights, it stays honest and keeps on fighting.
Valkyrie, a plot to assassinate Hitler, stars Tom Cruise as Col. Claus von Stauffenberg, a cultured aesthete who turned
against his supreme commander. Cruise is not bad, but he cannot suggest the aristocratic hauteur or the steely authority
needed in this role. Going into this film, you know how things are going to come out. Still, with actors as good as Tom
Wilkinson, Bill Nighy, Thomas Kretschmann and Kenneth Branagh in key supporting roles, this ensemble piece avoids the
usual action-movie triumphalism.
Adam Sandler plays Skeeter, a hotel handyman under the thumb of the owner (Richard Griffiths) and manager (Guy Pearce). Skeeter and his sister (Courteney Cox) grew up in a motel bungalow court, and Skeeter longs for a crack at running the hotel that's built on the site. While Sis is away, Skeeter must baby-sit for his niece and nephew, and the adventure stories he spins become fantasy vignettes that somehow manage to improve his disappointing life. It's an adequate idea, dutifully delivered.
Kate Winslet stars in the film version of the Bernhard Schlink novel about a 15-year-old West German boy who, in 1958,
embarks on an affair with a 36-year-old trolley conductor with more on her mind, and in her past, than she admits.
The novel was hugely popular as well as controversial worldwide
Jim Carrey plays a loan officer who cannot get out of his self-pitying rut three years after a breakup. Then he encounters a self-help guru (Terence Stamp, in his first genuinely funny screen appearance) who challenges
his followers to say yes to every single thing that comes their way.
Gran Torino Gran Torino Movie Review & Movie Trailer
Clint Eastwood performance as a reclusive Korean War veteran toughing it out in a sketchy Detroit-area neighborhood may well lead to his first Academy Award for acting. After the vets young neighbor (Bee Vang) breaks into his garage to steal the car for which this film is named, our hero sets out to teach the boy how to stand up to his venal gangsta cousins.
Seven Pounds Seven Pounds Movie Review & Movie Trailer
Will Smith plays an IRS agent who has committed a terrible deed and appears to be investigating the cases of a carefully selected group of people, including a seriously ill heart patient (Rosario Dawson) and a blind pianist (Woody Harrelson).
This earnest, emotional film is a mixed but pretty interesting bag, though its G rating may mislead some parents into taking 4 or 5 year-olds to it, which could lead to some freakouts. Much of the movie, based on a Newbery Medal-winning book, has a grim narrative.
Frost / Nixon Frost / Nixon Movie Review & Movie Trailer
Defiance starring Daniel Craig & Liev Schreiber Movie Review | Michael Phillips Reviews Defiance Defiance Movie Review & Movie Trailer
Defiance stars Daniel Craig & Liev Schreiber.
Defiance in Theaters this weekend Defiance movie review and movie trailer
RSS
