Vanessa Rossi and Will Jackson
Considerable headwinds are hampering efforts to bring debt under control. Firstly, annual interest costs alone will be as much as seven to eight percent of GDP and rising as debt is now estimated to reach around 150 percent of GDP in 2011. Thus the government will not be able to reduce the budget deficit unless it achieves a substantial surplus on the primary budget - the balance between revenues and noninterest expenditure.
Secondly, it is extremely difficult to achieve and maintain a primary budget surplus. The programme of structural adjustments, spending cuts and tax reforms agreed as part of the bail-out deal has been only partially implemented. The tax take remains low, and moves towards deregulation and privatisations are progressing only slowly, hindered also by recessionary conditions.
And thirdly, while government debt was expected to peak at about 150 percent of GDP, it is now likely to rise to over 160 percent of GDP even if the tough budget targets set in the bail-out deal are met, which is unlikely.
With weak local growth and low national savings, the level of debt and interest payments in
Limits Of Credibility
Last year, as the Greek crisis threatened to boil over and infect other countries, the Eurozone's announcement of a sizeable bail-out plan for periphery debtors - the European Stability Mechanism (ESM), to be operated in conjunction with the IMF - was punchy enough to convince investors that there would be no disorderly defaults in the short-term. Countries at risk would be protected for the coming one to two years. It also provided a breathing space for a more thorough, long-run solution to be thrashed out. Yet, after a short respite, the situation steadily deteriorated and, one year on, even the terms of the Eurozone bail-out mechanism have yet to be fully settled. It is now much harder to persuade markets that there are no default risks and debts will be repaid in full.
It is no surprise that the periphery debt crisis continued to escalate through 2010-11. As its banking crisis overwhelmed national resources,
Apart from the shifting scale of the bail-outs, their varying terms are also somewhat confusing, prompting complicated wrangles over the differing interest rates applied across the four to six percent range, and demands for adjustments to reduce the cost of loans. Negotiations over the ESM - likely to be completed at the European Summit in June - by the countries being bailed out are expected to focus on easier repayment terms and lower interest costs. However, any such subsidies will have to be provided using Eurozone funds, as the IMF has no mandate to pursue such concessions.
In theory, there is also potential for a creditor agreement on rescheduling, involving the European banks (which are the main holders of periphery debt), as well as the
What Would Be A Viable Level Of Debt?
The latest surge in market interest rates on periphery sovereign debt towards twenty percent or more reflects further downgrades from the credit rating agencies and a renewed slump in investor sentiment. Access to markets is restricted and would be too costly to be supportable for the troubled periphery economies. This is not the fault of markets and speculators - the scale of debt in these countries, coupled with the difficult task of achieving both fiscal austerity and a return to growth, have damaged confidence in the ability of the respective governments to meet the terms of bail-out plans and repay debts, even under a regime of cheap emergency loans.
For debtor countries, a moratorium on all interest costs - effectively a form of staggered 'hair cut' for creditors - would probably not be sufficient to bring debt down to manageable levels by 2013, the end of the present ESM. To return to a sustainable position, some debt reduction will be necessary. Instead of trying to fudge the terms of repayments on debts that cannot be repaid, suppose the question is turned around: what level of debt might the periphery economies actually be able to afford to repay? How much would the 'hair cut', of one form or another, have to be to reach a viable level?
For example, cancellation of about a third of the present debts should leave the debt burdens of
Politically, the tensions have also grown. Not only are troubled debtor countries seeing voter resentment build up over the scale of fiscal austerity and persistently weak economic conditions, but those countries providing the bailout funds are also restive. This was perfectly illustrated by the electoral gains made by anti-bail-out parties such as the True Finns, and the loss of support for the ruling coalition in
In addition, there could be trouble brewing in EU relations with the IMF, the Eurozone's bail-out partner, as its terms of engagement in financial assistance are constrained - bail-out terms must be adhered to, loans must be repaid and it cannot offer lower interest rates on the funds made available. There may also be disagreements about progress on budgets and reforms and policy options - which could become more difficult to manage given the likely departure of Strauss-Kahn as head of the IMF. If additional assistance is to be granted to debtors, then the Eurozone may find that it has to provide all of the new funding itself. This could also be a financial challenge if the cost of bail-outs continues to escalate.
