Umm al-Hieran, Israel
Salim Abu al-Qi'an's family lives in Israel's Negev desert in the "unrecognized" Bedouin village of Umm al-Hieran, 9km from the nearest source of clean water.
"There is no water in the village. We truck it in. It costs about 50 shekels [US$13.4] per cubic metre of water," explained the 53-year-old village leader. "There is a pipe that's about 8km long, but it's too old, and the planning authorities don't allow us to put a new one under the ground. We are asking for better access to water, a new pipe that should be close to the village."
The Israeli authorities forced Umm al-Hieran residents to move to the area where the village now sits in 1956, shortly after the military had evicted them from their original homes in the Wadi Zuballa area of the Negev desert.
In 2004, the villagers faced a new threat of expulsion, as the Southern District Planning Committee unveiled a master plan which involves once again displacing Umm al-Hieran, and building the Jewish community of Hiran in its place. According to the Israeli government, the 500 residents of Umm al-Hieran are trespassers who are illegally squatting on state land.
Some 80-90,000 Bedouin citizens of Israel live in unrecognized villages in the southern Negev, according to a report by the Association for Civil Rights in Israel. As a result of their unrecognized status, nearly every structure in these communities can be demolished at any time, and residents do not receive basic services from the state, including electricity, paved roads, healthcare facilities, schools, and water.
Constitutional right
In June 2011, however, the Israeli Supreme Court ruled that the right to water was a constitutional right, and that the state must guarantee a "minimum access to water" for the residents of the unrecognized villages. Still, the court did not specify what constituted a fair minimum.
Shortly thereafter, a Haifa court, acting as a water tribunal, rejected Umm al-Hieran's application to be connected to the local water network. The court argued that the villagers had minimum access to water, and suggested they buy water from private citizens in towns connected to the water network, or move into nearby government-planned Bedouin townships.
According to Sawsan Zaher, an attorney at Adalah, the Legal Center from Arab Minority Rights in Israel, which has represented al-Qi'an's family and the residents of Umm al-Hieran in their legal struggle, the water tribunal's decision means that "a constitutional right, which is the right to water as part of the right to a minimal standard of living, [will] be provided by private actors and not by the state. This is in contradiction to constitutional law. The duty is on the state to fulfil this right and protect it even."
Adalah has filed an appeal to Israel's Supreme Court, asking that "minimum access to water" be explicitly defined, and challenging the constitutionality of forcing Umm al-Hieran residents to purchase water from non-state actors.
"Despite the fact that they are citizens, they are not entitled to the same level of rights as other citizens of Israel. Why? Because they are living in unrecognized villages," Zaher told IRIN.
"We want you to move out"
"The purpose is not hidden any more. It is revealed and it's very official: we are not connecting you to water because we want you to move out. This is the policy. It's a kind of punishment. This is in huge contradiction with human rights and logic and humanity - to come and punish people by not giving them water for political purposes," Zaher said.
In a 9 March report, the UN Committee on the Elimination of Racial Discrimination raised concerns about Bedouin communities in Israel, particularly with regard to Bedouin home demolitions, and inequalities between Bedouin and Jewish citizens' access to land, housing, education, employment and public health.
Israel's proposed Law for the Regulation of Bedouin Settlement in the Negev, which would forcibly displace 30,000-60,000 of the 80,000-90,000 Bedouins living in unrecognized villages, should be shelved, the UN Committee found, since it legalizes "the ongoing policy of home demolitions and forced displacement of the indigenous Bedouin communities".
According to Salim Abu al-Qi'an, forcibly displacing residents of Umm al-Hieran to the nearby government-planned Bedouin township of Hura is indeed the motivation behind denying them direct access to high-quality water.
"They want to push us to leave the village and to displace us," he told IRIN. "Even though we are an unrecognized village, this is nicer than to live in Hura. There are no services there. Sewage and garbage is in the street. There's not enough space. It's another refugee camp."
jkd/eo/cb
- Provided by Integrated Regional Information Networks.
