Free the College Football Market
The burlesque show that is college football has gone about as far as it can go. Each fall it arrives clothed in garments of academic integrity (the players are scholar-athletes, don't you know) only to peel them off one at a time as the year goes on.
College football pretends it's about boola-boola, but it's really all about ka-ching ka-ching.
Recent months have seen a wave of scandals hit one big-time program after another, with traditional powers like the University of Southern California, the University of Alabama, Auburn University, Ohio State, and North Carolina State either censured or about to be. All involved payments to players in one form or another.
Yet even while asserting the sport's essential innocence, college presidents and athletic directors began a game of musical chairs trying to rearrange college football conferences so that their respective schools could dip deeper into the river of television money that flows through campuses. Traditional rivalries, geographic proximity, and common sense all went by the wayside in the money grab. And it isn't over yet.
The University of Michigan, a not atypical athletic powerhouse, recently spent a quarter of a billion (that's with a b) dollars to renovate its 84-year-old football stadium. This is in addition to building a new indoor football practice facility to replace the old one, as well as adding a recruiting center, a basketball practice facility, a baseball stadium, and a matching softball field. Did I mention the new soccer field or the renovations of the ice hockey and basketball arenas?
It all demands money, and football is the big -- in some cases only -- dollar magnet on the athletic scene.
What makes it such a brilliant business plan is that they don't have to pay the players. Oh, the athletic departments buy the "student-athletes" scholarships and say that's the equivalent of pay for players.
Except that the education many of the athletes receive isn't worth the price of a movie ticket.
Colleges take a Republican view of things.
That means anything the corporations do to make money is fine and dandy, while anything the workers do is greedy and possibly illegal.
Howard Cosell, the great if sometimes obnoxious sports journalist, once said:
"The last thing in the world a college or university should be concerned with is being No. 1 in football or basketball if the price one pays for that is the corruption of character and the undermining of true student morale on campus."
Robert Maynard Hutchins, the president of the University of Chicago at the time, said essentially the same thing in fewer words when he had his school drop football in 1939.
"Football," he explained, "has the same relation to education that bullfighting has to agriculture."
His old school has since taken up football again, though now at a truly amateur level, Division III. Hardly anyone goes to the games but they have great cheers. The New York Times recently relayed this splendid example:
The Peloponnesian War,
Who for? What for?
Who we gonna yell for?
Now that's a cheer alumni can be proud of.
They say you can't pay college players because you'd then have to pay all athletes on campus, which would be unaffordable. That's probably true.
The solution, however, (short of following Chicago's lead) is capitalism.
Let boosters, supporters, shoe companies, whoever, pay the kids over the table.
Some athletes would play for the money, some for the love of the game, others for the education. The most zealous of fans would have a sense of helping their schools without feeling guilty. What you would lose in amateurism you would more than gain in honesty.
You either believe in free-market capitalism or you don't
- Originally published by Other Words
- Free the College Football Market
- Arizona Fires Football Coach Mike Stoops After 1-5 Start
- Purdue Looks to Redefine Season After Blowout of Minnesota
- Former Big 12 Commissioner Dan Beebe Wanted Revenue Sharing Deal
- Crimson Tide Demolish Vanderbilt in SEC Clash
- LSU 'Ware' Out Florida in Rout
- Oklahoma Sooners Rout Texas in Red River Rivalry
- Boyd's TD Pass and Scoring Run Power Clemson Over Boston College
- Boise State Continues Mastery Over Fresno State
- Purdue Bounces Back Routs Minnesota
- Ohio State Buckeyes Search for Offense in First Trip to Nebraska
- Landry Jones Looks to Lead Sooners Past Texas in Big River Rivalry
- Big 12 Presidents Approve Revenue Sharing in Effort to Save Conference
- Despite Violations Gee Still Sees Ohio State as Model Program
- Ohio State Football Again in Hot Water with NCAA
- LSU Sustains Dominance: Gets More Potent with Jordan Jefferson
- Alabama Crushes Florida 38-10
- Notre Dame Extends Winning Streak with Pounding of Purdue
- Jordan Jefferson Returns as Second-Ranked LSU Throttles Kentucky
- No Slip Up This Time as Boise State Routs Nevada
- Michigan Marches On: Undefeated Wolverines Roar Past Minnesota
- Vincent Smith's Versatility Sparks Michigan's Shellacking of Minnesota
- No. 16 South Florida's Perfect Mark Dashed; Pitt Routs Bulls
- LSU Tackles Kentucky in Week 5; Sooners Seek to Regain Top Spot
- Big Bucks to See Ohio State Buckeyes
- MAC Commissioner Says Toledo Loss to Syracuse Has to Stand
- College Football: Oklahoma and LSU Lead Winners in Week 4
- Brandon Weeden Guides Oklahoma State Past Texas A&M
- Rees-pect: QB Rallies Irish to Victory Over Pittsburgh
- Bring on the Buckeyes: Michigan State Ready for Big Ten Opener
- Cincy Bearcats Rout NC State
- Tar Heels QB Bryn Renner Learns Not to Be Perfect
- Wisconsin QB Russell Wilson Trying to Follow in Weinke's Footsteps
- PAC-12 to Remain 12-Team Conference
- Big 12 Conference; Commissioner Dan Beebe Part Ways
- Syracuse Hoops Coach Jim Boeheim Laments Leaving Big East Behind
- Texas Quarterback Gilbert Out Remainder Of Season
- Michigan QB Shows Weaknesses Despite Being Dangerous With the Ball
- Tar Heels Football To Vacate Wins and Cut Scholarships
- Bruised and Battered Buckeyes Badly Beaten by Miami Hurricanes
- LSU Defense Thwarts Mississippi State
- Big 12 Teetering on Edge of Disintegration
- NCAA Hits Boise State with Probation
- Ohio State Lacking Depth with Injuries and Suspensions
- No. 2 LSU, third-ranked Alabama Romps Highlight Week Two
- Ohio State Survives Scare from Toledo
- Michigan State Piles Up Yards in Lopsided Win Over Florida Atlantic
- Arizona State Overcomes Late Surge Stuns Mizzou In Overtime
- ACC Considering Raising Buyout Amount If Teams Want to Leave Conference
- Legal Loopholes Hamper Texas A&M's Move to SEC
- Mistake-prone Oregon falls to LSU in Opener
- Michigan State Lineman Sets Ambitious Goals in Pursuit Of Big Ten Title
- SEC Presidents Set To Meet About Possible Texas A&M Move
Copyright © 2011 iHaveNet.com