World's Thugs do not Appreciate Obama's Goodwill
Victor Davis Hanson
President Obama Foreign Policy
President Barack Obama came into office apparently believing that his non-traditional background, charisma and good intentions could placate dictators hostile to America and ease global tensions.
In these first six months, the new administration has made clear to Iran's Mahmoud Ahmadinejad, Venezuela's Hugo Chavez, Nicaragua's Daniel Ortega, Russia's Vladimir Putin and other strongmen like them that Barack Obama is not a mean-talking George Bush.
A kinder, gentler United States has promised to push the "reset" button.
In the interest of peace, an American president would finally be listening rather than lecturing, and willing to talk to authoritarian bullies without preconditions.
But so far the world's thugs do not seem to appreciate that new goodwill.
Intelligence reports indicate that North Korea's Kim Jong-il is planning to launch a ballistic test missile in the direction of Hawaii between July 4 and July 8. Russia's Vladimir Putin would like to replace the dollar as the global currency.
Most recently, Obama kept relatively silent for a week after the fraudulent Iranian election and the ensuing government crackdown against protestors. He was apparently worried about offending Iran's Mahmoud Ahmadinejad and the mullahs above him who truly run the country -- and thereby making it more difficult to negotiate once the resistance was put down.
Obama's confusion about the world's bad actors suggests that he needs a general refresher course in the world of thugs.
Lesson One: Thugs only want America, the world's most powerful democracy -- not others -- to apologize
Iran's Ahmadinejad does not care whether his friends the Russians slaughtered Muslims recently in Afghanistan and Chechnya, or have meddled in Iranian affairs for over two centuries. Iranian mullahs only want Russian nuclear expertise, not their apologies.
When President Obama says he is sorry to Iran about American involvement in a coup 66 years ago, it may make us feel better. But thugs like Ahmadinejad more likely interpret our apologies as signs of our own confusion -- and so a green light for more troublemaking.
Lesson Two: Being anti-American and mouthing tired charges about imperialism, colonialism or capitalism do not make a thug authentic or populist
By definition, thugs acquire power illegitimately. They keep it unlawfully. And they exercise it illegally -- regardless of their professed concern for the "people" or their gripes against America.
Thugs are thugs, and they come in all ideologies, colors and religions -- from Zimbabwe's Robert Mugabe to North Korea's Kim Jong-il to the late Slobodan Milosevic of Serbia.
Theocratic Ahmadinejad may scream constantly about Western oppression, but that does not mean any of his loud grievances are legitimate, or that his own people see him as a romantic popular leader. Communist Fidel Castro may scream anti-American slurs, but he still spent a half-century jailing or executing anyone he pleased.
Lesson Three. The more we speak out about the harsh rule of thugs, the more oppressed people will come to respect us
Our past resistance to Ahmadinejad may help explain why the Iranian people seem to admire us more than do many in the Arab street, whose dictatorships in Saudi Arabia and Egypt we so fawningly have praised.
Lesson Four. Thugs can never be trusted -- whether an Adolf Hitler or Josef Stalin of the past or the rogue's gallery of today
Ahmadinejad is lying about his peaceful plans for nuclear technology. Kim Jong-il continued his nuclear program when he promised that he would not. Syria's Bashar Assad hid his nuclear reactor under construction.
Lesson Five. Most of the world's problems are caused by a handful of thugs
Any time one can be isolated and replaced by a consensual government, the world gets just a bit safer.
If Iran were to embrace a free and fairly elected government, it would likely not be threatening to wipe out Israel or funding terrorists in Lebanon and Palestine. Once Saddam disappeared, so did $25,000 payments to the families of suicide bombers on the West Bank and Iraq's plan to conquer the Persian Gulf. With the Taliban out of power, Afghanistan is less likely to be used by terrorists to take down an American skyscraper.
So, Mr. President, do not talk to a thug unless you absolutely have to
Do not apologize to -- or put our trust in -- one. And whenever people rise up against a thug, speak out immediately and forcefully on their behalf -- and let the thug, not America, worry about the consequences of the spread of freedom.
by Victor Davis Hanson
Are you confused by all that has changed since President Barack Obama took office in January? If so, you're not alone. Perhaps, though, this handy guide to Age of Obama "logic" might be of some assistance.
Our Historically Challenged President
by Victor Davis Hanson
Despite President Obama's image as an Ivy-League-educated intellectual, he lacks historical competency, both in areas of facts and interpretation.
As Iranians Revolt, Their Government Reveals True Self
by William Pfaff
The truly significant result of the suppressed Iranian revolt is that the most important Islamist radical movement in the contemporary world has demonstrated that it has become a brutally repressive dictatorship whose leaders rig elections and beat down clear popular demands for a true election count or repeat of the election itself.
The War Between Civilizations That Never Was
by William Pfaff
An important change is evident in what since Samuel Huntington's time has been mistakenly identified and manipulated as a war between Muslim and Western civilizations.
Iran's (So Far) Revolution-less Struggle
by William Pfaff
Iran's cosmopolitan and liberal middle classes and its students are making a revolutionary bid without intending a revolution. Few think that the demonstrations in Tehran, and now in other Iranian cities, can produce a change in regime.
- Events in Middle East & Central Asia Challenge U.S's Conventional Assumptions
- Richard Haass on Bush's Unjust Iraq War Blunder
- Indian Ocean: Center Stage for 21st Century Struggles Between India & China
- Obama Should Not Abandon Israel in Effort to Court Muslims
- Tehran's Take: Understanding Iran's U.S. Policy
The Nation-State is Back & How
International Politics & Foreign Affairs
- A Bright Star on the World Stage: Smiles & handshakes a Start But Obama's real challenge will be to show results
Victor Davis Hanson is a classicist and historian at the Hoover Institution, Stanford University, and author, most recently, of "A War Like No Other: How the Athenians and Spartans Fought the Peloponnesian War." You can reach him by e-mailing email@example.com.
(C) 2009 TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.