Twitter: @ihavenet
- Death Penalty Stalks the Middle East and North Africa
- Arms Appetite in Middle East and North Africa Remains Strong
- Web Grows in Middle East and North Africa But So Does Censorship
- Al-Assad Revives Father's Torture Techniques
- Military Intervention in Syria is a Bad Idea
- The Great Syrian Divide
- Syria's Systematic Torture
- The Screws Tighten on Syria's Assad
- Assad Is Not All That's Toxic About Syria
- Tales of Horror From Syrian Refugees
- A 'New Humanitarianism' at Play in Syrian Crisis
- Collapse of Syrian Pound Echoes Across Jordan
- Syrian Unrest Affecting Entire Communities
- Iraq and the Limits of U.S. Power
- New Protests Test Saudi Monarchy's Control
- Saudi Women on Their Way to London Olympics
- What's Wrong with Containment
- Iranian Angst: Not Israel, But Domestic Discord
- Israel: Water Being Used to Coerce Bedouin Villagers
- Israel: Joining Start-Up Nation
- Film Aims to Shift Narrative About Israel
- Israel's Shrinking Middle Class
- Egypt's Liberals Shun Constitutional Assembly
- In Egypt, A cellphone is a Wireless Lifeline
- Egypt: Livestock Disease Puts Food Security at Risk
- Copts Debate: Fighting Pope or Peacemaker
- Sick and Tired of the Middle East
- The Arab Spring at One
- Arab Spring Democracy: A Win for Women?
- Iran's Ahmadinejad Down But Not Quite Out
- Attack on Iran Would be a Mistake
- School Debate Shows Deep Divisions in Israel
- Youth Aren't Being Served in Saudi Arabia
- Saudi Arabia and the Muslim Brotherhood: Unexpected Adversaries
- Saudi Students Stage Rowdy Protests
- Netanyahu Fails to Convince Israelis on Iran Threat
- Iran's Domestic Struggle Continues
- Crisis-Managing United States - Iran Relations
- The Iraq We Left Behind
- NATO's Victory in Libya
- If America Won't Lead Against Iran, It Should Get Out of the Way
- United States and Israel Need to Agree on Strike Against Iran
- Israeli Attack on Iran Could Become a Religious War
- United States Should Discourage Israel From Striking Iran
- Threat of U.S. Strike is Vital to Deterring Iran
- United States and Israel Should Push for Regime Change in Iran
- Solving Syria Requires Separating Myth From Reality
- Questioning Intervention in Syria
- Yemen: Tortured for Ransom
- Honor Killings Defy Attempts at Reform
- Egypt: Helping Refugee Women to Fend for Themselves
- Egypt: Fears of Malnutrition Amid Increasing Poverty
- Lebanon: Tussle Over Gender Violence Law
- Lebanon: Boost for Relatives of Civil War Missing
- Red Sea Bridge Back on the Drawing Board
- Writing on the Wall: Israel and its Christians
- Get Ready for War with Iran
- Panetta: U.S. Will Do 'Everything' to Stop Iran
- Next Fight in Egypt and Tunisia Will Be Among The Islamists
- Tunisia at a Crossroads
- Egypt's Other Revolution: Modernizing the Military-Industrial Complex
- Clock Ticking for Egypt's Finances
- Port Said Dialogue Aims to Restore Calm
- Egyptian Strike Fails to Mobilize Masses
- The Egyptian Revolution One Year On
- Russia and China Defy Morality by Backing Syria's Assad
- Inside the Anti-Uprising Movement in Syria
- Jihadist Opportunities in Syria
- Syrian Youth Against Tyranny
- Worrying Signs for Food Security in Syria
- Syria's Chaos Reaches Its Kitchens
- Syria is Trending Toward the Libya Model
- Many Non-Military Options in Syria
- Syrian Intervention Need Not Be Military-Focused
- Too Many Obstacles Stand in Way of Syrian Intervention
- Intervening in Syria is Tough, but Civilian Victims Deserve It
- Syria: Two Car Bombs Hit Security Facilities
Copyright © 2012 AHN - All Rights Reserved