The lessons to be learnt from a British debacle that cost an Afghan king his reputation and his life
During a news conference with
No one who reads
Karzai, like Shah Shuja, faces irreconcilable dilemmas, many of which are unchanged since the 1840s.
The fate of the 'king who returned' offers a harsh lesson to Afghan leaders. To this day Shah Shuja is 'a symbol of quisling treachery' in
Dalrymple, a writer and historian known for his interest in the Indian sub-continent, points to the many striking parallels between the invasion of 1839 –42 and the invasion of the Americans and their allies in 2001. Both put individuals acceptable to the invaders -- astonishingly, from the same Popalzai subtribe -- in power. Many of the battles in both wars are in the same places, with the same tribal alignments. Foreign understanding of
Dalrymple tells a cracking good story, drawing upon new British, Indian, Russian and, above all, 'elusive' Afghan sources, including contemporary accounts and epic poems. The result is a captivating picture of one of the most foolhardy exercises in British imperial history, viewed through the eyes not just of British military and
Diplomats, soldiers and development workers in
But Dalrymple sometimes risks taking the analogy too far. He clearly loves the country, and his exasperation with the current intervention is understandable. But there are important differences.
Afghans enjoy conspiracies, and many are convinced that the Americans want to control their country. But this underplays the importance of 9/11 as the trigger for the invasion, the significance to the West of Al-Qaeda's use of Afghan territory and, many would argue, the reduced strategic importance of
While the current foreign intervention may be foolhardy -- it has been described as an attempt to build a Westphalian state on top of a tribal society -- it has brought some dividends for the Afghans, including upgraded infrastructure, improved health, more girls' education, awareness of rights and the experience of freedom of expression. And as reformists point out, the 'good governance' agenda has century-long Afghan roots; it would be patronizing not to acknowledge this.
This intervention has also brought more cronyism and corruption, empowered warlords and criminals, and spread uncertainty among the Afghans about the future. From an Afghan perspective, security is deteriorating.
The issue now, as military withdrawal gathers momentum, is whether the West has the appetite and sense of responsibility to support the Afghans after foreign combat troops depart. If it does, and it is smart about using the many levers at its disposal, notably money and political influence in the region, then a transition is possible, one that will be far less violent and chaotic than the British debacle 170 years ago.
As Return of a King so powerfully underscores, foreign engagement, if it is not to end in waste and disaster, must be on terms acceptable to the Afghans. This requires listening to the Afghans, and greater national consensus among them on key issues -- the nature of the law, economic and social priorities and how power is distributed between the centre and provinces, and between the state and more traditional sources of authority.
None of this will be easy. Foreigners, by their actions, can make things worse, or contribute to the conditions that will make peaceful succession possible. Afghan leadership will be critical; it must be seen as sovereign, and legitimate. The 2014 elections, and how the international community supports them, really matter.
Dalrymple depicts Shah Shuja as far more competent, loyal and brave than Afghans today recognize, successfully manipulating different factions, retaining tribal loyalties against the odds and managing contradictory and humiliating foreign demands. This book should mark the return of the King's reputation.
History may judge
- Bizarre Belligerence on the Korean Peninsula
- Considering a Departure in North Korea's Strategy
- United States, South Korea Ready to Counter North Korean Aggression
- Philippines Hopes Better Credit Rating Will Draw Investors
- Basketball Diplomacy, Pyongyang Style
- Is International Pressure Failing in Sri Lanka?
- Georgia's Armed Forces: Army of the All or Army of the Few?
- China Begins Efforts to Lift Veil on Officials' Assets
- New Internet Regulations Provide Window into North Korea
- New Faces, Old Tensions in East Asia
- India's Middle-Class Dilemma
- India: Misogyny in Bollywood
- North Korea May Have Finally Gone Too Far
- Chinese Silk Railroad Ambitions
- Keeping The Dream on Track
- Lessons from William Dalrymple's 'Return of a King'
- Indonesia Tries 'Cloud Seeding' to Prevent Flooding in Jakarta
- Six Australian Rugby Teams Investigated for PED Use
- 30 Million Pilgrims Take Holy Dip at India's Kumbh Mela
- Spiritual Guru Launches 'Volunteer for a Better India' Campaign
- Why Civil Registration Matters in Asia
- China: When Soft Power Fails
- Powering the Pacific 'Pivot' With Leon and Chuck
- Dark Days for Okinawa
- North Korean Nuclear Test Could Worsen China Relations
- South Korea to Implement New UN Sanctions Against North Korea
- Korea: The Case for Withdrawal
- Ferocious, Weak and Crazy: The North Korean Strategy
- Pakistan Coming Apart at the Seams
- Afghanistan Bribes Totaled Nearly $4 Billion
- The Long Struggle for Moro Autonomy in the Philippines
- Despite Increasing Prosperity, Vietnam's Appetites Remain Unique
- Food Security Still Major Issue in Southeast Asia
- Vietnam is a Country to Watch
- Continued American Presence in Afghanistan Recipe for More Disaster
- China Bans Ads for Luxury Goods
- Fresh Outbreak of Nipah Virus in Bangladesh
- Economists Optimistic About China's 2013 Outlook
- United Nations Calls for North Korea Human Rights Inquiry
- Time to End the Korean War
- India Orders 'Aggressive' Response to Kashmir Provocation
- Political Rally Shuts Down Pakistani Capital
Copyright © 2013 Tribune Media Services, Inc. "Lessons from William Dalrymple's 'Return of a King'"