A Realistic Endgame?
For the Eurozone, the imperative for all member states must be to reduce debts to sustainable levels while ensuring that reforms put economies on a sound footing to achieve future growth. But more must be done to collectively contain the risks posed by the periphery debtors. First of all, an injection of realism is necessary. Over-optimistic projections for the speed and scale of reforms and fiscal adjustment will lead to the debilitating experience of persistent failures. This is unlikely to ensure a return to capital markets for periphery governments.
Secondly, excessive debt must be recognised as uncontrollable by fiscal austerity alone. In the case of
And thirdly, simply extending existing emergency financing arrangements, either in maturity or scale, may only make political tensions within
The reluctance of the Eurozone leadership to contemplate the 'R' word (restructuring) may be due to concern that easier terms for debt will simply encourage both a return to laxity and more requests for debt relief. But the risk of moral hazard and debt games cannot hold back a final resolution of the debt dilemma forever. The ultimate endgame will simply be default for countries with uncontrollable debts. And the prudent parts of the Eurozone may be unable to finesse either the timing or the impacts of any default. It may be better to settle early and decisively.
- Back to the Pre-American World
- Washington Says It's Not Scared by China's Inroads in Latin America
- The Middle East: The Persian Illusion
- China: New Incentives?
- A Low in Cycle of United States - Pakistan Ties
- Pakistan and Afghanistan: A Tangled Knot
- Defense Policy: After Pakistan
- Defense Policy: International Terrorism Narrative Shift
- Defense Policy: The Changing Debate
- Libyan Intervention Displays Complexities of a United European Foreign Policy
- Europe: Multicultural Europe?
- Europe: No Happy Anniversary
- Bosnia: Crisis Averted?
- Serbo - Croat Relations: Addressing Injustice
- Betraying Israel
- The Scapegoat Syndrome
- The Latest Futility: New President, Same Middle East
- A Political Vision for Israel
- 3 Ongoing Conflicts You May Not Be Paying Attention To But Should
- Visegrad: A New European Military Force
- Turkey Setting Poor Example for Other Arab Nations
- IMF's Crisis-Management Challenge
- Dominique Strauss-Kahn Scandal an Embarrassment for France
- Going Cold on Bin Laden
- Chinese Investors Are Coming to Latin America
- Bin Laden's Death a Rorschach Test for the World
- Tough Times for Radical Islam
- China No. 1 in Five Years? Not so Soon
- Global Demography: Population Inflation
- Smallpox Threat Resurrected
- What's Next for al-Qaeda?
- Bin Laden's Death and U.S. Afghan Policy
- Engineering Programs React to Japan Nuclear Crisis
- Syria: At A Crossroads
- Iran: Authority Deficit
- NATO: Lessons From Libya
- United Kingdom: Forged In The Crucible Of Austerity
- United Kingdom: Democracy As Conflict Prevention
- United Kingdom: Military Defense Test Case
- British Defense Policy: MoD Mess
- United States - Pakistani Relations Beyond Bin Laden
- Bin Laden Death Raises Big National Security Questions
- Where the United States Goes from Here
- Welcome to Paybackistan
- Osama Bin Laden: Got Him!
- Will Bin Laden Death Affect Afghan Exit Timetable?
- Pakistan Unaware of Osama bin Laden Presence? Don't Believe It
- Congress Praises Obama and Troops After Bin Laden Death
- Strategic Implications of Osama bin Laden's Death
- Europe: No Happy Anniversary
- Final Letter to Osama bin Laden
- Justice Has Been Done
- President Obama on Osama Bin Laden
- Bin Laden and the Return of Common Sense
- Osama Bin Laden Dead
- Osama bin Laden Aftermath
- The Future of the Liberal World Order
- Why DOHA Trade Negotiations Are Doomed and What We Should Do About It
- Who's Afraid of the International Criminal Court?
