'Flexicurity' is under strain and generous Nordic welfare states are getting meaner
When the global financial crisis began to gather pace in 2007, policymakers around the world scrambled for ideas that would lead them out of the mire. The Nordic countries' apparent resilience to the storm attracted much admiration and curious officials swamped the region seeking elements they could poach.
Outside the region the Nordic model and its Danish derivative, 'flexicurity' -- a portmanteau of labour flexibility and social security -- still have their fans. Earlier this year,
In public at least, Nordic political leaders still profess their faith in the template. 'The Nordic welfare model has shown its worth precisely by being able to withstand economic times of pressure and at the same time taking care of the vulnerable in society,' said
But while the countries agreed that the Nordic welfare model has demonstrated its strength as a shield against the global financial crisis there were also indications that the model was in urgent need of adjustment.
'There is no way of combining an overstretched public economy with a generous welfare state. You have to do what is necessary to make the welfare state work, and this is where the universal responsibility of the individual comes into the picture,' Katainen said.
This was a broadside against those who believe that the welfare state is obliged to underwrite every aspect of a citizen's life.
But though the notion of a 'cradle-to-grave' welfare system is still bandied about, the reality is that it has long since been on the wane and its demise is actually accelerating.
As leader of a conservative party, it is no surprise that Katainen is focused on trimming welfare excess and balancing budgets. But the same trend is evident in those Nordic countries with social democratic prime ministers --
And nowhere is the welfare-paring more evident than
They didn't get it. Instead, one of the new government's first acts was to sign a budget deal with the centre-right that included cutting the time limit on unemployment pay from four years to two.
While this has since been softened somewhat by emergency measures for the first six months of 2013, up to 20,000 unemployed Danes could be left without any financial assistance from the state in coming months.
Trade union leaders thunder that slashing benefits is undermining the Nordic welfare model and slowly strangling flexicurity.
This peculiarly Danish twist on the Nordic model relies on three pillars for its success: flexibility, employers can hire and fire at will; social security, fired workers receive good benefits; and active labour policies, measures to help the jobless back to work.
Besides public policy initiatives, flexicurity is also being squeezed by other forces. Take Scandinavian Airlines System, the struggling airline that is 50 per cent owned by the governments of
As well as plans to shed 40 per cent of its 15,000 workforce through lay-offs and divestments, SAS took the unprecedented step of tearing up its pay-and-conditions agreements with 35 trade unions. Captains and crew contested the legality of this unilateral action saying it under-mined the Nordic model by disregarding a century-old tradition of labour market consensus.
For all their outward devotion to the Nordic model, the airline's largest shareholders -- the three Scandinavian governments, all backed the SAS plan.
Something similar occurred in
As liberal politicians and free market supporters, neither
Finance Minister, could have been expected to intervene to save
Though they had campaigned to tweak the model rather than remove it, and Borg in particular has won many plaudits for his steadying hand on economic and fiscal policy,
Change has been gradual in
Given Borg's recent warning that a slump in exports might well trigger an economic downturn in the near future, there is little reason to expect
- European Union Gives Peace a Chance
- Great Britain: The Great Power Hangover
- Scotland: We'll Take The High Road
- Scotland: Would Holyrood Pay for Independence in Euros?
- The Nordic Model: Q&A with Håkan Tribell
- Lessons From Our Nordic Friends in the North
- The Art of Cutting the Welfare State
- Sweden: No Wonder Wallander's Depressed
- BP bounces back in Russia
- As Hollande Struggles, So Does the Opposition
- Mimicking Breivik in Poland
- Turkish Economy Meets EU Entrance Criteria
- Spain: Catalonia and Romantic Nationalism
- Spain's Economic Crisis is Different
- Europe Loses its Chinese Cheerleader
- Europe is Divided Again: This Time It's Creditors vs Debtors
- Europe: The Politics of Fear
- Britain Must Engage with a Multi-Tier European Union
- Russia Struggles to Exert Influence in a Weakened Europe
- Russia's Internet Censorship: Not as Bad As It Looks
- Congratulations, Europe, on Winning the Nobel Peace Price
- French Favor Obama -- Which Shows They Have Much to Learn
- Would a Stronger European Federation Even Help?
- Britain's Backup Plan
- Is Putin the Russian Reagan?
- Fear and Loathing on the Streets of Athens
- How Football Continues to Influence Spanish and Italian Politics
- Breakup of Euro Would Be 'Cardiac Arrest' for Europe
- 'All the Choices are Ugly' for Europe
- European Leadership is Limp, But Merkel on Steroids is Not the Answer
- A Date with History: Germany's 1990 Re-Unification
- Tensions Between Germany and Greece Run Deep
- Germany Must Shift from Crisis Agenda to Positive Political Agenda for Europe
- Breakdown of British Euroscepticism
- Geopolitics is an Existential Issue for Poland
(c) 2012 Tribune Media Services