- 5 Economies Worse Off Than the United States
- The Rise of the Islamists
- The Black Swan of Cairo
- Understanding the Middle East Revolutions of 2011
- Parsing the Differences Between Tunisia, Egypt and Libya
- The Heirs of Nasser
- Terrorism After the Arab Revolutions
- Egypt Can't Seem To Shed Bad Habits
- How Hosni Mubarak's Reign Came to an End
- Libya: The Two Obamas
- How to Save the Euro and the European Union
- Recalibrating Homeland Security
- Getting the Military Out of Pakistani Politics
- Power and Politics in an Autonomous Latin America
- The Sacred and the Dead
- China and the End of the Deng Dynasty
- United States - Pakistan Partnership in Peril
- Islamist Militancy in a Pre- and Post-Saleh Yemen
- Iraq, Iran and the Next Move
- World's Most Dangerous Man? Syrian Leader Makes Strong Case
- A View from Syria
- Libya and Beyond: Why not Every Nation for Itself?
- Confidence Remains Strong in Global Markets Despite Crises
- Latin America Provides Cautionary Tale for Middle East
- The Arab Risings, Israel and Hamas
- America Should Exercise Pragmatic Idealism in the Arab World
- Richard Goldstone Recants His Report Attacking Israel
- Middle East: Autocratic Deafness
- A Brave Libyan Stands Up Against Rape
- Is Pacific Fish Safe to Eat After the Disaster in Japan?
- Demand and Disasters Complicate Global Energy Picture
- Global Arms Trade: A Vortex of Death and Wealth
- Arms Trade: a Filter, Not a Dam
- Organised Crime: Joint Responsibility
- It's Time, Mr. President: A Time for Clarity
- Chances for a New US Foreign Policy Not Taken
- Did the United States Give Up on Libya?
- The Gulf Region: Anger Management
- Saudi Arabia: Guarding The Fortress
- Israel's Recent Political Actions Aren't Going Over Well
- Israel: If Not Now, When?
- A 'Reverse Beauty Pageant' for Tyrants
- African Hydropower: Damming at What Cost?
- United States - Pacific Relations: Pacific-Minded
- 7 Problems That Could Derail the Global Economic Recovery
- Technology Powers Revolutions and Saves Lives
- Russia Stocks Soar on Rising Oil Prices
- Japan: Heavy History
- China: Weak Impetus for Change
- China Sees the Evil of Plastic Bags
- Pakistan: Educating For Tolerance
- Immaculate Intervention: The Wars of Humanitarianism
- AQAP and the Vacuum of Authority in Yemen
- Japan Quake and Tsunami Among Most Costly of All Time
- China's Economy the Key to Quelling Social Unrest
- Syria's Stalled Revolution
- Prudent Multilateralism in Libya
- The Thinly Veiled Campaign for Regime Change
- Unexpected Revelations in Libyan Intervention
- President Obama's Most Amazing Libyan Achievements
- Libya: Insanity Dawn
- Obama's Half-a-Loaf War
- Obama Said He Doesn't Mind Criticism on Libya Mission in Latin America
- What Happened to the American Declaration of War?
- The Power of Giving Back
- Safety on the Cheap
- Egyptian Elections: the Sooner, the Better
- The Libyan Question: What Now?
- Obama's 'Goldilocks' Doctrine
- War Number Three
- Un-Unified Oppositions in Bahrain and Yemen
- Japanese Earthquake Brings Back Sad Memories
- 5 Reasons Investors Should Not Bail on Japan
- Japan's Nuclear Crisis Reignites Safety Debate
- Military Involvement in Libya Costs Taxpayers Millions
- United Nations Relevance
- A Mother's Confession on Mothers' Day
- Middle East Crisis: Today's Events in the Middle East
- World's Costliest Disaster
- Japan Crisis: Video Reports 3/23/2011
Available at Amazon.com:
Copyright 2011, Chatham House; Distributed by TRIBUNE MEDIA SERVICES, INC.